We live in the area. Gave this place a try, since we love pizza and eat it often. This place is a far cry from having good Italian pizza! Pizza was greasy which can indicate quality of cheese. Crust had no flavor. Place is very dirty. We also ordered an Italian sub that had to be the thinnest sub I had ever eaten. 1 slice of ham, 1 slice of Salami, the tomatoes tasted horrible, like it was the middle of winter! You would think being in the heart of an abundance of fresh produce that they would serve fresh one’s. It’s sad to see a business putting in such little effort to satisfy customers. I’m sad to say this place is a thumbs down for us! Not worth coming back to.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Shawn
Dropped by this pizza place on a whim and was pleasantly surprised. The crust was just the right balance of crispy and chewy, toppings were fresh, and the sauce had that perfect tang. Nothing too fancy, just good, honest pizza — exactly what you want when you're craving a classic slice. Big shoutout to Sam for the excellent service! Friendly, quick with recommendations, and clearly knows their way around the menu. It’s always great when someone genuinely seems to care that you’re having a good experience.
Robin Egloff
Great New York pizza! Worth a visit.
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Christopher
Horrible!!! I usually go to Strasburg pizza but thought I’d try something new. I will never be back. Staff is extremely rude and the food is no better. The cheesesteak was bland with no flavor, Too much roll for the amount of meat and cheese and the roll was very dry. Stromboli wasn’t any better. Very greasy and salty, the cheese wasn’t melted and the dough tasted like it’s not done.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Robert Heavlow
Great pizza 🍕, really nice people
Chris Moritzen
I’ve driven past this place 1000 times and never stopped. Dropped in to grab two slices for lunch and they did not disappoint. Great pizza great service great quality. I’m no Dave Portnoy, but a very solid slice 9.5/10 on the big guy scale. If you’re in town and need a quick bite. Don’t drive past, stop in.
Tim P
Stopped here after I went to the train museum. I got a steak sub with hot peppers, onions and sauce and it was DELICIOUS!!! I can't wait to try their pizza next time I go down.
Thomas Weitzel
Drive a few miles off 30. Good wings pizza and subs. Go give them a try.
Also it's fun to look at the old pics on the walls. The Years fly by.
Ellen Jenders
Best pizza in Lancaster. I moved from Strasburg to Hempfield area recently and I miss being so close to this amazing local gem!
Great food and great prices! It has been there a long time! Incredibly friendly!
Randy Nusbaum
Great food!
Laura Chuba
This place is a hidden gem for great quality food! Not much atmosphere here but tasty fixings, generous portions, friendly staff!
some hoodlum
Sam is the best I love his pizza
K “Smeary” T
The dude working seemed like a genuine man, down to earth, and a little funny. A side of fries with your pizza for only $1.50... okay I'm down with that! My hubby loves his pizza and I love my fries so it was a perfect match. The fries were good, they tasted like fries but the pizza was only okay.. it could be a little better. The place isn't clean though, it's sad because people might think better about eating food made from somewhere at least some what clean. There was dust everywhere like layers of it that you can see, and the bathroom was the dirtiest bathroom I've ever seen anywhere ... Literally. But hey the employee was super cool.
We live in the area. Gave this place a try, since we love pizza and eat it often. This place is a far cry from having good Italian pizza! Pizza was greasy which can indicate quality of cheese. Crust had no flavor. Place is very dirty. We also ordered an Italian sub that had to be the thinnest sub I had ever eaten. 1 slice of ham, 1 slice of Salami, the tomatoes tasted horrible, like it was the middle of winter! You would think being in the heart of an abundance of fresh produce that they would serve fresh one’s. It’s sad to see a business putting in such little effort to satisfy customers. I’m sad to say this place is a thumbs down for us! Not
worth coming back to.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Dropped by this pizza place on a whim and was pleasantly surprised. The crust was just the right balance of crispy and chewy, toppings were fresh, and the sauce had that perfect tang. Nothing too fancy, just good, honest pizza — exactly what you want when you're craving a classic slice. Big shoutout to Sam for the excellent service! Friendly, quick with recommendations, and clearly knows their way around the menu. It’s always great when someone genuinely seems to care that you’re having a good experience.
Great New York pizza! Worth a visit.
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Horrible!!! I usually go to Strasburg pizza but thought I’d try something new. I will never be back. Staff is extremely rude and the food is no better. The cheesesteak was bland with no flavor, Too much roll for the amount of meat and cheese and the roll was very dry. Stromboli wasn’t any better. Very greasy and salty, the cheese wasn’t melted and the dough tasted like it’s not done.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great pizza 🍕, really nice people
I’ve driven past this place 1000 times and never stopped. Dropped in to grab two slices for lunch and they did not disappoint. Great pizza great service great quality. I’m no Dave Portnoy, but a very solid slice 9.5/10 on the big guy scale. If you’re in town and need a quick bite. Don’t drive past, stop in.
Stopped here after I went to the train museum. I got a steak sub with hot peppers, onions and sauce and it was DELICIOUS!!! I can't wait to try their pizza next time I go down.
Drive a few miles off 30. Good wings pizza and subs. Go give them a try.
Also it's fun to look at the old pics on the walls. The Years fly by.
Best pizza in Lancaster. I moved from Strasburg to Hempfield area recently and I miss being so close to this amazing local gem!
Pizza was dried out...cheesesteaks not much meat.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food and great prices! It has been there a long time! Incredibly friendly!
Great food!
This place is a hidden gem for great quality food! Not much atmosphere here but tasty fixings, generous portions, friendly staff!
Sam is the best I love his pizza
The dude working seemed like a genuine man, down to earth, and a little funny. A side of fries with your pizza for only $1.50... okay I'm down with that! My hubby loves his pizza and I love my fries so it was a perfect match. The fries were good, they tasted like fries but the pizza was only okay.. it could be a little better. The place isn't clean though, it's sad because people might think better about eating food made from somewhere at least some what clean. There was dust everywhere like layers of it that you can see, and the bathroom was the dirtiest bathroom I've ever seen anywhere ... Literally. But hey the employee was super cool.
Loading...