Shelly Pie Pizza
$ • Italian, American, Pizza
Hours:
912 Penn Ave, Turtle Creek
(412) 646-2560
About Shelly Pie Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Shelly Pie Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Shelly Pie Pizza
We dined there for the first time this week. We told our waitress, Katie, that we had never been and she went above and beyond to give us an amazing experience. Our drinks were constantly refilled and the appetizer hot pepper cheese balls were delicious. She recommended the cheese bread sticks (they were so good!) and we thought the pizza (pepperoni sausage mushrooms) was outstanding. Thank you Katie for being so attentive. We will definitely be back Shelly Pie!
pizza was not even edible absolutley disgusting, if you want a Vincent's pizza go to Vincent's if you want a soggy undercooked knock off go here
I love this place!! I highly recommend it!!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
Shelly Pie Pizza is a popular spot known for its quality pizza and friendly service. The restaurant offers large servings with very good pizza, apps, and soups. The pizza crust is chewy and well baked, and prices are extremely reasonable, with a large plain pizza costing $19 and a two-topping large for $26. Many customers have enjoyed standout dishes like the Cajun chicken breast over Alfredo pasta, and some have noted that the food is consistently phenomenal. The crust is airy and puffy due to the light dough used, and while the sauce is good, it is light. Customers recommend not getting more than two toppings, as the crust may not hold more. The restaurant tends to be busy on weekends and nights, which is a good sign. Many visitors have praised the excellent service, mentioning friendly staff and standout waitresses. Overall, it is a great place to eat, and many recommend checking it out for a fun get-together or before the next Steelers game.