Bakeries in St. Marys

Sugar Mamas Bake Shop Bakery • $
424 Depot St, St Marys

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak Bagel Bomb
Cooper Grilled Cheese
Hearty Mama
Sausage
Scone

“The owner is so sweet and kind. Not only did she make one dairy free smash cake for our son, she made two! They turned out amazing! Our son loved them!!“

5 Superb19 Reviews
Storybook Sweets LLC Bakery • $$
148 Houston Rd, St Marys

“Delicious and reasonably priced“

5 Superb4 Reviews
D D's Specialty Bakery Cafe Bakery • $
31 Erie Ave, St Marys

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Sandwich
Slices of Toast
Cheese Omelet
Pancakes

“A true gem in St. Marys. Glad I was able to visit DD's bakery on this visit to St. Marys. In addition to 2 large cases of every kind of pastry and donut you could want, they also serve breakfast, with a big menu of great home cooking. I went in to get a couple breakfast sandwiches and a donut or two to take to my dad at the nursing home and ended up walking out with an additional dozen assorted donuts and pastries. Didn't know who was gonna eat them exactly, but they were begging to be bought. For all that, it was like $21? Ridiculously cheap. Not to mention the convenience and crafts store adjacent.“

4.4 Superb22 Reviews