I cook at the bar next Door. I get his cheese steak hoagies and he makes it just like I want it with extra mayo American cheese, lettuce and ketchup (the Jersey way lol) it is so bomb..Sometimes I ask for extra meat just to be greedy, but it bomb without it???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hoagies
Kelly Donovan
Food is always excellent! Hot and fresh, accurate and fast! We love Fellini’s Penn Hills! Its our go to spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Stallion, White Pizza,
Lisa Penn
Used to be my favorite local pizza place. They must have switched ingredients, the quality & taste ( and after taste) were awful. Extremely disappointed. The cook & delivery driver were very pleasant. That was my last visit. Too much competition to ot taste good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Abby Popp
Everything I've ordered has always been delicious! (Hoagies, pizza, wings) Best in the area.
J C
Called to place an order for the first time. I called back because $30+ for 1 large cheese pizza and bread seemed high. The owner answered and became really sarcastic, defensive and agressive just because I was asking why the pizza cost so much when I only wanted cheese. After questioning his pricing of charging double topping for just cheese, he abruptly went into a fit and yelled at his workers to cancel my order, when all I did was ask questions.If you're going to have higher prices than most other pizza shops, then you should be able to explain and justify it to customers without throwing a fit like a toddler. And you're the owner?
Service: 1
David Goliath
They tried to over charge me for a pizza, when I asked them to explain the charges, the owner, Joe, told the guys to THROW AWAY my order. I wasn't even disrespectful, just wanted to know why I was overcharged from what their menu prices were. The employee who took my order was super nice and friendly, but "Joe" makes me hope this place goes out of business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jim B
Not gonna bash the food. Actually it’s good. Just can’t understand why it’s taking a week for me to collect $140 I won on the poker machine. Tired of being told come back! $140 is a tank of gas. Had no problem taking my money when I lose. Anyone know the owner of this franchise? Appreciate any help and thank you!
Greg Mellon
I orderd the "Italian stallion" pizza. It arrived with no peperoni and no salami.
tjfarri1
Ordered 2....TWO cheeseburgers and cheese fries. They delivered ONE double cheeseburger and fries, with 2 Litter pop. Total came to $22!! Never again!
They had good food but my recent order was very much sub par...the pizza was not fresh dough..very thin and the toppings were non-existent..two pieces of pepperoni per slice...talk about cheap and skimping..they have gone down hill very badly..never again.
Tammy adams
This is what Fellini Pizzeria Steak and Cheese looks like in person. To be honest this was the worst steak and cheese I’ve ever had. Very little meat everything mash up together like baby food. steak, red onion green peppers mushrooms and very little cheese & too much bread. If it’s a pizza place stick with the pizza.
Toni Ayala
Amazing pizza and hoagies! Def my favorite in the Penn Hills/monroeville/Verona area! I order almost every week! It is a bit expensive so look for coupons before ordering.
Kimberly Porter
This place is wildly unassuming on the outside, but the food is Soooo tasty! We had pizza and burgers. The pizza was comparable in taste to NYC pizza (if that has meaning for you). The burger was juicy with a good char taste (and the bacon was crispy and done). You can only do take out, but it'll be worth it when you get it home.
Robert Fox
Haven't had a bad pizza from the Penn Hills branch yet.
I cook at the bar next Door. I get his cheese steak hoagies and he makes it just like I want it with extra mayo American cheese, lettuce and ketchup (the Jersey way lol) it is so bomb..Sometimes I ask for extra meat just to be greedy, but it bomb without it???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hoagies
Food is always excellent! Hot and fresh, accurate and fast! We love Fellini’s Penn Hills! Its our go to spot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Stallion, White Pizza,
Used to be my favorite local pizza place. They must have switched ingredients, the quality & taste ( and after taste) were awful. Extremely disappointed. The cook & delivery driver were very pleasant. That was my last visit. Too much competition to ot taste good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Everything I've ordered has always been delicious! (Hoagies, pizza, wings) Best in the area.
Called to place an order for the first time. I called back because $30+ for 1 large cheese pizza and bread seemed high. The owner answered and became really sarcastic, defensive and agressive just because I was asking why the pizza cost so much when I only wanted cheese. After questioning his pricing of charging double topping for just cheese, he abruptly went into a fit and yelled at his workers to cancel my order, when all I did was ask questions.If you're going to have higher prices than most other pizza shops, then you should be able to explain and justify it to customers without throwing a fit like a toddler. And you're the owner?
Service: 1
They tried to over charge me for a pizza, when I asked them to explain the charges, the owner, Joe, told the guys to THROW AWAY my order. I wasn't even disrespectful, just wanted to know why I was overcharged from what their menu prices were. The employee who took my order was super nice and friendly, but "Joe" makes me hope this place goes out of business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Not gonna bash the food. Actually it’s good. Just can’t understand why it’s taking a week for me to collect $140 I won on the poker machine. Tired of being told come back! $140 is a tank of gas. Had no problem taking my money when I lose. Anyone know the owner of this franchise? Appreciate any help and thank you!
I orderd the "Italian stallion" pizza. It arrived with no peperoni and no salami.
Ordered 2....TWO cheeseburgers and cheese fries. They delivered ONE double cheeseburger and fries, with 2 Litter pop. Total came to $22!! Never again!
Great white pizza.
Restaurantji Recommends
They had good food but my recent order was very much sub par...the pizza was not fresh dough..very thin and the toppings were non-existent..two pieces of pepperoni per slice...talk about cheap and skimping..they have gone down hill very badly..never again.
This is what Fellini Pizzeria Steak and Cheese looks like in person. To be honest this was the worst steak and cheese I’ve ever had. Very little meat everything mash up together like baby food. steak, red onion green peppers mushrooms and very little cheese & too much bread. If it’s a pizza place stick with the pizza.
Amazing pizza and hoagies! Def my favorite in the Penn Hills/monroeville/Verona area! I order almost every week! It is a bit expensive so look for coupons before ordering.
This place is wildly unassuming on the outside, but the food is Soooo tasty! We had pizza and burgers. The pizza was comparable in taste to NYC pizza (if that has meaning for you). The burger was juicy with a good char taste (and the bacon was crispy and done). You can only do take out, but it'll be worth it when you get it home.
Haven't had a bad pizza from the Penn Hills branch yet.