Olde New York
2298 E College Ave, State College
(814) 237-1582
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Always a good experience and meal when in town. Well done, Kenny and team!
Older New York is my favorite restaurant in the area. Great food, great service, and super nice people.
Portions are small ....Tasty though
I am leaving 5 stars only because of the most amazing server, Jancy. The kitchen was very backed up and Jancy was so proactive making sure our drinks were always filled, and keeping us updated on when the food would come out. She was very kind and checking up on us very often. She also gave my son a beautiful birthday dessert. She was extremely busy with several tables around us yet managed to give us ongoing personal treatment. Give her a raise!!
Beautiful surroundings, good food. If you like German style food, this is a good choice. Weiss wurst is my choice.
Excellent food and service..Will be returning soon.
We were a party of 3. The service was excellent. My burger was good. My daughter ordered the mac and cheese with no blu cheese. When it came out it tasted like Blu cheese. Don't know if that's just how they make it or if someone made a mistake.
Now, the reason I gave the restaurant the score for food, was because of the hair found on the cheesesteak plate. I understand things happen and it's ok. But really? Gross!
Great food.
Everything is good, but the perogies are amazing!!
The food was terrible. The only thing that was good was the dessert. A $30 dollar steak should taste good. A waste of money. We will not return
Restaurantji Recommends
Great atmosphere and same for the service!
Atmosphere is great. Food is amazing. Staff was very nice. The only complaint is it was EXTREMELY slow service even when the place wasn’t too busy so Im taking one star off for that. Even though it’s a little pricey and slow, I would eat here again - but I would give myself more time in the day.
A decent experience. We enjoyed the appetizer and really enjoyed the Apple Strudel dessert. The entrees were okay but the schnitzels were a little overdone. We both agreed that we would go back to try some other appetizers and desserts and maybe skip the entrees.
When we arrived there was no wait and we were seated quickly. After sitting down and removing my coat, noticed the place was quite chilly. While looking at the menu, we noticed something moving around a window near us. Then noticed a few times something moving around above us. Finally figured out that it was a small bird inside the restaurant.
Waitress was attentive and very nice.
I order the Jagerschnitzel with spaetzle, and red cabbage. The Jagerschnitzel was very dry and when checked the bottom of it, found it was black in spots and quite brown in others. The sauce for the meat was quite bland. The spaetzle was extremely salty and tough to eat, tasted like it was fried way to long. The portion of red cabbage was enough for several people and tasted so-so. Overall, I was quite disappointed. Ate Jagerschnitzel many times while in Germany and other places. This was by far the worst I've had.
My wife order the currywurst with coleslaw. The portion of coleslaw was quite small. The wurst was of decent size. What she had seemed to be a better choice than what I ordered.
I have no plans of returning and suggest, if you're considering going here, try some other place instead.
Unique spot. I was totally apprehensive as soon as we noticed this restaurant was located in a strip mall but thank goodness we gave it a shot anyway. As soon as you walk through the door you are wrapped in a warm and welcoming interior with smiles to boot.
The menu is a happy step away from what you find at your usual establishment. There are many specialties and tons of options I wouldn’t mind trying! We decided to go for two of the schnitzel options. No disappointment! Everything was delish! The portions were more than generous. Wait staff—very attentive and pleasant. In fact she was sweet enough to pitch in when we were having trouble taking a selfie. More than that she showed us where to get the best shot and snapped it herself!
Would return anytime!
Loading...