Restaurants near Sugar Grove

“I see on pictures that you carry chipped dried beef on toast, but I can't find it on your menu. Do you carry it ?”

“I’m from NJ, I was visiting the area and this place by far had the best pizza I ever had. Something about their dough was special, wasn’t expecting to still crave it after returning to my state. Highly recommend.”

“All wonderful but their BBQ sauce. It is horrendous. Full of vinegar. As long as you order your items, especially their nachos--yummmy!, with no BBQ sauce or sauce on the side, they are great. You order at the bar for everything. HUGE selection of alcohol. Their whiskeys are great and you have the ability to buy a shot. Then you can take home a bottle of your favorite flavor. Fun T-shirts and sweatshirts as well (especially now in full Pumkin King season). Fun music trivia nights and live bands too. It is an experience not to be missed if you are in the area.”

“We were up at Lake Chautauqua from Pittsburgh, had breakfast at this diner. What a hidden gem. Food was delicious and owner Mark who is also the cook is salt of the earth type person. Must eat there!!!!!”

“Pizza and wings were delicious. Prices were great too.”

“Probably the best restaurant from Erie to Buffalo. Simple ingredients, elevated. 10 orders in 17 minutes, plated. Every element on each dish- perfected. I did not expect to find a new favorite restaurant, but here we are, each member of our group aged 5-60+, with the kind ofsmile that only comes from stomach-happiness.”

“I too, have never been here. But, since there is some obnoxious woman asking that people leave a one star review when clearly you have a lot of support from the community (for asking her to stop filming in the middle of your dining area), then I felt the need to come here and counteract that. It looks like I am not the only one but it definitely also is clear that so many people from the community love ya'll! I will definitely be dropping in the next time I am in the area!”

“Just had one of the best meals of the summer at Stella’s last night! 10/10/25. I ordered their special of stuffed haddock and was not disappointed. Thank you to your entire staff for another outstanding dining experience! Great date night thanks to ALL of you!!”

“While in Jamestown to see Nat Comedy Center & Lucy/Desi Museum, we stopped for lunch at The Pub. Excellent service! Great food! 😋 Will def eat here again next time I'm up that way.”

“My wife and I have come to Jamestown for events the past two years and have made it a point to visit The Swamp. Everyone has been so nice and welcoming and that includes staff and other patrons. And the swamp wings are a must have. Hopefully we'll be here next year as well!”

“A place to get all your baked goods. I picked up rolls for a bbq we were having. Go in a week before for large orders, prepay, and tell them what time you need them by. The day of, walking in pickup, and leave in minutes, get a treat for the ride home.”

“Great food, great service, great prices. They were pretty packed and we didn't know to make a reservation, so we ate outside. That being said, I don't know what the interior is like, but outside was nice.”

“One of the best kept secrets in Jamestown. Excellent food, service with very reasonable prices.”

“The southwest bowl and mushroom soup are my classic Lab favorites, and the Specials List is always, always on point! I'm also a fan of the somewhat newer Munich Burger on a salad or GF wrap, and the Sausage Party Flatbread on GF! okay. the list goes on...”

“We got there at about 7:45 thinking they closed at 9. They actually were closing at 8pm for after labor day hours. I didn't want to be inconvenient and would have left, but the Jeremy and his crew were really polite and kind and said it was no big deal. Everything was made quick, was reasonably priced, and delicious as always. Thanks again for another great meal!”

“The meals were great, service was friendly, and the atmosphere was inviting. Looking forward to coming back here, especially when the weather is nicer and the outdoor seating is more welcoming. 😁”

“Amazing food and amazing service. The waitress was very nice and welcoming, great food at a great price.”

“Came in with a custom drink order and Juana made it and exceeded expectations she's also always so sweet and kind!”

“I made the trip up from PA just for the Concord Grape pies, because I didn't have time to make them myself. I was very happy to find them available not far away, as I always figured I'd have to make a day trip up by the Finger Lakes region to get my hands on one. I just had a slice, and it was absolutely delicious!! I'll definitely be going back for special occasions - it's a beautiful little shop & you should check it out!”

“We've been coming to Pace's Pizza for many years. It has always been great, but since new ownership has taken over, it is even better! Great staff, owner (Joe) always stops by the table, and the Pizza is by far the best around. We are summer residents and drive in from Mayville many times each summer, as Pace's is a family favorite for all of our visitors. I highly recommend you give it a try!”

“I love coming here! Everyone is so kind, it is so cozy and with all the flavor syrups the have - ice latte choices are endless! My new favorite go to coffee shop near work.”

“You can't get better service than you'll get from Phil N' Cindy's!!! We are on a road trip and stopped for a to go lunch. The owner was there helped me out to my car with our large order and even threw in a few extras to help make the trip better for the kids! The portions were large and the food was outstanding!!! Highly reccomend!!!”

“Wonderful remodel, fantastic food & the sweetest server!!! Thank you! 😍”

“Our first time here. We love it! Atmosphere was wonderful. Food was excellent! Our server Julia was fantastic!! Thank you so much! We will be back for more. 👍”

“We have dined at the Good Time Saloon several times and have never been disappointed with the food, service, or atmosphere. The prices are more than reasonable and the food is delicious. The staff are friendly, the drinks aren’t watered down, and all the bartenders make a damn good LIT! Good Time Saloon is our new hangout when we’re in town… Cheers 🍻”

“We ate there tonight. The restaurant is absolutely beautiful! The atmosphere, food and staff are nothing short of excellent! Highly recommend!”

“Best hot 🌭 ‘s in whole wide world!! There is no one better!!”

“Amazing food”

“Great place friendly staff delicious food good prices”

“Very friendly staff. Good food and great prices.”