Sugar N’ Spice
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
32 High St, Waterford
(814) 796-0060
About Sugar N’ Spice
Sugar N’ Spice Reviews
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu


Sugar N' Spice is a restaurant located in the historic Eagle Hotel in Waterford, PA. They serve amazing Amish food, including the popular Amish sampler, which features three dinners on one plate. The portions are generous, ensuring that diners are often prepared for leftovers. The menu accommodates those with dietary restrictions, and the kids menu is a plus for families. The staff is friendly and wonderful, making it a great spot for a dinner outing. On special days, like Thursday, they offer a turkey dinner that feels just like Thanksgiving. The food is homemade, always served fresh, and looks delicious. The historic setting and beautiful interior add to the charm, making Sugar N' Spice a hidden treasure in this small town that attracts visitors even from over an hour away.