Il Pizzaiolo Warrendale

Good food but very expensive.

Be prepared to not look up if you sit at the high top tables in the bar area as the overhead light fixtures are so heavy with dust and grime - it will make you faint. For sure that stuff falls off in your dish… it was that heavy with grime & dust.

Always a great place for a delicious meal! Great food, great drinks, great service!! Their pizza is always so good as are their Italian dishes. Seasonal drinks are divine! Also, bob’s limoncello…. Just yum!!!!!

We were there for a private event and the food was amazing. I'm planning on coming back to enjoy more

Large portions, we just each had appetizers for dinner which was plenty

Delicious food and large portions! The service was friendly, attentive and fast.

We go here often and have seen a decline.was doing yard work and didn’t want to cook so got take out. Not the best idea. Apps are good but the pasta portions for thirty dollars is horrible. Sauce was decent but not great. Love their zucchini and arranchini. Stick to pizza and apps. Not many non chain restaurants these days so wish it was better.

Super swanky place, with chill old world vibes. Lively staff and friendly front of house who greets you on entry. Got a Margherita Pizza and it's easily top 3 woodfired pizza in the region. Very similar if not better than 91 Wood Fired in North Canton. It took them less than 15 minutes to take my order and have the pizza in my hands. Will get it again without hesitation!

I was there for a dinner with a pre-selected menu. The food I tried was all good. I prefer to choose my own salad dressing but was already on the salad. If possible, I would have eaten it plain. The pizza appetizer was okay, but not topped as I like. Entrees that I tried were good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Definitely gone down hill. The market square location had delicious food. Now the sauce tastes like it's from a can and the rest of the menu has become inconsistent. The meatballs and gnocchi are very salty.

I rarely leave a bad review or a poor tip but unfortunately tonight had to be an exception due to the service. I was so excited to bring my long-distance girlfriend here who is visiting from Italy to try America's take on authentic Italian food. We ordered an appetizer, two pizzas, and two pastas.

We knew we probably wouldn't finish it all (and so what if we did anyway right?) but she is only here for a limited amount of time and we wanted to try a lot of things. After giving the order to our server Neil, he said "that's it??" and snarkily laughed at the two of us (neither of us were laughing back). I understand he was maybe trying to joke but this came off to us, and especially to my girlfriend, as quite rude since in Italy ordering multiple courses and a lot of food is the norm (Remember also this was in an ITALIAN restaurant).

Wouldnt you want your customers to order more food anyway? Throughout the night he continually made several comments about this that just did not land well and sort of just ruined the mood and made us feel uncomfortable. As someone who has been in the service industry for almost 8 years I have almost never left a bad tip or even bothered to leave a bad review but this really upset us. Maybe it seems like an exaggeration but again it really just did not come off well with all the comments about how much we were ordering.

Can you imagine if this is the last dinner we were spending together while she is still here? I certainly will not be coming back here and neither will she.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Best Italian food I've ever had. Staff was incredible! 10/10 highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had a fantastic dinner. The service was perfect and the manager, Jason, is more than accommodating. Made you feel right at home. 🤩🔥🤩

Today, my family of 4 went for lunch. I wish I caught the servers name. She was fantastic ? We had the charcuterie board and calamari w/peppers. (Get the peppers with the calamari! They are bites of deliciousness and I am going to try to duplicate it at home.) We all super, enjoyed our entrees. The Shrimp Diavolo pasta is the best around. Again, our server made the meal with her timing, disposition and knowledge. We will definitely return!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A really great place to have pizza pasta, and a world-class tiramisu. I thoroughly enjoyed the wood oven pizza - there are lots of vegetarian options if you’re looking for. The place is upscale, so please be ready to spend a lot more than what you think. As I was traveling 300 miles I was in not that awesome appearance, but definitely work on it if you plan to get more respect from the person who’s serving you

Amazing cocktails, great food and maybe if they can work a little bit more on their service - that would be ideal

Vegetarian options: As I mentioned before, there are some vegetarian options as well

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Wine Selection, Tiramisu Cake