Country Custard Cottage
1503 Mars Hill Rd, Sutersville
(724) 872-7911
Customers' Favorites
Peanut Butter Brownie Parfait
Chocolate Ice Cream Cone
Chocolate Covered
Hot Fudge Sundae
Custard Clusters
Custard Flight
Salted Caramel
English Toffee
Butter Pecan
Waffle Cone
Menu
Photos
+56 photos
+55 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I was honestly shocked when I pulled up because there were so many people there, but after going inside, I completely understood why. The place has the feel of an old-fashioned country store with a huge variety of ice cream flavors to choose from. The ice cream itself was top quality, and the service was quick even with how busy they were. There’s also a nice porch out front where you can sit and enjoy your ice cream, plus plenty of parking available. The prices were about average...
Finally got to stop in and was not disappointed! Very busy as well and well maintained and super kind staff and the other customers even were very kind as well! Strawberry shortcake sundea and brownie sundea was amazing ❤️ cant wait to come back again soon!
Update: I also got strawberry wax melts and put 1 of the cubes in as soon as I got home and this single cubes scent has lasted thru the whole night and still going strong! The wax melts are amazing ❤️ and the...
Update: I also got strawberry wax melts and put 1 of the cubes in as soon as I got home and this single cubes scent has lasted thru the whole night and still going strong! The wax melts are amazing ❤️ and the...
Could not recommend this place enough! The staff is always so nice, the ice cream is delicious, and for being busy they served everyone quickly! So happy they’re back open for season!
You May Also Like
Valley Pizza Shop - 115 Industry Rd
![]()
Pizza, Salad, Burgers
Rock Run Inn: Restaurant & Banquets - 800 Rock Run Rd
![]()
American, Venues & Event Spaces