Country Creamery

3694 PA-204, Selinsgrove
(570) 374-3700

Recent Reviews

Sort by
David Van Benthuysen

Fantastic place with great, quick food. Service is super friendly and prices are reasonable. Absolutely amazing ice cream!

Bb

Went earlier today to have a mini date with my boyfriend before I went to work (night shift). The environment is cute and welcoming, it's a lot larger on the inside than it looks on the outside.

The food is definitly made to order, we had cheese fries, mozzarella sticks, their country burger, and mushroom swiss burger. My boyfriend had a small soft serve of their peach flavor and I got the baby size cup of soft serve chocolate. Not overly sweet, and the baby size was the perfect size if you are looking to fill your craving for ice cream but not feel too full after eating.

We live locally and it was our first time dining in, it's affordable, local, and great quality food. I *highly* recommend visiting for a sweet treat, or a tasty made to order meal.

They have a window service too if you want something for on the go or to just enjoy outside or in your car. The staff are kind, their is ample parking space (unless there is a lunch/dinner rush of course from what I hear) and the place is kept very clean and tidy.

We definitly plan on coming back and if we can, bring friends and family along too.

Chris\u0026Katie Moore

We were trying to find an ice cream place but most were closed. We stumbled upon this place and the ice cream was pretty good. My husband got the Fluffer Nutter and said it was amazing.

The staff seemed to be a little short with customers but it could be because they were trying to take care of everyone before closing. They did seem to get the ice cream out pretty quick, we only waited maybe 10 minutes if that for ours and we had alot of people in front of us.

Darryl Dash

Good food, but they charge more than the prices on the menu. Cheesesteak was supposed to be $7 but was charged $9.

Brian Brouse

Great homemade hand crafted hand dipped and soft ice cream. Amazing and the best in Central PA.

Steven Fischer

Worth Every Mile!
My girls had been begging me to take them to The Country Creamery after hearing all the hype about the Moonbeam ice cream. I was hesitant about the hour-long drive… but WOW, am I glad we went. The ice cream is unbelievably creamy and packed with flavor — and finding out they only use Pennsylvania dairy just took it to the next level.

I tried the Black Licorice ice cream (who knew that was even a thing?!) and it was absolutely incredible. Unique, rich, and perfectly balanced. You can tell everything here is made with care and quality.

Totally worth the trip — we’ll definitely be back! 🍦

Asher Corman

Truly Exceptional Ice Cream – Worth Every Second!

The Country Creamery is hands-down some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had in my life. Every flavor is unique, rich, and clearly made with love and care. You can taste the freshness—everything is farm to cone, and it makes all the difference. Yes, there can be a bit of a wait, but trust me, it’s 100% worth it. This place is seriously incredible and absolutely a must-visit for any ice cream lover.

Kristen Miller

Their icecream is very good, but unfortunately not worth waiting 45 minutes to get it.

Ashley Miller

The homemade icecream deserves a 5 star but the reason for my rating is due to the 45 minute wait we had. It was 8 o'clock pm. which is usually a busy time for icecream shops but I still feel the orders could have been completed faster.

Kayla Bloch

I went last night with friends and at first there we only saw 2 people working and we came 30 minutes before we closed. After we ordered, we waited 45 minutes to get our ice cream, and only to find out there were 4 or 5 workers there cleaning while one boy was serving over 15 people. The girl taking orders messed many orders up and the manager was taking it out on the boy serving it. Everyone was in there laughing and trying to get things closed while the poor boy was making stuff all by himself. We gave the boy an extra tip because we felt so bad. It was ridiculous that no one helped him and they couldn’t even get the orders right.

June Becker

Great Food family restaurant…
That just happens to make AWESOME
ICE CREAM…😉🙂.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Danielle Wilbert

the homemade ice cream is to die for! We got a variety of all the Easter flavors. the Robin's egg is my favorite, but toasted white chocolate strawberry is definitely a close second 🩷

John Becker

My wife and I where there this afternoon I had the best crab cakes I've had in a very long time. They said homemade they were exactly that. 👍👍👍👍👍

Jackie Kline

The best food around. The Creamery is the best place to eat , fellowship, work, or grab a sweet treat. You will not find more loving, caring people. I cannot recommend them enough.

Mary Horning

Delicous, creamy soft serve ice cream

Loading...