Only gave it 5 Stars because I was not a fan of the sweet sauce... But then I asked them to mix the sauces and Pizza was fantastic and the sauce was good. So sweet! Great pizza . Num num num num num
Jeff Peck
Fantastic
Jofenna Bradford
One of our favorite places to order ❤️
Sherri
This pizza is great. I always get thick, lightly baked, and sweet sauce. The parking lot is now expanded, so it's easy to find a spot.
Gregory James
This is my favorite pizza. The sweet sauce with pepperoni is seriously perfection. I've had all the great pizzas in our valley and all the top rated in NYC, and Gerry's is still quite possibly the best. The service is also top notch. Can't recommend this place enough.
Erin C
We called a bit late to order a pagash and when they said they were out we were so disappointed and were awww no. My daughter came in from Pittsburgh and was dying for one. He said I can make one for you. So very nice of them. I can't put into words how happy we are. Thanks again. Love their pagash!
Gary Boots JR
Pizza is their only business, and they do it very well
Derek Metzger
I mean it's kind of a staple in the area so that says a lot already but it is a credit well deserved! Build your own pizza with all the norms plus other toppings you wouldn't normally see. Sweet sauce is a whole other take on pizza and opens the door for new tastes and combos. Def give it a try!
Kathleen Lockman
Loved all the pizza and the staff was fabulous
Jody Fletcher
POV: you’re ordering Gerry’s on a Friday night “hi can i place an order?” “sure. let me find out the wait time… …yes we can have that ready tomorrow morning at 7 am” “perfect see you then” not really but honestly would wait until tomorrow morning, or next week. i don’t care. absolutely obsessed with this pizza !! at the busiest it could be a 2+ hour wait, which tells you everything you need to know about how awesome this pizza place is. 10 stars from me
We travel 2 hours just to have Gerry’s thin crust pizza. We first tried it because of David Portnoy’s pizza review on Instagram and Gerry’s did not disappoint. A menu full of toppings, sweet pizza sauce being one of the options which is how we like it. Friendly waitress! Well worth the trip even in a snow storm. Can’t wait for our next road trip.
Daniel Courtney
Ordered 2 medium pizza’s, one regular pepperoni and one mushroom with sweet sauce, they both had sweet sauce, next to zero cheese and the sauce tasted like tomato paste with sugar in it. Definitely wouldn’t serve this pizza to anyone.
Only gave it 5 Stars because I was not a fan of the sweet sauce... But then I asked them to mix the sauces and Pizza was fantastic and the sauce was good. So sweet! Great pizza . Num num num num num
Fantastic
One of our favorite places to order ❤️
This pizza is great. I always get thick, lightly baked, and sweet sauce. The parking lot is now expanded, so it's easy to find a spot.
This is my favorite pizza. The sweet sauce with pepperoni is seriously perfection. I've had all the great pizzas in our valley and all the top rated in NYC, and Gerry's is still quite possibly the best. The service is also top notch. Can't recommend this place enough.
We called a bit late to order a pagash and when they said they were out we were so disappointed and were awww no. My daughter came in from Pittsburgh and was dying for one. He said I can make one for you. So very nice of them. I can't put into words how happy we are. Thanks again. Love their pagash!
Pizza is their only business, and they do it very well
I mean it's kind of a staple in the area so that says a lot already but it is a credit well deserved! Build your own pizza with all the norms plus other toppings you wouldn't normally see. Sweet sauce is a whole other take on pizza and opens the door for new tastes and combos. Def give it a try!
Loved all the pizza and the staff was fabulous
POV: you’re ordering Gerry’s on a Friday night
“hi can i place an order?”
“sure. let me find out the wait time…
…yes we can have that ready tomorrow morning at 7 am”
“perfect see you then”
not really but honestly would wait until tomorrow morning, or next week. i don’t care.
absolutely obsessed with this pizza !! at the busiest it could be a 2+ hour wait, which tells you everything you need to know about how awesome this pizza place is. 10 stars from me
Restaurantji Recommends
Always clean
Awful customer service
best pizza around hands down
We travel 2 hours just to have Gerry’s thin crust pizza. We first tried it because of David Portnoy’s pizza review on Instagram and Gerry’s did not disappoint. A menu full of toppings, sweet pizza sauce being one of the options which is how we like it. Friendly waitress! Well worth the trip even in a snow storm. Can’t wait for our next road trip.
Ordered 2 medium pizza’s, one regular pepperoni and one mushroom with sweet sauce, they both had sweet sauce, next to zero cheese and the sauce tasted like tomato paste with sugar in it. Definitely wouldn’t serve this pizza to anyone.
Loading...