During our stay at the Skytop Lodge we had two breakfasts and two dinners in the Windsor room. One breakfast was on the weekend and was a buffet, one we ordered from the menu. Both were great. The buffet was much above average. We had huevos rancheros, potatoes, sausage, smoked salmon, and fresh fruit. The morning we ordered from the menu we had the caprese omelet and the South porch breakfast. The omelet was a little over cooked, but that’s being picky. The flavors were well balanced. For dinners we had the duck duo, pork prime rib, rack of elk, and short rib pappardelle. Words cannot describe how these meals were prepared, the flavors, fats, acids, and spices were all balanced and the presentations were perfect. For appetizers we had the mussels, bison chorizo crostini, and the crab stuffed mushrooms. Again all of the flavors were outstanding. We had no dishes that we didn’t like.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura Jeffer
My husband and I went here for our anniversary. The food was amazing and service impeccable. Highly recommend for a nice dinner out. We're are going back really soon. The restaurant is very elegant.
Masterness Mike
Food was great. Service was very attentive. we had the beef Wellington for two. Had to order 24 hours in advance and totally worth it! Cooked to perfection and super delicious. Definitely revisit .The lodge and the grounds are massive and impressive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Baldassari
We had the Beef Wellington for 2 and it was cooked perfectly. Service was very attentive. All of our food was very flavorful. Amazing property with lots of history and atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Pudding
Paul Larkin
This is e " go too" place when we celebrate anything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pancakes
lindsay green
Chefs kiss to curry noodles w shrimp this weekend. I’m back home and want it over again. Really good. Drinks, sub par.
Dustin Switzer
Had another amazing dinner at Windsor before working in another part of the building. Service was excellent and the venison special was incredible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Luke Andrzejewski
Atmosphere was good service they were doing their best. Location is amazing. Dinner was not good. You could tell they were trying to do something just missed the mark. I took a group of 20 when I sent out a survey monkey on the entire retreat that dinner a lot of bad remarks
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Bill Shafer
Had a nice dinner here at 10–18
Abbi K
We went for the valentine’s day special menu, the food was excellent but unfortunately we had a horrible server, Terry, who made the entire experience very underwhelming. never once did she check on us or ask how everything was. between the bartender, the server’s assistant and and manager, they were basically doing all the work. it was not a busy night there were about 6 tables there including us and her service was terrible. not a personable person by any means and we were just another table she had to be bothered with. brought us an incorrect bill in the end and never bothered to come back, we had to ask someone else with assistance on getting it fixed. we really enjoyed the food but it was very unfortunate to have such poor service at such a nice place.
Went for breakfast, dinner, and buffet dinner (thanksgiving dinner). Breakfast buffet was better last year, now its similar to what you would find at a hilton hotel. Regular dinner was great, I recommend the octopus and their bread pudding dessert. Thanksgiving dinner was great, plenty of options and the spread was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Pudding
Katrina Claro
Went for breakfast, dinner, and buffet dinner (thanksgiving dinner). Breakfast buffet was better last year, now its similar to what you would find at a hilton hotel. Regular dinner was great, I recommend the octopus and their bread pudding dessert. Thanksgiving dinner was great, plenty of options and the spread was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Pudding
Whiskers McDonald
– The service was outstanding, the staff were helpful, knowledgeable, and relatively prompt. Several parties arrived half an hour after us and our server disappeared for 20 minutes but upon his return all was well. They just need more staff is my guess. This was another case of everyone loved their meal except for the one picky eater whos opinion doesn’t count. His steak had “too much flavor”, but I think it tasted great. I had the Chilean seabass which was divine; foraged mushrooms were bland and a tiny serving for the price, but I threw them into the sea bass bowl and they soaked up the tasty liquids down there. The creamed spinach, while very tasty, needs to dial back the salt by a lot. Like, try half the salt. No one at our table could eat more than 2 bites. I would definitely dine here again. However their breakfast buffet is another story all together; the egg trough was overcooked and flavorless and the potatoes were undercooked every single day. Like seriously! Stop serving raw potatoes! They taste like they need another 10-15 minutes in an oven at 400F, or at least microwave them so they are cooked through cus they were just gross. The omelette station was pretty good, despite having one guy cooking he did so rather quickly with 4 pans going at once. The omelette makers need a raise. The servers were hit of miss getting coffee, water, etc i.e. 2 mornings the service was spectacular while two other mornings I got up and got water and coffee myself and was given side eye from the server. Well don’t make me wait 20 minutes for coffee which I asked for twice and he said right away and never came back. Thanks Lazaar.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Jeffrey Jones
Very inviting and comfortable atmosphere. All members of the dining area were very professional and personable. All the food was delicious and prepared perfectly.
Marisol S (Sharpy)
Nicole was our waitress - OUTSTANDING!!! Definitely ask for her for too service!! The food is amazing!!! Options for everyone!!
Vegetarian options: So many - I am vegan and it was phenomenal
Kid-friendliness: Well behaved kids
Parking: Large lot
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes
Dietary restrictions: So many options for every restriction
During our stay at the Skytop Lodge we had two breakfasts and two dinners in the Windsor room. One breakfast was on the weekend and was a buffet, one we ordered from the menu. Both were great. The buffet was much above average. We had huevos rancheros, potatoes, sausage, smoked salmon, and fresh fruit. The morning we ordered from the menu we had the caprese omelet and the South porch breakfast. The omelet was a little over cooked, but that’s being picky. The flavors were well balanced. For dinners we had the duck duo, pork prime rib, rack of elk, and short rib pappardelle. Words cannot describe how these meals were prepared, the flavors, fats, acids, and spices were all balanced and the presentations were perfect. For appetizers we had the mussels, bison chorizo crostini, and the crab stuffed mushrooms. Again all of the flavors were outstanding. We had no dishes that we didn’t like.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I went here for our anniversary. The food was amazing and service impeccable. Highly recommend for a nice dinner out. We're are going back really soon. The restaurant is very elegant.
Food was great. Service was very attentive. we had the beef Wellington for two. Had to order 24 hours in advance and totally worth it! Cooked to perfection and super delicious. Definitely revisit .The lodge and the grounds are massive and impressive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had the Beef Wellington for 2 and it was cooked perfectly. Service was very attentive. All of our food was very flavorful. Amazing property with lots of history and atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Pudding
This is e " go too" place when we celebrate anything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pancakes
Chefs kiss to curry noodles w shrimp this weekend. I’m back home and want it over again. Really good. Drinks, sub par.
Had another amazing dinner at Windsor before working in another part of the building. Service was excellent and the venison special was incredible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere was good service they were doing their best. Location is amazing. Dinner was not good. You could tell they were trying to do something just missed the mark. I took a group of 20 when I sent out a survey monkey on the entire retreat that dinner a lot of bad remarks
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Had a nice dinner here at 10–18
We went for the valentine’s day special menu, the food was excellent but unfortunately we had a horrible server, Terry, who made the entire experience very underwhelming. never once did she check on us or ask how everything was. between the bartender, the server’s assistant and and manager, they were basically doing all the work. it was not a busy night there were about 6 tables there including us and her service was terrible. not a personable person by any means and we were just another table she had to be bothered with. brought us an incorrect bill in the end and never bothered to come back, we had to ask someone else with assistance on getting it fixed. we really enjoyed the food but it was very unfortunate to have such poor service at such a nice place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Went for breakfast, dinner, and buffet dinner (thanksgiving dinner). Breakfast buffet was better last year, now its similar to what you would find at a hilton hotel. Regular dinner was great, I recommend the octopus and their bread pudding dessert. Thanksgiving dinner was great, plenty of options and the spread was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Pudding
Went for breakfast, dinner, and buffet dinner (thanksgiving dinner). Breakfast buffet was better last year, now its similar to what you would find at a hilton hotel. Regular dinner was great, I recommend the octopus and their bread pudding dessert. Thanksgiving dinner was great, plenty of options and the spread was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Pudding
– The service was outstanding, the staff were helpful, knowledgeable, and relatively prompt. Several parties arrived half an hour after us and our server disappeared for 20 minutes but upon his return all was well. They just need more staff is my guess. This was another case of everyone loved their meal except for the one picky eater whos opinion doesn’t count. His steak had “too much flavor”, but I think it tasted great. I had the Chilean seabass which was divine; foraged mushrooms were bland and a tiny serving for the price, but I threw them into the sea bass bowl and they soaked up the tasty liquids down there. The creamed spinach, while very tasty, needs to dial back the salt by a lot. Like, try half the salt. No one at our table could eat more than 2 bites. I would definitely dine here again. However their breakfast buffet is another story all together; the egg trough was overcooked and flavorless and the potatoes were undercooked every single day. Like seriously! Stop serving raw potatoes! They taste like they need another 10-15 minutes in an oven at 400F, or at least microwave them so they are cooked through cus they were just gross. The omelette station was pretty good, despite having one guy cooking he did so rather quickly with 4 pans going at once. The omelette makers need a raise. The servers were hit of miss getting coffee, water, etc i.e. 2 mornings the service was spectacular while two other mornings I got up and got water and coffee myself and was given side eye from the server. Well don’t make me wait 20 minutes for coffee which I asked for twice and he said right away and never came back. Thanks Lazaar.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Very inviting and comfortable atmosphere. All members of the dining area were very professional and personable. All the food was delicious and prepared perfectly.
Nicole was our waitress - OUTSTANDING!!! Definitely ask for her for too service!! The food is amazing!!! Options for everyone!!
Vegetarian options: So many - I am vegan and it was phenomenal
Kid-friendliness: Well behaved kids
Parking: Large lot
Wheelchair accessibility: Yes
Dietary restrictions: So many options for every restriction
Loading...