York Fish & Oyster Co

1369 W Market St, York
(717) 848-2867

Recent Reviews

Marleny Hernandez

Great sea food, Best service.

John Morrison

Dissatisfied!!! I asked for fresh crab meat non pasteurized. Fresh not frozen. I got home to a pre frozen slacked out crab meat. It was fully loaded and drenched saturated in juice the crab meat tasted horrible. Lost my business first time getting seafood and the last. Thought I found a nice place apparently not. Asking the lady if it was any good and quality she relied we have hi standards here I trusted her word. Sad.

sam Rannels

Ordered a half a bushel of crabs today. Let me tell you I was shocked how good they were owners of the seafood place are very nice and have awesome quality crabs very happy.

Barry Koser

Best local place to buy seafood. Always fresh and best quality. They have the best crabs. They weigh their crabs after steaming and sell them according to weight so you know what you are buying.

Robert Lee

Oh my, very nice! It's a good sign when you walk in to a fishmonger and smell fresh seafood, not fish! I traveled with a friend who is local who told me about this fabulous fish purveyor that was so good. Her review was an understatement! Everything that looked fresh, was! I tried the monkfish fillet and prepared it as directed and it was wonderful!

Catman Doo

A very nice selection of fish, and other assorted seafood goodies!They also have T shirts, and assorted gift items. A good place to get seafood, and support a local business. They have been in York for a long time. That says something! Stop by, and take a look!

Kim Henry

Nice fresh selection and excellent customer service!

Samantha Downey

Great service and highly recommend their oysters!

Gary Lee

Oh my, very nice! It's a good sign when you walk in to a fishmonger and smell fresh seafood, not fish! I traveled with a friend who is local who told me about this fabulous fish purveyor that was so good. Her review was an understatement! Everything that looked fresh, was! I tried the monkfish fillet and prepared it as directed and it was wonderful!

paul macek

Smell the crabmeat b4 u buy it!! Bought from here and the smell was nauseating!! That was 6 months ago...never been back since!!! Imo, if u dont want to waste your $$ and get sick ,dont go

Krystal Guynn

I came in Saturday and spent almost 500$ here for my daughters birthday. The crab legs were great. But unfortunately the shrimp were spoiled. Had to throw away all of them the smell was horrible. Am hoping something can be done because this is very upsetting. It was the jumbo shrimp.

Chris L

Usually come for king crab legs. Those are meaty and big, the price is high though. I also get the catfish filets which were ok looking last time, but other fish filets did not look so great. Maybe it depends on the day. Clams were great.

Cheryl Standiford

I love this place. Always so helpful and their products are always so delicious. Very fresh.

Sharon Ehrhart Maitland

Amazing seafood and super friendly staff.

Dan Kelshaw

Picked up some steamed shrimp, coleslaw, and fresh seafood. The fresh seafood was great, the coleslaw was dry and flavorless, the steamed shrimp were overcooked and very chewy. Will just stick with the fresh seafood from here on out. Staff was very friendly.

Load More