Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
10016 Molly Pitcher Hwy, Shippensburg
(717) 532-9886
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Best custard ice cream in the area hands down!
Everyone got sick after eating here, except the one out of five of us that didn’t. 5/10/26.
I attempted to use my gift card, I had put $15 on it a week prior, but I was told that I owed money for my order. It was supposed to have $22 on it, of course using the card at a previous visit was an issue also. I was having a bad day and I was so upset. I am sorry for being emotional, but I put the card on the counter and walked away as my sister paid. I like Rita products but don’t trust going back.
Waste of money wasn't made right what's the point of a gelati if I got more ice than custard
A shippensburg town staple for over 20 years.
Very friendly employee's made exactly how. Like it
Always friendly everything looks clean and they serve you with a smile
Love the custard and the pretzel sticks are awesome!
Tasty options and enjoyed my ice cream.
Very friendly staff and very good Italian ice
Restaurantji Recommends
We had great service and I loved my gelato! The vanilla custard was phenomenal!🤤
I liked the starburst flavor and the staff was pretty kind.
We each got a gelati, I got the mango ice and vanilla custard and he got the strawberry lemonade ice and vanilla custard. Fire combos! Fast and great service
Food: 5
Service: 5
I would love to see more choices for sugar free stuff at every Rita's for the ones who can't do sugar due to diabetes. We only have one choice of sugar free ice would like to see more improvements at Rita's Shippensburg pa.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
My wife and I like stopping by here on occasion for a cool treat in the summer time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Italian Ice
Loading...