The Tomato Shack salad & pizza co, West Chester

31 W Gay St, West Chester
(484) 887-0241

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Grilled Cheese \u0026 Tomato Basil Combo
Grilled Cheese & Tomato Bisque Combo
Smashed Avocado Turkey Bacon
Craft Your Own Salad
Craft Your Own Pizza
Chicken Sandwich Bar
Tomato Basil Soup DF
Couch Club Sandwich
Cheesy Breadsticks
Tomato Basil Soup

Menu

Featured items
Grilled Cheese Combo (VT)
Our signature blend of cheese topped with arugula on our buttery house focaccia. Served with our famous Tomato Basil Bisque
Tomato Basil Soup (DF)
16" Plain Jane
Plain pizza, cheese then red sauce, garnished with Grana Padano
Cheesy Breadsticks
freshly baked breadsticks topped with garlic sauce and farmers cheese, served with tomato sauce and garlic butter*Vegan and Gluten Free options available
Kickin Chicken
Chipotle spread, chicken, romaine lettuce, avocado, & pepper jack cheese
16" Coach Tony
Tomato sauce on top of farmers cheese, pepperoni, basil, grana padano & hot honey drizzle
Personal Signature Margherita
Roasted garlic spread, tomato, farmers cheese, Grana Padano, fresh basil with a signature margherita sauce
Personal Coach Tony
Tomato sauce on top of farmers cheese, pepperoni, basil, grana padano, & hot honey drizzle
16" Godfather
Roasted garlic spread, farmers cheese, roasted red peppers, prosciutto, arugula, grana padano & balsamic glaze drizzle
Food Pyramid
greens, strawberry, cucumber, candied pecan, farmers cheese, chicken with balsamic vinaigrette.
Holy Chipotle
greens, chicken, red onion, black bean relish, smashed avocado, tortilla chips with chipotle dressing.
Build Your Own Sandwich
Your choice of bread, spread, and 4 "included" toppings. *Additional toppings are extra
Couch Club
Buttermilk ranch spread, house-roasted turkey, tomato, bacon, smoked cheddar, & avocado
Chipotle Chicken Chowder Soup (NOT DAIRY FREE)
Personal Godfather
Roasted garlic spread, farmers cheese, roasted red peppers, prosciutto, arugula, grana padano & balsamic glaze drizzle
Pear Fection (VT)
greens, fresh pear, gorgonzola, candies pecans, & dried cranberry with balsamic vinaigrette. VT
Personal Craft your own
Craft your own personal pizza with your choice of sauce, farmers cheese and three "included toppings" (*additional toppings are extra)
Demeter (VT)
greens, olive tapenade, cucumber, pickled red onion, tomato, house croutons, feta, organic quinoa with green goddess*We apologize as roasted chickpeas are discontinued
16" Florentine
Roasted garlic spread, spinach, farmers cheese, fontina, ricotta, with sea salt, black pepper & lemon zest
16" Buffalo Chicken
Choice of hot sauce or our house ancho-agave sauce with chicken, gorogonzola, farmers cheese, & celery

Our Cafe Salads
Pear Fection (VT)
greens, fresh pear, gorgonzola, candies pecans, & dried cranberry with balsamic vinaigrette. VT
Holy Chipotle
greens, chicken, red onion, black bean relish, smashed avocado, tortilla chips with chipotle dressing.
Anchor Cobb (GF)
greens with pickled red onion, grape tomato, pork bacon, smashed avocado, gorgonzola, & chicken with ancho-agave hot sauce & vegan ranch
Food Pyramid
greens, strawberry, cucumber, candied pecan, farmers cheese, chicken with balsamic vinaigrette.
What About Cobb (GF)
greens, hard-boiled egg, tomato, bacon, chicken, gorgonzola, & smashed avocado with ranch
La Fiesta
greens, chicken, pico de gallo, mango, pepper jack cheese, & tortilla strips with chipotle dressing.
Porty Pig
greens, bacon, portobello, whipped goat cheese, croutons, dried cranberry with balsamic glaze drizzle and balsamic dressing
CYO SALAD
Your choice of greens, any 4 "included" toppings, choice of dressing and a house baked roll
Demeter (VT)
greens, olive tapenade, cucumber, pickled red onion, tomato, house croutons, feta, organic quinoa with green goddess*We apologize as roasted chickpeas are discontinued
Hail Caesar (VT)
greens, croutons, Grana Padano, hard-boiled egg with pesto-caesar dressing.
Tuscan Farmhouse (New)
greens, roasted tomato, roasted red pepper, red onion, white bean, basil, house crouton, grana padano with Italian vinaigrette

Our Sandwiches
Kickin Chicken
Chipotle spread, chicken, romaine lettuce, avocado, & pepper jack cheese
Couch Club
Buttermilk ranch spread, house-roasted turkey, tomato, bacon, smoked cheddar, & avocado
Perky Turkey
Cranberry mayo, house-roasted turkey, goat cheese, sliced pear, & arugula
Vernazza
Prosciutto, fontina, roasted red pepper, & spinach with house pesto
Atomic Veggie (PB)
Pesto Mayo, roasted red pepper, avocado, vegan cheese, & spinach
Grilled Cheese without soup (VT)
Our special blend of cheeses topped with arugula on our buttery house focaccia
The Baja
Spicy Chicken or Seitan, sauteed peppers & onions with cilantro, pepper-jack, spinach and vegan chipotle sauce
Buffalo Joe
Roasted chicken, gorgonzola, farmers cheese, avocado, romaine, ranch & ancho-agave spread
Chickaletta
house chicken salad, arugula, sliced apples, farmers cheese with balsamic glaze
Build Your Own Sandwich
Your choice of bread, spread, and 4 "included" toppings. *Additional toppings are extra
Grilled Cheese Combo (VT)
Our signature blend of cheese topped with arugula on our buttery house focaccia. Served with our famous Tomato Basil Bisque
Smokehouse
Smokey house BBQ Sauce, cider braised pulled pork, banana peppers, smoked cheddar, & caramelized onions

Our Personal Pizzas
Personal Craft your own
Craft your own personal pizza with your choice of sauce, farmers cheese and three "included toppings" (*additional toppings are extra)
Personal Coach Tony
Tomato sauce on top of farmers cheese, pepperoni, basil, grana padano, & hot honey drizzle
Personal Godfather
Roasted garlic spread, farmers cheese, roasted red peppers, prosciutto, arugula, grana padano & balsamic glaze drizzle
Personal Florentine
Roasted garlic spread, spinach, farmers cheese, fontina, ricotta with sea salt, black pepper, & lemon zest
Personal Buffalo Chicken
Choice of hot sauce or our house ancho-agave sauce with chicken, gorogonzola, farmers cheese, & celery (shown with ancho-agave)
Personal Veggie House Special
Roasted garlic spread, portobello mushrooms, artichoke, spinach, feta, & farmers cheese
Personal La Bamba
Chipotle Sauce, House Roasted Chicken, Tortilla Chips, Sour Cream, and a mix of Pepper Jack, Cotija and Farmers Cheeses. Try adding Jalapenos for a little extra "picante"!
Personal Plain Jane
Plain pizza, cheese then red sauce, garnished with Grana Padano
Personal Cousin Sal
Garlic sauce, Italian sausage, farmers & provolone cheese, banana pepper, red onion, roasted tomato with basil & grana padano
Personal Signature Margherita
Roasted garlic spread, tomato, farmers cheese, Grana Padano, fresh basil with a signature margherita sauce

Our Large Pizzas (16")
16" Plain Jane
Plain pizza, cheese then red sauce, garnished with Grana Padano
16" Craft your own Pizza
Craft your own large pizza with your choice of sauce, farmers cheese and three "included toppings" (*additional toppings are extra)
16" Buffalo Chicken
Choice of hot sauce or our house ancho-agave sauce with chicken, gorogonzola, farmers cheese, & celery
16" Coach Tony
Tomato sauce on top of farmers cheese, pepperoni, basil, grana padano & hot honey drizzle
16" Cousin Sal
Garlic sauce, Italian sausage, farmers & provolone cheese, banana pepper, red onion, roasted tomato with basil & grana padano
16" Florentine
Roasted garlic spread, spinach, farmers cheese, fontina, ricotta, with sea salt, black pepper & lemon zest
16" Godfather
Roasted garlic spread, farmers cheese, roasted red peppers, prosciutto, arugula, grana padano & balsamic glaze drizzle
16" La Bamba
Chipotle Sauce, House Roasted Chicken, Tortilla Chips, Sour Cream, and a mix of Pepper Jack, Cotija and Farmers Cheeses. Try adding Jalapenos for a little extra "picante"!
16" Veggie House Special
Roasted garlic spread, Portobello mushrooms, artichoke, spinach, feta, & farmers cheese
16" Signature Margherita
Roasted garlic spread, tomato, farmers cheese, Grana Padano, fresh basil with a signature margherita sauce

Soups & Sides
Cheesy Breadsticks
freshly baked breadsticks topped with garlic sauce and farmers cheese, served with tomato sauce and garlic butter*Vegan and Gluten Free options available
Garlic Knots
dozen knots tossed in garlic butter with grana padano and parsley - served with tomato sauce for dipping*vegan available
Kettle-cooked chips (GF)
Joe's Sweet Potato Chips
Tomato Basil Soup (DF)
Chipotle Chicken Chowder Soup (NOT DAIRY FREE)

Desserts
Cookies
Sold in pairs; You pick, chocolate chip, double chocolate chip, or oatmeal raisin.
Fudge Brownie
Vegan Maddie Bar (contains nuts)

Drinks
Fountain Soda
Made with organic sugar cane; Fair trade certified
Lemonade
Crosscut Iced Coffee
Iced Coffee
Black Tea
Organic, Unsweetened
2 liter soda
Kombucha
No juice, No extracts, No concentrates; Brewed in Phoenixville
Herbal RaspberryTea
Unsweetened
Culture Pop Can
Probiotic Soda
Harney & Sons Bottled Juice
Organic
Bottled Water
Mountain Valley Sparkling Water

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+81 photos
Photo credit: google
+80 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I love tomato shack sooo much the food feels like home and the costumer service feels like family the food is so amazing and I’ve been to tomato shack so many times and it’s felt like community to me
August 2026
First time here and we will definitely be coming back! This place offered vegan options that are DELICIOUS! We had a sandwich and pizza 10/10. Service 10/10. Vibes 10/10. Atmosphere 10/10. Customer service 10/10. Jessica made my birthday so special!! Highly recommend this place!!
July 2026
It was an all around awesome experience eating at the tomato shack. Everyone was super friendly and helpful, service was fast, the food was amazing, and there were some great gluten free and vegan options. The gluten free pizza crust was the best I’ve ever had, and the veggie pizza with vegan cheese was delicious. 10 out of 10, can’t wait to go back!
July 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Sedona Taphouse - 44 W Gay St Ste 1
New American, Beer Bar, American, Seafood
Turks Head Cafe - 111 N Church St
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Coffee Roasteries, Cafe
Santino's Tap & Table (West Chester) - 40 E Market St
Pizza, Italian, Bar, Cocktail Bar

The Tomato Shack salad & pizza co, West Chester

31 W Gay St, West Chester, PA 19380
(484) 887-0241