New York Bagelry
$ • BagelsAbout New York Bagelry
Customers' Favorites
French Toast Bagel with Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese
Blueberry Bagel with Blueberry Cream Cheese
Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Plain Bagel
Bagels with Cream Cheese Bagel
Breakfast Sandwich
Baker's Dozen 14
Bagel Bundle
Muffin
New York Bagelry Reviews
181 ratings
Share your opinion about New York Bagelry
$18 for a baker's dozen??? Are you kiddding me? Remember folks the plain ones are nothing more than flour and water . Plus Sunday mornings expect to wait with the line often to the door due to consistent understaffing. We haven't been there in a while but now find the size of the freezer bags they throw in are now smaller. So pay more and get less? No thank you.
Great place for on the-run to hold you over in the morning, brunch time
The breakfast sandwich bagels are huge! I got 2 thinking I might still be a little hungry after (I came in starving), but I was stuffed after 1.5 of them. Some of the best breakfast sandwiches I’ve had too!
Hours
| Monday | 5:30AM - 6PM |
| Tuesday | 5:30AM - 6PM |
| Wednesday | 5:30AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 5:30AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 5:30AM - 6PM |
| Saturday | 5:30AM - 3PM |
| Sunday | 5:30AM - 3PM |
New York Bagelry is known for its New York-style bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches, along with a variety of fresh bagels and cream cheeses. The friendly staff always serves with a smile, ensuring a wide range of food and drink options. Despite occasional long lines, customers find it worth the wait and appreciate the mom-and-pop bagel shop atmosphere. The pork roll, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel is a popular favorite, described as "perfect every time." Customers have also praised the comfort food-like service, feeling "like they were in her home." The bagels are consistently described as "incredible," with the perfect "tart/sweet combo" in the cream cheese. The "family-friendly hole-in-the-wall place" is a breakfast staple for many, with the "bagel bundle" being a customer favorite, especially the "bee sting" flavor.