Papa Johns Pizza

1949 N Susquehanna Trail, Selinsgrove
(570) 743-7474

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Samantha Weyant

Everytime we pick up our orders we are met with the most welcoming guy. Always says hi when you walk in, comes out to hold the door if your hands are full, or brings it to your car if you have kids sleeping in the car. The food is always great too.

matthew Oyster

I felt bad for the employees as we were there a few minutes before opening, the staff was professional and kind giving us a heads up that it’d take a little longer due to the oven heating up. They were quick to make the food and it came out delicious. The place is a bit small and has been the same since I can remember. They have TVs in the dining room area so if you’re waiting or eating there you have some entertainment.

Betty Davis

I had a BBQ chicken papadia tonight it's the best item I ever had from this store.I only wish I would've tried it sooner! Besides the bbq chicken and onions I chose mushrooms in place of the bacon,I'm so glad I did,I'll be ordering it again soon,thank you so much for an awesome dinner🔥👌

Trish Hinkel

Excellent service, very kind employees.

Von K

Very awesome delivery drivers who go above and beyond! Never had a single problem always faster than what the time says. Thank you the pizza is bussin

Dennis Hassinger

Absolutely love this place!!!!! Phenomenal staff and always fresh, hot pizza!!!!

Bethany Houghton

Very quick service and excellent pizza.

Benjamin Miller

The service wasnt bad but the whole place could have been cleaner and the food was pretty decent

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Cheryl Dool

Very good!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Audrey Knepp

Keep the SHAQ a roni pizza. It's the best

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Michelle Melachrinos

I had to order some pizzas for some people for my husband I tried to order it the night before they did a great job with having everything ready but I ended up giving them the wrong time because I was in a hurry they jumped in and went above and beyond and made me completely new pizzas and had them ready there on time fresh ready to go. That was a total blessing for me that I didn't mess up my husband's friends order. Thank you so much

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

connie mentzer

Always Love Papa Johns!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Edward Zablosky

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mikki Anselmo

Papa John’s in Shamokin Dam is one of my favorite places to go because of the people that work there. While the food is good, they go above and beyond to be kind in a world that no longer values that. They are locally owned and operated, which is wonderful because I love to support our local community. If you go there or order from them, you won’t be disappointed. I highly recommend as one of the bright spots in our Community

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rhonda Smith

Loved the Selinsgrove location!!!
Everyone was so nice.
We like to go inside and sit down and eat and this one has lots of seating!
We will be going back!!???

Loading...