11 Best Italian Restaurants near Stillwater

“If you haven’t, you need to! The vibe was amazing. The food was spectacular and the service was out of this world.“

“went to bridal shower on a Sunday first time there food was so good . Went back on Wednesday to order take out dinner awesome food“

“5 ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ Stop in by chance on our way back to Boston from Indiana. Has soon as we walked in I said this is going to be a great meal!! The place is clean and smells Greeted with a friendly hello and a smile, we were sat within minutes, our waitress came right over and introduced herself. She informed us of the specials, answered all of our questions and made some recommendations based off our answers. I knew from the moment we walked in and I was wright Food was amazing, staff was knowledgeable and friendly it was a great experience and I will be returning“

“My girlfriend and I went to Olive Garden the other night and had a really good time. The food was solid as always, but what really made the experience great was our waitress, Grace. She was super respectful, friendly, and on top of everything the whole time. Our drinks stayed full, she checked on us just the right amount, and you could tell she actually cared about making sure we had a good experience. It wasn’t just the usual service you expect. She went above and beyond and made us feel really welcome. I had the chicken Alfredo and my girlfriend had the seafood pasta. Both dishes were delicious and came out hot and fresh. Everything was paced really well and we never felt rushed. We both felt comfortable the whole night and it just made the dinner that much more enjoyable. Big shoutout to Grace for being awesome. We’ll definitely be back and hoping to sit in her section again.“

“They are GREAT! Delivered ON TIME, pizza was nice & hot (& good!)“

“Pleasant to order from and the food is very good! We will be back.“

“Service was quick, friendly, and direct. It's a little small, but extremely clean with some of the best pizza I've ever had (that's saying quite a bit for me). I ended up getting a pepperoni and a veggie slice while I was there, soft fluffy crust with a good crunch to it, couldn't leave without a stromboli and a slice of their sweet pizza. I've been through the area quite often, but usually don't have much time to stop, definitely going to try and work on making more time when I can now that I know this place is here.“

“ordered through doordash-first mistake (no help from their customer service)but issue was quickly and kindly resolved by the establishment“

“Absolutely the best! We got Large Shicky Stromboli and it was HUGE! Delicious, fast, very meat packed! 🙂🤫“

“Such a great place! Best pizza I’ve had in years! Also the best service I’ve had in years! Feels like being part of the family. LOVE that vibe!!!“

“I love their hoagies and I tried fried pierogies, which were scrumptious.
Yesterday May 31,2024 I placed an order for delivery. I ordered a chef's salad and a child's chicken finger meal. The fries were terrible. They were raw in the middle. I tried to fry them, but whatever oil they used made me ill just smelling it and they tasted terrible. But the chef's salad was wonderful. Fresh ingredients were used. That was the best I ever had from Berwick OIP!“