Coming from NYC this is very close to that pizza. Excellent sauce, gooey melted cheese, just right amount of spices. Great prices. They even do Nutella celebration pizzas in shapes. Only the interior is a little old and outdated. But nice outdoor patio seating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Slice of Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Keven Hebert
All the way from Québec. We loved it
Jeff Manross
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
d Shaffer
The food is good just be prepared to have kids toys in the dining room and kids yelling and screaming other than that a very nice place to have a good slice of
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Slice of Cheese Pizza
Rebekah Hassinger
The Stromboli we had order was perfect, but we had gotten a meduim pizza and it was raw and cold on the bottom.
Food: 2
Michael J. Burns
BUDGET LOVE, At OIP Express in Selinsgrove, you can grab a quick pizza that tastes gourmet. You get two slices and a medium drink for $6.95, which is pretty budget friendly. They have a variety of toppings, even for those who like pineapple on their pizza.It's a laid-back place where the staff are friendly. You can have a chat while you wait for your pizza, and it doesn't feel rushed. If your order happens to be incorrect by any chance, they'll treat you like family to make it right.Overall, OIP Express is a good spot for an easy meal that feels a bit like you're just hanging out at a friend's house. It's nice when you want some good pizza without any fuss.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Blain (1nsane0wnag3)
Food always thrown together, delivery orders always wrong. Do selingrove a favor and shutdown for something respectable.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Gunnar Nielsen
This place is what other O.I.P. restaurants should strive to emulate. The service is great, the make ulyou feel like an old friend, warm and inviting. The food OMG...... I have not had anything that wasn't great. It's not good, but great. Pizza, yes, subs, yes, wings,yes all good. I've only been going in for the last few months now, but lunch regularly and they never disappoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Cheesecake, OIP Burger, Slice of Cheese Pizza, Italian Sub, Buffalo Wings, Sicilian Pizza, Cheesesteak, Chef Salad, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Calzone Medium, Fries
Chris Muncer
Consistently good food and a wide variety of it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Sub, Sicilian Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Calzone Medium
Stephen Groner
Do not order pizza from OIP in selinsgrove!! Your order will not be made properly and you will be overcharged. You would think a pizza place could get a pepperoni and extra cheese pizza right. Wrong!! And I’ll add very greasy and overcooked!! They have been so generous in taking care of the matter with 10% off my next order. Keep it I will not be ordering any longer from OIP. Lazy and unacceptable. Both the food and the service.
Worst experience ever delivery driver left food on trash can and refused refund would not recommend ever
Brady Fries
I'm sad to have seen the old ownership no longer in management. I can tell a major difference in product and service. I recently called to play an order for pickup and halfway through the phone call, it seemed the individual taking the order got yelled at, placed the phone down, and a new voice picked up and said "Hey" and "where were you with your order." Rather than letting the individual who was more than halfway through taking the order, I received food that was incorrect. When I ask for a sub with just lettuce and mayonnaise, I don't expect OIL. This was disappointing as my sub was saturated with oil. On a side note, we had recently ordered a stromboli the other week, the sauce doesn't taste the same, the bread seemed sour/uncooked. Maybe I'll try again later in the year, but this was disappointing.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Tabitha Sellars castle
Worst experience ever delivery driver left food on trash can and refused refund would not recommend ever
Kaleh Gersd
Friendly staff, and the food is delicious ?
A p x
I ordered a small cheesesteak for takeout. The guy told me 20 minutes it would be done. I arrive and they can't find my order when I called. I showed them the number that I called and the time. The lady that was making the food was irritated and kind of made it seem like I was in the wrong when it clearly was them. I told them don't worry about I couldn't wait for them to figure out what happened. If you don't like you job to the lady that was working tonight abound 5:50 pm May 8th, 2023 do something about. I wasn't the one that screwed up it was fellow coworkers.
Coming from NYC this is very close to that pizza. Excellent sauce, gooey melted cheese, just right amount of spices. Great prices. They even do Nutella celebration pizzas in shapes. Only the interior is a little old and outdated. But nice outdoor patio seating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Slice of Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
All the way from Québec. We loved it
Great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is good just be prepared to have kids toys in the dining room and kids yelling and screaming other than that a very nice place to have a good slice of
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Slice of Cheese Pizza
The Stromboli we had order was perfect, but we had gotten a meduim pizza and it was raw and cold on the bottom.
Food: 2
BUDGET LOVE, At OIP Express in Selinsgrove, you can grab a quick pizza that tastes gourmet. You get two slices and a medium drink for $6.95, which is pretty budget friendly. They have a variety of toppings, even for those who like pineapple on their pizza.It's a laid-back place where the staff are friendly. You can have a chat while you wait for your pizza, and it doesn't feel rushed. If your order happens to be incorrect by any chance, they'll treat you like family to make it right.Overall, OIP Express is a good spot for an easy meal that feels a bit like you're just hanging out at a friend's house. It's nice when you want some good pizza without any fuss.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food always thrown together, delivery orders always wrong. Do selingrove a favor and shutdown for something respectable.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
This place is what other O.I.P. restaurants should strive to emulate. The service is great, the make ulyou feel like an old friend, warm and inviting. The food OMG...... I have not had anything that wasn't great. It's not good, but great. Pizza, yes, subs, yes, wings,yes all good. I've only been going in for the last few months now, but lunch regularly and they never disappoint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Cheesecake, OIP Burger, Slice of Cheese Pizza, Italian Sub, Buffalo Wings, Sicilian Pizza, Cheesesteak, Chef Salad, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Calzone Medium, Fries
Consistently good food and a wide variety of it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Sub, Sicilian Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Calzone Medium
Do not order pizza from OIP in selinsgrove!! Your order will not be made properly and you will be overcharged. You would think a pizza place could get a pepperoni and extra cheese pizza right. Wrong!! And I’ll add very greasy and overcooked!! They have been so generous in taking care of the matter with 10% off my next order. Keep it I will not be ordering any longer from OIP. Lazy and unacceptable. Both the food and the service.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Worst experience ever delivery driver left food on trash can and refused refund would not recommend ever
I'm sad to have seen the old ownership no longer in management. I can tell a major difference in product and service. I recently called to play an order for pickup and halfway through the phone call, it seemed the individual taking the order got yelled at, placed the phone down, and a new voice picked up and said "Hey" and "where were you with your order." Rather than letting the individual who was more than halfway through taking the order, I received food that was incorrect. When I ask for a sub with just lettuce and mayonnaise, I don't expect OIL. This was disappointing as my sub was saturated with oil. On a side note, we had recently ordered a stromboli the other week, the sauce doesn't taste the same, the bread seemed sour/uncooked. Maybe I'll try again later in the year, but this was disappointing.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Worst experience ever delivery driver left food on trash can and refused refund would not recommend ever
Friendly staff, and the food is delicious ?
I ordered a small cheesesteak for takeout. The guy told me 20 minutes it would be done. I arrive and they can't find my order when I called. I showed them the number that I called and the time. The lady that was making the food was irritated and kind of made it seem like I was in the wrong when it clearly was them. I told them don't worry about I couldn't wait for them to figure out what happened. If you don't like you job to the lady that was working tonight abound 5:50 pm May 8th, 2023 do something about. I wasn't the one that screwed up it was fellow coworkers.