Restaurants in St. Marys

“I just had the lobster rolls this afternoon, and Wow!!! I'll definitely be getting that again!”

“Visited for the first time, and it definitely won’t be our last! The chicken Cobb salad was delicious! Hubby had the poutine (fries with cheese curds and gravy) and chili dog and said they were great!”

“Love the straub ,light On the box it reads returnable bottles $5 , When I asked the dealer about it ,he said not here WHERE ??”

“I went to lunch here for the first time and felt so comfortable as soon as I walked in. The wooden tables, warm decor and welcoming atmosphere made me feel right at home. I sat with my friend and ate delicious food while also feeling relaxed in the environment. I will 100% be back. Who doesn’t love delicious food in a comforting place?”

“There are meatball hoagie was awesome”

“Gunners hosted the dinner after my mother-in-law‘s funeral. They accommodated a very big crowd so well. Everything was laid out perfectly and the food was absolutely delicious! We couldn’t have asked for anything better and are so appreciative of them catering to our needs. Highly recommend them for any event or a special dinner. This place is a gem in St. Marys!”

“(Franklin location) Amazing service, amazing food, generous portions! Beautiful atmosphere. We ended up taking some home. You can taste how fresh everything is and it is sooo so good! My husband and I loved every bite.”

“great food and wonderful service”

“We had a great experience at Wildwoods tonight. We had a large party of 15 people which included a bunch of small children . The food was incredible and the service was great! The price was extremely reasonable as well. Definitely recommend this restaurant! Thank you for a great time!”

“Great Sicilian pizza and Stromboli!”

“Nice clean everything was fresh. I ordered 7 sandwiches. They were very nice& friendly. Got my order very fast& accurate. It was even the owners birthday. Dedication for sure. This is definitely my Subway from now on. Thank you for your excellent service!”

“We had Rigatoni made by the Cafe for our Christmas dinner. It was absolutely amazing. I would recommend the Cafe 110%. Thank you so much!!!!!”

“The Straub Brewery and Tap Room are a must-visit spot for beer and wildlife enthusiasts alike. The wide selection of beers showcases their rich German heritage, and the taproom feels like a local gathering place, serving both local and German-inspired menu items.”

“Great food, happy service. There was a weird dude giving us the stink eye the whole time. He knew we weren't from there, regardless it was a great hometown diner.”

“Thank you for our Excellent pizza and bucket of garbage wings they were fantastic”

“Wouldn't go here. After new owners took it over. Nope! I know too much. Becareful posting a review on here. People harassing me about this!! Another reason to stay away!!”

“The owner is so sweet and kind. Not only did she make one dairy free smash cake for our son, she made two! They turned out amazing! Our son loved them!!”

“Pizza panini was great!!!!😊”

“Once again our DIY cookie kits were amazing. Reasonably priced, taste fantastic and ample supplies. You simply can’t go wrong with these.”

“Great food and amazing service !!”

“The grilled chicken (with mozzarella and bacon) sandwiches are excellent. NONE OF OUR FAST FOOD PLACES IN SAINT MARYS HAVE GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICHES... I just wish the sandwiches were accompanied by french fries for the price.”

“👍We love what New Horizons Healthy Foods/Fitness Fun is all about. Supporting healthy eating and fitness in the community is meaningful mission. You couldn't find a more helpful and knowledgeable owner than Leroy. Highly recommended!”

“A true gem in St. Marys. Glad I was able to visit DD's bakery on this visit to St. Marys. In addition to 2 large cases of every kind of pastry and donut you could want, they also serve breakfast, with a big menu of great home cooking. I went in to get a couple breakfast sandwiches and a donut or two to take to my dad at the nursing home and ended up walking out with an additional dozen assorted donuts and pastries. Didn't know who was gonna eat them exactly, but they were begging to be bought. For all that, it was like $21? Ridiculously cheap. Not to mention the convenience and crafts store adjacent.”

“🔥 Big thanks to Buck’s Pizza in St. Mary’s, PA! 🔥 The GoNano of Pennsylvania crew was out working hard today, and nothing hits better after a long day than Buck’s Pizza. The pizza was absolutely amazing — hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. Our guys loved every bite! We’re all about supporting local businesses that take pride in what they do, and Buck’s never disappoints. If you’re in or around St. Mary’s, go grab yourself a pie — you’ll thank us later! 🍕💪”

“This is the absolute best Chinese in the area. Nothing to add. Hands down where you need to go if you want Chinese. Get the crab rangoons, they serve them as both the triangles and little hobo bags all in one order so everyone gets the type they prefer.”

“Just moved to town and was wanting Chinese food the prices where decent for the meal I got the rice was very well cooked and came out shortly after I ordered it so didn’t wait long it’s a very quiet place which was nice to eat in peace the staff was friendly in my opinion it was a very nice lunch”

“Great Place and Food !”

“Went late (about 8pm) .. ordered meatball sub and Buffalo chicken sub .. super fresh buns .. large meatballs and just right spiced buffalo chicken .. service was prompt and great .. highly recommend the place ..”

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Big shout-out to Fox’s Pizza in St. Marys! Our son has gluten and dairy intolerance, and they always go above and beyond for him. Pete loves their gluten free pizza (just crust, sauce, and pepperoni) and they remember his unique order every time. When daycare parents order pizza for the kids, Fox’s makes sure Pete gets his own safe pizza too so he’s never left out, that means the world to us. On top of that, their food is always great and the staff genuinely cares. We’re so thankful for everything they do for our family. Highly recommend!”

“The grilled Italian chicken breast was amazing & 5 star - tender, moist & so flavorful!! The blueberry lemonade was very unique & refreshing! I’ll be back very soon to repeat my meal!”

“Food was good , served up fast . Just very surprised they had no regular taco sauce. We were told they don’t have it anymore . One employee was yelling in the back at another employee. They need an adult in the place . Too many kids working there !”