“Ordered the mushroom Swiss burger with fries. Everything was fresh and tasted great. Burger patty tasted and appeared to be homemade and not a pre-made frozen patty like fast food places use. Prices were very resonable, service was great, and our food came out quickly. Would highly recommend and we will be going back next time we are in the area.“
“I like visiting restaurants where you can see community happening. I was staying with a friend for the weekend and I was told this is where we have to go after church. The charm of the small town eatery is present before you even step through the door. I saw customers holding the door for one another, greeting one another, teasing as they entered the sanctuary after their church service on a Sunday afternoon. It was obvious people didn't just eat here, they interacted on a personal level. I generally skip the chains when traveling and this is why. The food was good, the prices were fair, the service was friendly, but I love seeing community on a deeper level. The waitresses knew their regulars, treated them more like family than customers but were quick to welcome an out of towner as well. If I'm ever in the area again I will definitely be returning to Coal Oil Johnny's. If I could pack a restaurant up and take it with me I would, but then Pleasantville would be a little less pleasant. This place is a must for anyone that appreciates the spirit of a small town.“
“Joe and his team catered our wedding at the Titusville Ironworks and they absolutely crushed it for us. The food was incredible, the service was amazing, and they really did a great job making sure we had the best day. We can't recommend them enough! Thank you to Joe and your entire staff!“