Hoby's Hoagies & Pizza

On Tuesday 6/24/25 I arrived to pick up my order placed and paid for on DoorDash. Upon arrival a hand written closed sign was placed on the door. The time was 9:28 pm, and according to the times, they were not going to close until 10. The man who greeted me at the door who clearly worked there could not have been more rude. I simply said that I had an order for pick up which he did a very heavy sigh and then started lying and gaslighting me. Including that they were closed and they had no orders. Then proceeded to go check for my name, which he never came back to answer me instead I had to walk up to him again to check. Which he immediately went ahead and said we had no orders again, so I deserved no answer I suppose in this case? He was extremely rude to me, telling me I must have placed the order after 9, which was incorrect as it was placed at 8:56. Then when I mentioned I didn’t appreciate the attitude, he just said “well that’s your problem I guess”. According to some of the recent reviews maybe I’m glad I didn’t end up with a terrible cooked pizza.

Ordered 2 ham cosmo and the is the meat we got. After I called they said they pre portion the meat. To maybe 2 oz

Terrible. Do not attempted to go. $62 later.,,,, Cheesesteak meat burnt, kids burgers burnt as well as the buns, meatball sub burnt.

I ordered the turkey and cheese cosmos and the cheesesteak egg rolls, and everything was a mess. The cosmos were soggy, the lettuce was wilted and sad, and the whole thing tasted like it had been thrown together hours ago. The cheesesteak egg rolls were greasy and bland, with hard, undercooked green peppers that ruined the texture. Nothing was fresh. Honestly, it was just nasty. I won’t be ordering again.

Great take out food!

Update 4/21/25: tried again, ate the insides of stromboli due to getting burnt bottom this time. See pictures.
Older original post: literally the best stromboli... ONCE. Have tried probably 5 times since to get what I thought was great, but cannot. The straw that broke this camel's NOT GOING BACK was ingredients I specifically asked not to be on were added, and when I called, the owner said it wasn't on the slip ( I was looking at the slip taped to the box that clearly had my instructions on it). Ended with him saying I'll have a credit. Went today and asked what the credit was. $10..... I PAID after tip 30$ for something I DIDN'T EAT. I'm sure they won't go broke without my money, but they CAN take the credit and shove it up their A.... literally

Ordered a pizza with two toppings, and there were barely any toppings on it at all. It was basically cheese pizza with a few scattered pieces of chicken and vegetables. Pretty disappointed.

I ordered lucky strike and my order was wrong. When I called back to bring it back and have it replaced he apologized for giving me the wrong thing but said he can’t make me a new order, instead he can give me 4 dollars off my next order. This is not acceptable , I’m disputing it with my card and never returning again. Don’t eat here. .

Bad customer service and bad pizza

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

1st of let me say I'm mad at myself for not taking pictures of the food. It was so good we couldn't wait to eat it. We'll let me say I got cheese steak egg rolls, and hot sausage. The cheese steak eggs rolls were sooo good and the sausage was very tasty. My son got the BLT and it was a good size sandwich, and his girlfriend got the turkey BLT which also looked amazing, we also got the nacho fries...yummy. We definitely be back. Highly recommend you try this place if you already haven't

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Love every meal I get and hate every second I spend here, especially recently. It feels like everyone there is upset and trying to catch up/catch their breaths. I hope they can all get a break soon because it is uncomfortable even picking up food now.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak

$28 something for a pizza that has less then $3 into it is pure greed.
Wil never buy from again. Wow just wow

Messed up the order came to my house and gave me my correct order and let me keep the original order. Best service in Williamsport. Definitely a go too!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They sell 7", 14" and 21" hoagies! My husband ordered a 21" cheesesteak. My husband, son and myself were all able to taste it, very good. I also ordered a 14" Italian. I don't think I'd get that again. It didn't have much meat on It. There are a couple tables outside on a deck around the back of the building where you can eat your food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hoagies, Cheesesteak

Always been happy with the food and staff were always nice

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Hoby's Cheesesteak Hoagie, Loaded Fries, Hoagies, Philly Cheesesteak, Cheesesteak