Taste of Philly

23 S Water St, Selinsgrove
(570) 374-2940

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mikayla Freed

Not sure what happened, but ever since they closed for a brief time and then reopened their subs have not been the same. They kept the same price, but you’re basically getting HALF of what you used to get and the meat isn’t cut nearly as thick. Was so looking forward to a hoagie after they reopened, but was extremely disappointed with the price and quality.. so upset

Ty R

Was told this location has recently reopened and is under new management. Subs were expensive and cafeteria quality. Apparently it used to be much better, which is where the glowing reviews came from... won't be returning.

dustin carstetter

They need to change the name. It's not the same since new owners taken over. Tried it 3 times after new owners and first 3 times we were disappointed. Many months later I gave it a 4th try and I'm even more disappointed. Change your name! We miss the original owners and the pulled pork. This will be the last time i order. and the guy who took my order was extremely rude. All we wanted was the cheese to be melted on the grilled chicken salad like it use to be. Instead he said they dont do that.. bellas pizza it is...

Michael Depew

I'm sorry to say this has gone down hill with the new owners. My first visit with them with the new owners, my cashier had charged us extra by putting a tip for herself. Mind you we came ourself ordered and took it to go , the bare minimum of effort needed by staff. my 2nd visit today for lunch all the way from my home in harrisburg i was serviced by a "karen" with let em see your manger hair cut. She prepare my food with no hat or hair net which is untold safe. This is my last visit. They took away the option of adding a drink and chips for so much. So every thing is full price.

Linsley Cressinger Gentile

awful. ordered food at 530 and went to pick it up and they were closed. thanks. last time.

Daria Kaminskyj

Spent $50 for 3 sandwiches, (not including tip).

Brittany Yetter

Food was amazing. Service was lacking. Didn't have change in cash drawer for cash paying customers.

Sue Hackman

My ham and cheese cosmo was absolutely amazing!!! Sabrina was super nice and Made our visit a very good one!! We will definitely be back!!

Dan Morris

Great food and amazing service!!! If I could give 10 stars I would!!

Sue Hackman

My ham and cheese cosmo was absolutely amazing!! Not to mention....Sabrina was super nice and made our visit a very good one. Haven’t had good customer service like today’s in a very long time.

Dan Morris

food was amazing and service was great!! I will return again. would recommend to anyone. 10 stars!!

Jeffrey Loomis

Always great food and friendly staff. One of our favorite places to eat in the area. Highly recommend the cheese steak pretzels!

Jeremy Grose

I ordered the Philly cheese steak. It was amazing. I had 1 yesterday at a different local restaurant that was good, but not this good. You must check it out. Came back for lunch again ordered the RUManenough. This was a massive lunch. It was great, fresh, and fast.

Deborah Reevs

One of my favorite places for lunch. Food is always fresh and they don't skimp on quantity. Friendly staff.

Christian Yetter

I ordered a cheesesteak with onions. When I got it, there was no cheese, the onions were cold, the meat was dry. My coworker got a cheesesteak that had cheese on it. You could see the cheese on hers.

Loading...