Sylvia's Sweet Cakes

1 Susquehanna Valley Mall Dr, Selinsgrove
(570) 374-2619

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jodi Brown

Did not receive what we ordered and the cake did not taste good at all. Texted her multiple times with no response. Went into the store and she just argued with us that we should have brought the cake back. Would not recommend this place at all.

Matt Dickerman

What an amazing experience! I found myself in desperate need of a cake on very short notice. I felt terrible even asking however I was treated wonderfully and ended up with a beautiful, delicious cake. If I could give this place 6 stars I would!

A Princess Curry

My husband and I want to thank you Silvia for taking your time with being dedicated to making our beautiful wedding cake and delicious cupcakes for our special wedding day! It was very delicious and we are truly thankful that we were able to find a local company to support in our area and be able to have a tasting beforehand to ensure we were able to get what we wanted for our wedding day❤️ I highly recommend Silvia sweet cake for anybody special occasion or event and it is extremely delicious and will make your mouth water every bite that you take ♥️❤️💒🎂🙏🏽🤤

Kitty Souder

Our cake was beautiful and delicious! The icing was the perfect amount of sweetness. Will definitely order from Sylvia's again!

Leah Martin

Went in a few days ago got a chocolate cheesecake and a cupcake. Good prices and very good sweets. Definitely do recommend will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

t c

Very very good and well worth the price ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Koters

The only thing Sweeter than the sweets themselves, is the customer service. Please support this local buisness.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Thomas

Absolutely wonderful experience! Miss Sylvia is not only the nicest person, she’s the best baker! On top of INCREDIBLE desserts, when my four year daughters cake pop came off the stick (my daughters fault) as we were paying, Miss Sylvia gave her a new one instantly AND demanded we keep the one that fell off the stick, even though it was still wrapped. I would have left the same review even if she didn’t treat my daughter so well, that was just icing on the cake! Get it? Get it?

Holly Cardell

Love their cupcakes and cakes. So super friendly with hearts of gold. Their prices are very reasonable. Could not ask for better people. If you need cakes or any treats like that visit them in the susquehanna valley mall. You will not be disappointed!

Allen Keister

Cake pops are yummy!

Keenan Hill

Da Cheesecakes are Everything!!!Moved from NJ2PA. Her cakes remind me of home/homemade desserts like ur fav Grandma/Grandpa used to make.I tasted nothing but fresh ingredients and love. Go get a slice it's worth the drive n price, I promise you. On GOD

Martha Bohner

She did a wonderful job making a Corgi cake and it was delicious and beautiful

Loriann Kelleher

Sylvia's Tres le leche cake is the best I've ever eaten! It is absolutely delicious ? Her cake pops and cupcakes are awesome too. If you want a yummy treat, stop here!!!

Barbra Harper

I only recently found Sylvia's, and I have been amazed at how good everything is! The first time we were there, we got a big piece of the tres leches cake, some cake pops, and a cookie. Everything was fabulous. Today, I got a chocolate cupcake with chocolate frosting. I just ate it (with a cup of coffee), and it was hands-down the best cupcake I have ever eaten. The cake was moist and flavorful, and the frosting was absolutely to die for! I don't go to the mall very often, but I may have to start stopping in there more often just to get a treat from Sylvia's. And if I ever need a special occasion cake, I know exactly where I'll be heading!

Sylvia Narvaez

Love all custom cakes and we provide best service. Love all our customers ?‍♀️??

Loading...