Restaurants near West Milton

“Great service, great price, great taste! I was very surprised with how big the portions were for the cost! 10 out 10 would recommend!”

“We had ice cream waffles cones that were very tasty. Be nice to have more seats on the inside when it’s near 90 degrees outside. We’ll go again to a beautifully restored old building.”

“My partner and I had dinner to celebrate our five year anniversary and Elizabeth’s did not disappoint! The lamb was incredible. My partner had the trout and loved it. We would absolutely celebrate here again. The wait staff was super friendly and the atmosphere was romantic and clean. 10/10 all around!”

“Great food and Jessica was wonderful! Will be back when we are in the area. Thank you!”

“Worth every penny & the trip itself.”

“Less-is-more, and that’s done here so well! Not only is the coffee served with simplicity, but the environment and the space are free from clutter, allowing for people to establish connection with people, without distraction ☕️”

“Loved this place. We ate here for lunch on a college tour. We all had the chicken shawarma. It was delicious. We would come back and have no concerns recommending it to others!”

“Best hoagies I know of, anywhere. Unbeatable bread. Best alfredo sauce you'll come across. Chicken alfredo pizza is fantastic, or fettucine alfredo (with shrimp, chicken, broccoli mix and match). Very very nice people, always great service if eating in and a nice dining experience. The owner / head chef is always working hard but makes time to say hello to pretty much everyone he has an opportunity to engage with. Noticeably friendly guy. Great place all around, seriously awesome food at Amatos Norry.”

“Rather unusual that a place known for very good smoked meat entries would have such a good fish dinner. We've had the broiled haddock on several occasions and find it always enjoyable. Nice seasoning - not too salty- moist but not drenched in oil, as is often the case. Very good baked potato and coleslaw. An excellent value Be aware prices shown on this review site are out of date. Cash or Check only with available ATM.”

“Our subs that my son picked up tonight were excellent. You have the best subs around”

“The food is impeccable and the options cover a very broad range of ingredients. We find the Chicken Florentino, the Shrimp and Clams Marechira, The Ciro's Special (shrimp and scallops) to be very appealing to our tastes. Many of the specials they offer are delightful, as well. Definitely our "happy place"!”

“Great place for Live music! Everything’s pretty awesome, and people are very friendly!! Highly recommended!!!”

“Delicious food and very friendly staff and atmosphere! Nice little lunch spot after being at the playground across the street. Will definitely be returning and I can’t wait to try one of the bakery items next time!”

“Best Chinese food in the area… never disappoints!”

“Penne alla vodka was the best I’ve ever had, 10/10!!! Waitress was also outstandingly nice.”

“The staff was really nice sam opened the door for us as we arrived and was very friendly guiding us to our table pam was also very friendly the food was delicious my only complaint is the price but in their defense everything is expensive right now and it was on par with most sit down restaurants”

“This restaurant has a lot of nostalgia for people who grew up in the area. The pizza is unique in it's style and flavor. The grinders are crispy, fresh, and delicious. The server at the counter was friendly and helpful.”

“The best cakes ever! I even splurged for fresh baked bread and a fruit pastry when I picked up my cake. Will be back soon to shop for Easter baskets! Highly recommend.”

“Best wings around!!! Actually know how to put the sauce on the wings and are ACTUALLY buffalo flavor!!!”

“Any bad reviews this place has gotten are completely UNJUSTIFIED! I know these people and they treat everyone with the utmost respect. If you would ever have a problem, they would fix it immediately, but chances are you will never have a problem. Only 2 people make the subs and they make them exactly the same, consistency is always the winner!”

“I stopped here yesterday for a late lunch/early dinner after spending time in Lewisburg. I had stopped before and had a turkey dinner with all the trimmings and it was fantastic!! Yesterday, I ordered the honey dipped chicken tenders, baked potato, and the baked corn. Again it was fantastic!! The baked corn is some of the best I have ever eaten!! I make a point to eat here when I’m down that way. The parking lot is full quite often which usually means….good food!!! The service was great both times!! The girls have been friendly and the food has been pretty quick coming out. To the cook….your food is amazing and very delicious!!! Looking forward to my next trip south just to eat there again!!! Thanks for a wonderful experience at your restaurant!!!”

“The best stromboli ever. We will definitely be back to try your pizza wings”

“We visited to hear Cass and the Bailout Crew on a Friday night. The band was great, the food and service were good. The beer was excellent. The big negative for us was that we had to reserve for 10 people with a $100 down payment and final payment had to be on one card. This meant scrambling when a couple backed out and having to have cash on hand to give to the person paying with the card. I hope Jackass reconsiders this policy.”

“My husband and I went yesterday for the first time. It was amazing! I loved the food and the atmosphere. I will definitely be back!!”

“It's a great place with outstanding ice cream. It's often very busy. I gave only 4 starts because they have a 5 dollar minimum for credit cards, as almost the entire menu is under $5. If I go alone, I have to buy two ice cream cones...

It would make more sense to charge people a convenience fee, or just accept credit cards openly - it's 2024, no one likes cash anymore.”

“I’ve been going with my daughter for over a year now . She’s going on three years old . She loves to play on the slides, and then grabbing something to eat.”

“Wagging tail coffee company does a fantastic job all around from the great tasting coffee , to the customer service I would highly recommend stopping in along your travels like myself . Coffee surpassed my expectations and the kind lady's at the counter helped me order . I am from South Jersey and this coffee hit a home run for me”

“what a refreshing place to grab some delicious macaroons and a incredible latte we tried the double dog dare you iced latte talk about a refreshing yet subtle incredibly tasty treat! The environment in there was welcoming and so supportive 100% recommend we will be returning!!”

“Awesome people, food and beverages!!! Definitively know how to have a great friendly community event!! Congratulations to 150 years of service to the community!!! Stay safe friends”

“friendly staff just tried as new to community food was good. they definitely got that other diner beat an prices are good. will be back again!”