Shelly Pie Pizza

912 Penn Ave, Turtle Creek
(412) 646-2560

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Small Sicilian with Pepperoni and Sausage

Stuffed Banana Peppers

Medium Pepperoni Pizza

Pepperoni Pizza Fries

Large Pepperoni Pizza

Chicken Wings

Italian Hoagie

Fish Sandwich

Steak Hoagie

Garlic Knots

Our standard tossed salad, but bigger, with your choice of a grilled or fried chicken, french fries, and our signature blend of cheeses. House Italian, homemade buttermilk ranch, homemade thousand islands, blue cheese, french, fat-free sun-dried tomato, vinegar, and oil sweet & sour and homemade Asian sesame.

Tossed Salad

Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, and black olive. House Italian, homemade buttermilk ranch, homemade thousand islands, blue cheese, french, fat-free sun-dried tomato, vinegar, and oil sweet & sour and homemade Asian sesame.

Steak Salad

Our standard tossed salad, but bigger, with grilled steak. French fries and our signature blend of shredded cheeses. House Italian, homemade buttermilk ranch, homemade thousand islands, blue cheese, french, fat-free sun-dried tomato, vinegar, and oil sweet & sour and homemade Asian sesame.

Chef Salad

Our standard tossed salad, but bigger, with ham, turkey American, swiss cheese, and a hard-boiled egg. House Italian, homemade buttermilk ranch, homemade thousand islands, blue cheese, french, fat-free sun-dried tomato, vinegar, and oil sweet & sour and homemade Asian sesame.

Antipasta Salad

Our standard tossed salad, but bigger, topped our signature blend cheeses, ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, and pepper rings. House Italian, homemade buttermilk ranch, homemade thousand Islands, blue cheese, french, fat-free sun-dried tomato, vinegar, and oil sweet & sour and homemade Asian sesame.

Hoagies

Steak Hoagie

Shaved steak topped with grilled onions, our signature blend shredded cheeses, lettuce, tomato, and our homemade Italian dressing. Make it a Magoo, steak, cheese, mushrooms, and pepper rings only.

Meatball Hoagie

Italian meatballs topped with our homemade tomato sauce and a signature blend of shredded cheeses.

Italian Hoagie

Ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, and our signature blend of shredded cheeses. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and our homemade Italian dressing.

Turkey Hoagie Hoagie

Turkey topped with our signature blend of cheeses, lettuce, tomato, onion, and our homemade Italian.

Chicken Parmesan Hoagie

Golden fried chicken tenders topped with marinara sauce and our signature blend of shredded cheeses.

Hot Sausage Hoagie

Mildly hot sausage topped with onions, peppers, red sauce, and our signature blend of shredded cheeses.

Veggie Hoagie

Grilled mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, our signature blend of cheeses, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing.

Eggplant Parmesan Hoagie

Thinly sliced eggplant topped with tomato sauce and our signature blend of shredded cheeses.

Burgers

Maddie Mac Burger

Special sauce, lettuce, cheese, and pickle on a Mancini's bun. Served with french fries.

Half Pound Burger

Topped with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served with french fries.

Patty Melt Burger

Our 1/2 pound burger topped with American cheese and grilled onion a grilled Mancini's marble rye. Served with french fries.

Sandwiches

Reuben Sandwich

Tender, thinly sliced corned beef topped with swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and homemade thousand Island dressing. Served on grilled Mancini's marble rye. Served with french fries.

Hot Roast Beef Sandwich

All are served on texas toast with your choice of potato. We recommend the mashed.

Fish Sandwich

A large breaded fish filet served on a Mancini hoagie bun and choice of homemade tartar sauce or cocktail sauce.

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Texas toast grilled with American cheese. Served with french fries.

Tuna Melt Sandwich

Homemade tuna salad served on grilled texas toast and topped with American cheese. Served with french fries.

Chicken Sandwich

Your choice of a grilled chicken breast or golden fried chicken filet. We top it with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Make it buffalo of cajun style at no extra charge.

Hot Turkey Sandwich

All are served on texas toast with your choice of potato. We recommend the mashed.

Rachel Sandwich

Turkey breast topped with swiss cheese and coleslaw on grilled marble rye. Served with french fries.

Hot Meatloaf Sandwich

All are served on texas toast with your choice of potato. We recommend the mashed.

Clubs

Turkey & Bacon Club

Served on texas toast turkey, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.

Italian Club

We add balsamic mayo to this one. A twist on the original. Ham, salami, capicola and provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato on grilled garlic texas toast.

American Club

Served on texas toast turkey, ham, American and swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.

Entrees

Fettuccini Alfredo

Rich, creamy alfredo sauce tossed with fettuccini noodles. Served with tossed salad and bread and butter. Add chicken or shrimp for additional charge more. Spice up your chicken by making it cajun style. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Chicken Parmesan

Golden fried or grilled chicken breast topped with homemade tomato sauce and our signature blend of cheeses. Served with choice of potato or pasta. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Pasta Bolognese

Served with pasta and our homemade meat sauce. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Meatball Parmesan

Four large meatballs topped with homemade tomato sauce and our signature blend of cheeses. Served over pasta. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Stuffed Shells

Pasta stuffed shells, topped with tomato sauce and cheese.

Pasta with Homemade Tomato Sauce

Served with pasta and a meatball. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Lasagna

Layers of noodles, ricotta cheese, our signature blend of cheeses homemade tomato sauce. We top it with more cheese and a meatball. Add our pepperoni sauce for an additional charge. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Pasta Arrabiata

Hot. Served with pasta and a meatball. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Chicken Finger Dinner

Five chicken tenders served with your choice of potato or choice of dipping sauce. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Eggplant Parmesan

Thin sliced and breaded eggplant fried to perfection and topped with our homemade tomato sauce and a signature blend of cheeses. Served with pasta. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Shrimp Scampi

Large shrimp sauteed in garlic butter sauce and served over a bed of linguini. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Pasta O & G

A shelly pie twist on an oil and garlic recipe. Topped with fresh spinach and diced tomato. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Grilled Chicken Breast Dinner

Grilled chicken breast lightly seasoned. Served with your choice of potato or pasta. Comes with choice of soup or salad and fresh Italian bread.

Shelly's Traditional Pizza

19" Large Pizza (12 Cut)

Our version of the regular pizza with choice of red or white sauce.

16" Medium Pizza (8 Cut)

Our version of the regular pizza with choice of red or white sauce.

13" Small Pizza (6 Cut)

Gluten Free Pizza (Small)

Our version of the regular pizza with choice of red or white sauce.

Shelly's Sicilian

20" Large Sicilian (16 Cut)

13" Small Sicilian (8 Cut)

Shelly's same great crust just thicker. It has a different sauce too.

Specialty Pizzas

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Grilled or fried chicken dipped in buffalo sauce with cheese and ranch dressing. Variations of shelly's traditional pizza topped with specific items.

EBUT Pizza

Variations of shelly's traditional pizza topped with specific items.

Hawaiian Pizza

Ham, pineapple, & cheese with pizza sauce. Variations of shelly's traditional pizza topped with specific items.

Tomato & Spinach

Tomato, spinach, & cheese with our white sauce. Variations of shelly's traditional pizza topped with specific items.

Gluten Free Pizza

Variations of shelly's traditional pizza topped with specific items.

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Grilled or fried chicken dipped in BBQ and cheese. Variations of shelly's traditional pizza topped with specific items.

Shellzones

Shelly's Version of the Calzone

Shelly's dough filled with her blended cheese and ricotta cheese. It comes with a side of marinara sauce.

Extras

Extra Dressing

Garlic Butter Sauce

Cheese Sauce

Shredded Cheese

Sides

Fries

Side of Macaroni & Cheese

Mashed Potatoes

Side of Pasta

Cole Slaw

Veggie of the Day

Applesauce

Beverages

Soda (2 lt)

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, & mountain dew.

Cans

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, & mountain dew.

Gallons

Regular turners & diet turners.

Pints

Regular turners, diet turners, lemonade, & blend.

Pepsi (24 oz)

Quarts

Regular turners, and diet turners.

Bottled Water

Desserts

Carrot Cake

fluffy carrot cake with cream cheese icing

Raspberry swirl cheesescake

creamy raspberry swirl cheesecake

New York style cheesecake

Thick creamy slice of cheese cake

Photos

+65 photos

+64 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Ubereats

Doordash

Trycaviar

Slicelife

Dine

Recent Reviews

My first time at this place was September 21st for a birthday party. The service was EXCELLENT, food was great! Would recommend this place for a fun get together....👍🏾👍🏾

September 2025

Went to shellys for the first time tonight. Her place was recommended to me by my son's father in-law. Best pizza i have had around the burg. Lisa and Joe were very nice . They came out to talk to us. We had great friendly service as well. I would recommend it to anyone. Thanks for the delicious pie! Leo and Doug

September 2025

KATIE WAS GRRRREAT!!
Best waitress we ever had...
Oh yeah, the food was phenomenal!!
We never expected such an awesome salmon dinner at a pizza shop.
You guys got to try this!!

September 2025

More Reviews

Shelly Pie Pizza

Customers' Favorites