Pepper's Pizza & Subs

814 Theodore St, Scranton
(570) 341-7511

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dale Nat

Only tried their pizza and wings twice, so I can only rate the food and not the service or atmosphere. I used Door Dash both times and was amazed by the way my “work of art” - the American Cheesy pizza! Take note of char spots on the cheese. It added flavor and crispness to a lovely cheese and sauce combination. My only regret is I did not experience it there. Look forward to my first visit in person. If you take a look at the photo with my complete take out order - pizza, wings and the fried ravioli it all tasted wonderful and complimented each other. Now, back to the American Cheesy, since the cheese would run down the wall if I hung it up, need to print out one of these photos for the foodie wall! This pizza definitely stands out amongst others and is worthy of a try! Definitely recommend their food and of course the American Cheesy even though they have so many great offerings.

Richard Montanya

Really good food and wings

Moses moustafa

Always fresh and delicious
We picked up our food for a movie date night .
Wonderful staff and service

Tom Sanders

Food was great will be coming back.

Jen Schuback

Food is decent, but service kinda stinks. We had a pretty large order (12 people) where 1 family members order was missing. We weren't mad, it happens, called to ask for a refund on the 1 item. They said they don't do that and we had to drive all the way back to the restaurant to get the missing food. They were not even sorry and acted annoyed at our phone call. We probably won't go back.

Robert Peacock

Love the video game vibes at Pepper's. I couldn't wait to try the Taco Pizza because the description was amazing. It wasn't what I expected. It was SO MUCH BETTER. There was so much flavor and so much pizza. The folks at the shop were outgoing and friendly as well. I won't mind going a little out of my way for Pepper's pizza.

Heather Czachor

Great selection.

Joey Dee

Saturday night they are open till 1030 but they stopped taking orders at 9:15. Then why not just close at 9:15 you just lost a fairly regular customer
Ridiculous won’t take my order at quarter of. You’re open for 45 more minutes.
Close at 9:15 what the hell are you doing for the other hour and 15 minutes taking phone calls and you’re open?
And you know what your pizza was very inconsistent
Your boils were good, but you just lost a customer. You may not care but we moved here a few months ago and we’ve eaten there a lot…, no mo

Glenn Marshall

Amazing food and service. Try the double crust cheese steak pizza. It's outstanding!

Elizabeth Cyrilla Shaw

Saw a TikTok about the Double Crust Cheesesteak Pizza and just had to try. They were super friendly and the pizza was delicious. Will be a repeat customer!

Kenneth Ginanni

Great double crusted cheesesteak and pizza!

Laura Lett

It was my first time eating at Pepper's. My son and I had mozzarella sticks and a cheese pie. It was great! The pizza 🍕 was fantastic. The crust wasn't dry. Best pizza in the area. It's worth the trip. The staff was very nice too.

Ander Pindzola

Mostly a takeout place but we dined in. Good friendly service and great Italian Boli.

Brittany Adams

Ordered pick up
Everything was delicious 😋
Wings are always 100%

Carrie Andrews

Delicious pizza! Found a hidden gem I didn’t know existed.

Loading...