Pepper Mill

CLOSED
$ •

About Pepper Mill

Pepper Mill is a charming, little restaurant that serves excellent food. Their spicy chicken cordon blue cheesesteak is a standout, paired with crispy fries and a generous side of wiz. Delicious milkshakes complete the meal. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, this small sandwich shop is a neighborhood gem that has been around for decades. The food is authentic in terms of what a Philly Cheesesteak is, and the fries are awesome. Customers have been ordering from Pepper Mill since they were kids, and it hasn't changed in all that time, which they appreciate.

Recently, Pepper Mill accommodated a hockey team of 10-year-old boys, showcasing their great staff who handled the situation with ease. However, some long-time customers have noted that the building is showing signs of age, with a run-down interior that is disappointing. Despite this, the Italian special remains a favorite, and the cheesesteak stromboli continues to impress those who return after years. While there are mixed feelings about the overall condition of the restaurant, many still find the food worth the drive and plan to visit again for its delicious offerings and friendly, familiar atmosphere.