Mama Pepino's

110 W Main St, West Newton
(724) 872-0338

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Gary Glass

Ordered for the first time last night and my sons keep talking about it being the best pizza in the area. We have tried them all. The prices are low compared to quantity and quality of the food. Will definitely be ordering again.

Jessica T

The service is always amazing but almost every time we order the food is cold and soggy the only thing saving it every time is the amazing wings they have! They did offer us a refund after letting them know we were not only missing an item when delivered but that everything but the wings were cold and soggy. The person answering the phone is always friendly and helpful.

Aiden Verkleeren

Went in there with an average order for 6 people to get food I called in my order at 4:20 and the women told me it would be ready in 40-45 minutes. I pull in to the parking lot at 5:10 and pay for my food, but they didn’t even start cooking it nor did they tell me it would be another hour before it would be ready. After standing there for 20 minutes and witnessing one of them employees take money from his pocket twice and give it to the cash register to give him a bigger bill and they don’t even want to tell me where my food was. I was very disappointed and asked for my money back as they weren’t going to give me my food. I would stay away from this place as they don’t have anyone managing the employees inside.

Miloh Ortolona

The wings are probably the best wings I’ve had in my life. I’m not over exaggerating and the guy. At the Cast register is so nice and caring

Ryan Snyder

Operator was very rude said they close at 9 but they closed at 10.

Tracy Kosh

Ordered pick up . Plain extra cheese. I specifically ask if they would please bake the bottom on the light side , not to dark I'd really appreciate it
4/8/25

Tracy

Ordered pick up . Specifically ask to please don't let the bottom get to dark . I would appreciate it so much . The young lady assured me , no problem we can do that. Apparently they can not do that. Very disappointed I am. Was happy with the extra cheese pulled it off and ate it so not a complete loss.

Jaclyne Cavalcante

The food is good! I had it a few times now. Great service too. Thank you.

Pitbull

Got a pizza here it was awful cheese was burnt very little sauce called them they said oh well don't eat this slop got a pizza from Italian village awesome in b v clean pizza shop not a dirty dump like this place F U

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ashley Marano

The food is always 100% here. I order 3-4 times a month easily, via take out and delivery. The staff is always super friendly when I pick up, and the delivery drivers are ALWAYS here way before they say I can expect them. Bottom line is, this is the best pizza around this little local area. Period! <3

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Balls, Wings, Cheese Sticks, Spinach Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Halopino Poppers, Hoagie

John Y

Awesome pizza. Pro first responders too so that's always a plus. Piping hot and delish. A most order spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Always Evolving

Everything is top notch here. I highly recommend the spicy chicken calzone with fried mozzarella sticks and I like my food slightly burnt, they know what that means and take care of my orders better than my evil older step sister took care of my cat while I was out of town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary Lou Hall

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Spinach Pizza, Steak, Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Halopino Poppers, Hoagie

Sasantra Wyatt

Delivery driver literally just came and banged on my door like he was the police! Then had the nerve to lie and say he called my phone and didn’t. Bad service never will support again because of that driver! Literally just happened two minutes ago!

Service: 1

eric andriechack

Great pizza, the staff and the owner are all really nice people.
Their gyros and calzones are really good too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...