Worst pizza ever that I ordered from there picking up a slice from the pie and the cardboard box was soaking wet and stuck to the pizza and the pizza as I was holding it fell over just as I was going to bit into it the toppings fell off of the slice I would never recommend them to my worst enemy it's the worst I have ever had from them and will never by from them any more especially when the pieces of cardboard sticks to the slice and it falls apart as you are eating it! Take my advice and go somewhere else! I should have gone with Bono pizza instead!
Elizabeth Schultz
Ordered a supreme pizza crust is very thin and can't pick it up with out everything falling off
Food: 1
Service: 1
KIRTI PATEL
Best pizza in Stroudsburg Pa, went on vacation, and tried this pizza place was 3 minutes way, and it very good for us, it had nice texture and crunch and there sauce is excellent. They also have good pasta and other italian stuff. 100% recommended this place. The workers and the owner are very friendly and caring and also have nice deals there. Good place should try it out. Best pizza in Poconos, highly recommended it
This place used to be great before it changed hands.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Joe Ainslie
First time trying with the kids.They seemed to like it.We only got cheese pizza but was good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deborah Green
TERRIBLE! No service, dirty. TERRIBLE! Said hello to gentlemen behind counter and was ignored! Will not return.
Steven Green
5+ people were working. Didn't greet us when we came in. We looked at the menu. Decided what we to wanted. Looked in the fridge for drinks and there's a bowl of raw chicken. Looked around now and most of the place was extremely dirty. ??. We immediately left. Not one employee said anything the entire time we were there or as we left. Definitely wouldn't ever go back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
adam mosley
Excellent pizza and sauce. Being a NYC transplant I can say this was pretty close to home. Owner on premises was involved with all food making. New regular client now. Way to go Pizza 1
Excellent. Pizza was delicious. Please was clean a the staff was very friendly and cordial.
Sara Duprey
I am providing Pizza One with an honest review because while the majority of times I found at Pizza One were pleasant, they were not high quality enough for me to overlook the nightmare I experienced. I ate at Pizza One in the summer months of 2021, with a friend. I can't remember if the clerk was male or female at that time. We were given enough attention and received our slices, and there was adequate professionalism. I visited again in 2022, I was by myself, and the clerk was very careful. I had the undivided attention of the clerk, and I was given a good portion of an amount of food; it was an appropriate value. During this visit, I had a female clerk. I visited again in 2023, and the experience was the polar opposite. I ordered eggplant Parmesan without cheese, and I had a cashier who was a man. I ordered and he was asking me if I wanted angel hair or linguini, and another question. He never asked me if I wanted to take my food to go or not, and after I paid I went to sit down because I received a phone call. The cashier then put the food which was two separate containers of the eggplant and pasta, in a paper bag and small metal containers. The cashier didn't bother to put the heavy bag in a plastic bag over the paper bag, or even ask me if I wanted it to go! I had to leave so I didn't ask him to put it in a plate and I would sit down, and it was not my responsibility. It was obvious that there was more food than the container could hold. I get out of my car, and the bag breaks and spills tomato sauce all over my pants! I was forced to be put in public with tomato sauce all over my clothes and mask, all because of the carelessness of the clerk. It all would never have happened had he asked me one question, and took more precaution. I have a generous tip, and end up being given very careless service. I was humiliated. It was beyond inconvenient, I had to clean up my car seat. I was lucky that a person at another business was kind enough to give me a disposable face mask because I had a disposable one on that day (not a business located in the pizzeria's plaza). It seems that there is potential for the pizzeria to progress into a business in better practice, because they are fair in prices but certain practices need revision.
Parking: The plaza has many businesses, so it is very wide.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Joseph Buchanan
First time visiting. Everything was delicious and served very quick and fresh. The only problem I have is it's 1-1/2 hrs from home.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Madeline Chang
This place has such good pizza ny style not too thick good amt of sauce I love this place also the chicken caesar salad is good as well good dressing ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Steak Sandwich, French Fries
Worst pizza ever that I ordered from there picking up a slice from the pie and the cardboard box was soaking wet and stuck to the pizza and the pizza as I was holding it fell over just as I was going to bit into it the toppings fell off of the slice I would never recommend them to my worst enemy it's the worst I have ever had from them and will never by from them any more especially when the pieces of cardboard sticks to the slice and it falls apart as you are eating it! Take my advice and go somewhere else! I should have gone with Bono pizza instead!
Ordered a supreme pizza crust is very thin and can't pick it up with out everything falling off
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best pizza in Stroudsburg Pa, went on vacation, and tried this pizza place was 3 minutes way, and it very good for us, it had nice texture and crunch and there sauce is excellent. They also have good pasta and other italian stuff. 100% recommended this place. The workers and the owner are very friendly and caring and also have nice deals there. Good place should try it out. Best pizza in Poconos, highly recommended it
Vegetarian options: Pizza, pasta, garlic nots
Dietary restrictions: Care to use a clean cut
Kid-friendliness: Nice to customers
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Sausage Pizza, Pizza 1 Seafood Combo, Chicken Marsala, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Alfredo, Meat Lovers, Sausage, Meatball, White Pizza, Plain Cheese Pizza, Large Meat Lover Pizza, Plain Sicilian Pizza, Wings, Garlic Knots, White Broccoli Pizza, Garlic Knots 6 Each, Veggie Pizza, House-Made Chicken Tenders with Fries, Veneccia
This place used to be great before it changed hands.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
First time trying with the kids.They seemed to like it.We only got cheese pizza but was good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
TERRIBLE! No service, dirty. TERRIBLE! Said hello to gentlemen behind counter and was ignored! Will not return.
5+ people were working. Didn't greet us when we came in. We looked at the menu. Decided what we to wanted. Looked in the fridge for drinks and there's a bowl of raw chicken. Looked around now and most of the place was extremely dirty.
??.
We immediately left. Not one employee said anything the entire time we were there or as we left.
Definitely wouldn't ever go back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Excellent pizza and sauce. Being a NYC transplant I can say this was pretty close to home. Owner on premises was involved with all food making. New regular client now. Way to go Pizza 1
Parking: Lot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Sausage, Meatball, Large Meat Lover Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza lg, Jumbo Chicken Wings 12, Garlic Knots with Mozzarella
Excellent Pizza ? NY style An exquisite flavor and the pizza slices in a very reasonable portion I recommend this place 10/10
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I liked going there a lot, I will try to come back sooner
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent. Pizza was delicious. Please was clean a the staff was very friendly and cordial.
I am providing Pizza One with an honest review because while the majority of times I found at Pizza One were pleasant, they were not high quality enough for me to overlook the nightmare I experienced. I ate at Pizza One in the summer months of 2021, with a friend. I can't remember if the clerk was male or female at that time. We were given enough attention and received our slices, and there was adequate professionalism. I visited again in 2022, I was by myself, and the clerk was very careful. I had the undivided attention of the clerk, and I was given a good portion of an amount of food; it was an appropriate value. During this visit, I had a female clerk. I visited again in 2023, and the experience was the polar opposite. I ordered eggplant Parmesan without cheese, and I had a cashier who was a man. I ordered and he was asking me if I wanted angel hair or linguini, and another question. He never asked me if I wanted to take my food to go or not, and after I paid I went to sit down because I received a phone call. The cashier then put the food which was two separate containers of the eggplant and pasta, in a paper bag and small metal containers. The cashier didn't bother to put the heavy bag in a plastic bag over the paper bag, or even ask me if I wanted it to go! I had to leave so I didn't ask him to put it in a plate and I would sit down, and it was not my responsibility. It was obvious that there was more food than the container could hold. I get out of my car, and the bag breaks and spills tomato sauce all over my pants! I was forced to be put in public with tomato sauce all over my clothes and mask, all because of the carelessness of the clerk. It all would never have happened had he asked me one question, and took more precaution. I have a generous tip, and end up being given very careless service. I was humiliated. It was beyond inconvenient, I had to clean up my car seat. I was lucky that a person at another business was kind enough to give me a disposable face mask because I had a disposable one on that day (not a business located in the pizzeria's plaza). It seems that there is potential for the pizzeria to progress into a business in better practice, because they are fair in prices but certain practices need revision.
Parking: The plaza has many businesses, so it is very wide.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
First time visiting. Everything was delicious and served very quick and fresh. The only problem I have is it's 1-1/2 hrs from home.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place has such good pizza ny style not too thick good amt of sauce I love this place also the chicken caesar salad is good as well good dressing ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Steak Sandwich, French Fries
Pizza was not cut to good could have been
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Pepperoni Half Cheese Pizza
Loading...