Mileto's Sub Shop in Newberry

2127 W 4th St, Williamsport
(570) 323-0103

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Famous Cheesesteak
Cheesesteak Sub
Buffalo Chicken
Italian Hoagie
Add Fries

Menu

Featured items
Famous Cheesesteak
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Deep Fried Oreos (4 pcs)
4 cream filled chocolate cookies wrapped in a crispy, vanilla enhanced corn flake breading, deep fried and topped with powdered sugar! OH SO GOOD!
Bacon, Cheddar, and Ranch Fries
Chicken Tenders Basket
Chef Salad

With a Fork
Chef Salad
Cheesesteak Salad
Lettuce, Tomato and fried onion topped with 8oz of seasoned sirloin and american cheese. Your choice of dressing. Served with or without french fries on top. Please include choice of dressing. Ranch, Blue Cheese, French, Thousand Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Italian, Homemade Hoagie Oil.
Chicken Steak Salad
Grilled Chicken Salad
8oz of Delicious Grilled Chicken Breast Strips atop Lettuce, Tomato and Onion topped with a Shredded Mozzarella and Provolone Cheese blend and your choice of dressing!
Tossed Salad
Lettuce, tomato and onion with provolone cheese and your choice of dressing. Please include choice of dressing. Ranch, Blue Cheese, French, Thousand Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette,Italian, Homemade Hoagie Oil.
Tuna Salad
Tuna on a bed of lettuce, tomato and onion with provolone cheese. Your choice of dressing. Please include choice of dressing. Ranch, Blue Cheese, French, Thousand Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Italian, Homemade Hoagie Oil.

Finger Food
Chicken Tenders Basket
French Fries
Funnel Cake Fries
An order of a dozen fries topped with powdered sugar!
Fried Cauliflower
Fish and Fries Platter
Kids Nugget and Tot Basket
Curly Fries
Deep Fried Oreos (4 pcs)
4 cream filled chocolate cookies wrapped in a crispy, vanilla enhanced corn flake breading, deep fried and topped with powdered sugar! OH SO GOOD!
Funnel Cake (5 inch)
Missing fairs and carnivals as much as we do? This 5" funnel cake will help ease the cravings! Deep fried and topped with powdered sugar! They are thick, fluffy and delicious!
Bacon, Cheddar, and Ranch Fries
Bacon, Cheddar, and Ranch Tots
Fried Mushrooms
Mozzarella Sticks (4 pcs) with Sauce
Chicken Tenders
3 Large white meat chicken tenders and a pile of french fries.
Tots
Chicken Nuggets (6 pcs)
Fried Pickle Chips
Mac and Cheese Bites
Corn Nuggets
Onion Rings
Broccoli Cheddar Bites
Pierogies
Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls
4 Cheesesteak Eggrolls with fried onions in them.

Cold or Cosmo Hoagies
Italian Hoagie
Capicola, Baked Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese
Cheese Hoagie/Cosmo
Made with freshly sliced provolone cheese.
Pizzarolla Hoagie
Meatball Hoagie
Made with Thompsons beef meatballs, Ma Mileto's original recipe homemade sauce topped with Parmesan cheese. If made as a cosmo, topped with provolone cheese. If you would like a different kind of cheese please indicate in the notes.
Fried Haddock Hoagie
Roast Beef Hoagie
The "Big R" It's Huge Hoagie
It's HUGE! A pile of ham, turkey, roast beef, cheese.
Ham Hoagie
Turkey Hoagie
Grilled Chicken Hoagie
8oz on a half and 16oz on a whole of fresh white meat grilled chicken breast! Any way you want it!
Tuna Hoagie
Our Tuna is made with mayo only. No onions, celery or spices added.
Ham and Turkey Hoagie
A generous combination of ham and turkey!
Regular Hoagie
Dutch Loaf, Chopped Ham, Salami, Provolone Cheese
Veggie Hoagie
All Veggies any way you want it! With provolone cheese.
Salami Hoagie
Canadian Bacon Hoagie
BLT Hoagie
Mixed Cheese Hoagie
Perfect blend of provolone, swiss and american cheeses! Tastes amazing as a cosmo!
Grinder Hoagie
A regular sub with all the fillings and more provolone cheese on top toasted to perfection.
Stromboli Wrap
Choose your wrap flavor. Please add in the notes if you would like White, Wheat, Tomato or Spinach wrap. If you don't specify you will receive a white wrap. A wrap stuffed full with Salami, Capicola, Ham, Pepperoni, Provolone, Mozzarella and sauce. Baked in the oven to perfection! So good and a healthier alternative to the traditional stromboli while definitely filling you up likely with leftover
Half Size Chicken Parm Sub
PLEASE ADD IN NOTES IF YOU WANT BREADED OF GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST! OTHERWISE YOU WILL RECEIVE GRILLED. 8oz of chicken on a half and 16oz of chicken on a whole. On a toasted garlic hoagie roll with mozzarella cheese, homemade sauce and pesto. If you do not want pesto, please add that in the notes.
Whole Size Chicken Parm Sub
PLEASE ADD IN NOTES IF YOU WANT BREADED OF GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST! OTHERWISE YOU WILL RECEIVE GRILLED. 8oz of chicken on a half and 16oz of chicken on a whole. On a toasted garlic hoagie roll with mozzarella cheese, homemade sauce and pesto. If you do not want pesto, please add that in the notes.

From The Grill
Hot Sausage
Hot Italian Sausage, chopped to perfection! 10oz on a half. 20oz on a whole.
Famous Cheesesteak
An entire pound of chipped sirloin, seasoned to perfection on a whole! And a half pound on a half sub!
Chicken Cheesesteak
Half pound of seasoned white meat chicken on a half. Whole pound of meat on a whole.
Canadian Bacon Cheesesteak
Our famous pounder cheesesteak mixed with canadian bacon! Flavor bursting!!!
The Carson
Half pound of our famous steak, topped with crisp fries, golden aged whiz and ketchup on a wrap! It's amazing!
Half Size Boss Burger
All beef burger on a toasted bun. You get 10oz on a half and 20oz on a whole. Includes 3 cheeses! Cooper cheese, american cheese and whiz! Topped with bacon, onion rings, mayo and bbq sauce. Its HUGE and absolutely delicious!
Bacon Steak and Chicken with Whiz
A GIANT Portion of Real Bacon, Our Famous Steak and Chicke. Any toppings you like. If you would like a different cheese please indicate.
Bacon Cheeseburger
Comes on a hoagie roll and it's humongous!
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
8 oz. on a half. 16oz on a whole. We use franks red hot!
Cheeseburger
10oz on a half. 20oz on a whole. We chop our burger meat to fit the hoagie roll.
Canadian Bacon Cheeseburger
Delicious Thompsons Cheeseburger mixed with canadian bacon! It's SO GOOD!
Half Size Three Cheese Steak
Our Famous Cheesesteak with American, Provolone and Aged Cheddar Sauce! Any toppings you would like! So cheesy and delicious! Garden will be on top of this and cheese on the very bottom. It is very juicy so please know this ahead, since the cheese is on the bottom!
Whole Size Boss Burger
All beef burger on a toasted bun. You get 10oz on a half and 20oz on a whole. Includes 3 cheeses! Cooper cheese, american cheese and whiz! Topped with bacon, onion rings, mayo and bbq sauce. Its HUGE and absolutely delicious!
Whole Size Three Cheese Steak
Our Famous Cheesesteak with American, Provolone and Aged Cheddar Sauce! Any toppings you would like! So cheesy and delicious! Garden will be on top of this and cheese on the very bottom. It is very juicy so please know this ahead, since the cheese is on the bottom!

Keto Friendly and Gluten Free options
Famous Cheesesteak
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Cauliflower Pizza (8")
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Chicken Cheesesteak
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Canadian Bacon Cheeseburger
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Big R
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Roast Beef
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Double Cheeseburger
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Bacon Steakn Chicken
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Canadian Bacon Cheesesteak
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Bacon Cheeseburger
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Grilled Chicken
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Ham and Turkey
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins.
Any Other Hoagie
Original or Italian and jalapeno flavor cauliflower thins. Choose Cole hoagie type or it will be cancelled
Everything Flavor

Pizza
Pizza
Large Italian Hoagie Pizza
An amazing creation! Italian hoagie meat (capicola, ham, salami and provolone) on a pizza. Simple and so delicious! Top it with all the hoagie toppings you want, it's great with sauce, mayo, hot peppers, whatever you like!
Large Pounder Cheesesteak Pizza
A pound of our famous seasoned sirloin steak atop of a fresh baked Lycoming Bakery pizza shell! Choose any toppings you desire, whether it be in the garden with mayo, or with sauce, green peppers, fried onions and mushrooms! Or whatever you dream up! If you don't see it in the options here, put it in the notes!

Beverages
Pepsi
16oz
Diet Pepsi
16oz
Mountain Dew
16oz
Root Beer
16oz

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+52 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+51 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The cheesesteak was top notch! We were visiting from Michigan and this place is a gem. Friendly service. Food was fresh, and tasty. They don’t make them like this back home. Will definitely return when we come back to PA.
April 2025
I cannot rave enough about their food! So very delicious! The best cheesesteak I have had in Williamsport to date! The staff is extremely friendly and went above and beyond to ensure my first experience was 10 stars!!! I can’t leave out the fries! So good!!! Highly recommend!!
March 2025
miletos has very nice and polite staff and also I would recommend going there for their 1lb cheesesteaks because they are the best I've had ...so if you are looking for a cheesesteak I 10/10 recommend going there to get their 1lb cheesesteaks they are so so delicious and the staff is very pleasant to talk to and they are quick and efficient at getting your order ready and they get your order right
February 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Diamond Square Market Deli Cafe - 2131 W 4th St
Cafe, Coffee & Tea, Deli
Finish Line Cafe - 2014 W 4th St
Bar, Cafe
Riepstine's Pub - 913 Arch St
Brewpubs, Pubs, American

Mileto's Sub Shop in Newberry

2127 W 4th St, Williamsport, PA 17701
(570) 323-0103