The Main Street Creamery

17 Main St, Wellsboro
(570) 948-9558

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Marty Jelliff

It was delicious ,not long wait either,,,very good!

Alex Lehman

Amazing homemade ice cream in a fantastic old mansion.

Jeremy Bowling

This place has the best ice cream in the game. Honestly I have tried so many of the flavors here and never once have I been disappointed. Everything is made with such care and the staff that they have working here are always so delightful and friendly and they seem like they genuinely enjoy helping you pick out your ice cream. I am telling you if there is one place in wellsboro to stop at it is this ice cream parlor.

Amy Miskiewicz

Forgot pictures! Sorry. The ice cream was excellent, nothing too crazy flavor wise. I enjoyed Moose Tracks which had a lovely caramel stripe throughout in a fresh, crunch waffle cone. Hubby had a maple ice cream which he said hit the spot. Definitely worth the stop! The building is one of the many well maintained old homes in Wellsboro.

Lori Forrester

The vanilla ice cream was truly amazing. I just wished they had gluten free cones.

Robin SoutheastPA

Great ice cream, loved sitting on the porch having a cone.

Bradley Weatherby

Absolutely love their homemade ice cream!! Service is always exceptional!!

Jonas Sterner

I KNOW I KNOW...it seems really weird to post a picture of the toilet but I got your attention. They have the CLEANEST bathroom. They are super nice and the ice cream and other treats are simply the best. Don't pass this place up. So so good

Curt Wengert

Delicious house-made ice cream! So good!

Charlotte McIntosh

Ice cream is always awesome at the creamery. It was nice to sit outside and enjoy our cones. We had chocolate and salted caramel cone and a strawberry and vanilla cone. We are always met with a smile.

Digger Sherman

This place is beautiful and the ice cream is out of this world!!!

Sean Oros

Some of the best ice cream I've ever tasted. And I've tasted A LOT.

Bob Burkhart

Great icecream. I wish they would carry some sort of dairy free options.

Kayt Maeve

Amazing flavors! Almost no one has banana icecream or other unique flavors so this was such a treat that I went back a 2nd time! The cookie monster and the PB butterfinger flavors are genius (and delicious). A must visit! The building is also historic and beautiful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandy Bricker

Cute little ice cream and icecream soda shop.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...