Mileto's Sub Shop in Newberry

Fantastic food! Great Service!

The cheesesteak was top notch! We were visiting from Michigan and this place is a gem. Friendly service. Food was fresh, and tasty. They don’t make them like this back home. Will definitely return when we come back to PA.

I cannot rave enough about their food! So very delicious! The best cheesesteak I have had in Williamsport to date! The staff is extremely friendly and went above and beyond to ensure my first experience was 10 stars!!! I can’t leave out the fries! So good!!! Highly recommend!!

miletos has very nice and polite staff and also I would recommend going there for their 1lb cheesesteaks because they are the best I've had ...so if you are looking for a cheesesteak I 10/10 recommend going there to get their 1lb cheesesteaks they are so so delicious and the staff is very pleasant to talk to and they are quick and efficient at getting your order ready and they get your order right

Haven't had a awesome cheese steak in a long time and you guys knocked it out of the park very fresh and hot I'll definitely be back for more awesome job keep up the good work!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesesteak, Cheesesteak Sub

Old fashioned looking sub shop. We got the special for a Saturday night which is two whole subs for 25.00. They are ENORMOUS and PACKED. VERY good. Worth it. We read reviews about negative experiences with customer service and figured we could handle it.... they were extremely personable and very informative and brought our food out to us and cracked a joke. I would highly recommend this place if you're craving a really good sub...this is the place for it for sure.

Atmosphere: 5

I wish the new owners good.luck

I wasn't too pleased with the pizza I received. Seemed to be hurried and just thrown together.

The steak pounder was huge; the cosmos were fine. It is a sub shop, not much atmosphere, lol. The girl that took it order was efficient.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Famous Cheesesteak

Great food. I really miss the Montoursville spot. Everyone loved it. I think it was overwhelming cause they were always hopping. But very glad there still uptown. Very awesome subs and cool people

Famous Pounder Cheesesteak is world class.
I wish the cashier was a bit more kind though.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Famous Cheesesteak

Today 8/31/2024 I made 34 calls to try to make a food order. Someone picked up on the 35th call and asked me to please hold which I agreed to. I waited 6+ minutes and nobody ever returned to the phone. If you would have simply said we are very busy please try another time I would have been fine. I have been a faithful customer for over 5 years since I left Newberry Subs for the same rude treatment. I think the owner at least I hope the owner would not approve of this sort of treatment to their loyal customers and I hope she finds out!

Great food my sub was amazing and toasted perfectly. However the customer service was not that great. When i came in and openned the door. Most them had smirk looks on them. then the young lady who took my order, when i walked to go get chips. I could hear her mocking when i asked for peppers n oil on the side. Food was amazing but i dont think i will returning with such rude workers that sit there and give customers dirty looks when they order subs from you guys!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 2

Cheese steak Bliss! Service with a smile and a dope sandwich warmer!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Famous Cheesesteak

A small little sub shop that's HUGE on quality and value. Great prices and amazing food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Famous Cheesesteak, Cheesesteak