Coomb's Tavern / Bones n Shells

2575 S Queen St, York
(717) 854-8146

Recent Reviews

Jay Shenk

Fast service. We enjoyed everything we

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bonnie Balmer

A bit noisy. Only received 1 sushi menu for 2 people. This made it difficult to choose what we wanted by the time the server came to the table. I know better for nest time. Gater bites were quite tasty, and Grandma roll just as good as I remembered.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Laura S.

This is a very fun bar. Their sushi Is some of the best I've tried in the area. They have pool tables and often have local live music!!

Harry T.

When we walked in, we were given 3 different menu's. Monthly, Specials, and their house fold out menu. Overwhelming... We ordered medium-cooked cheeseburgers (something simple). When our meals were served, the burgers were well done and dry. The chef of the day placed cold cheese slices on top of the burgers, and another person in our group had only 3 mushrooms hidden under his cold cheese on their burger ! DON'T order the chicken tenders. They are chopped, processed and pressed into tenders, sort of like the nuggets you get from the clown fast food drive-thru. The servers (very short staffed) did their best to accommodate their full dining & bar areas. We were not impressed with the quality and presentation of the food. We were advised by several friends that they were disappointed as well.

Barbara H.

We wanted to dine here to experience 3 restaurants in one venue. We had reservations for 2 for Valentines Day made in advance. I couldn't recalled if I specified a booth. I requested booth when I got there. Told none were available. However, two were open the entire time we dined. They have a Coomb's tavern menu which we chose. The Crab Soup was delicious, and we also ordered the Crab Cakes. They were filled with meat and you can choose a 5 Oz. Single or an entree with 2 Crab Cakes. Old Bay French fries were average and was not impressed with the Cole Slaw. Prices were high for what we ordered. I will return to try their Steak . I'll keep you posted. They also need to room to accommodate their guests. Give it a try and let me know if I'm being too critical. Love the 3 menu concept. This has potential.

Kelley

I love Bones and Shells! Fantastic food and service!! My daughter and I visit often. Live music and new specials every day.Parking: Plenty of parking!Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Deviled Eggs, Cheeseburger and Fries, Seafood Pasta with Spicy Vodka Sauce, Blooming Crab Tempora Coated in Dino and Eel Sauce, Shark Bites, Caprese Salad Fresh, Soup, Cream of Crab, Burger, Prime Rib Sandwich, Wings, Salads

Michael W.

Went there last night (12/5/23) 2 of us ordered baby back ribs and got St. Louis ribs. Very disappointing. One ordered cream of crab soup and shrimp salad sandwich-they were delicious. Finally I ordered a sandwich and that was average at best. Will never go there again. What a shame the menu looked so good. Service was excellent. Ambiance was ok.

Sharon Barnes

Fantastic food and excellent service. It was our very first visit and we had a great time. I got the French dip sandwich and I can tell you it was the best French dip I have ever had. Will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shaneen Scandrol

The food was amazing and the price was good.My husband had the ribs, crab cake, shrimp with 2 sides. The ribs were huge and they were amazing the next two days.I had crab and shrimp with 2 sides and that was amazing as well. Very little if any filler. Only sad part was we missed out on the corn bread.Highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina Enfield

The food was great! The server we had was slammed and still did an amazing job. Just not my crowd. But still fun.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christine B.

Have been there a few times in the past few weeks. The Crab Cakes are amazing and everything else we had was delicious. The service was great and we will definitely be going back again!

Melissa T.

Among arriving on a Friday night at 6 pm we walked in to a sign that read "Wait to be Seated". Not one employee in sight. Also at the entrance was a tip jar full of cash that anyone could have easily taken and walked out with because not one employee was waiting to seat us. We had to walk up into the actual restaurant until we were noticed and the older staff member said just seat yourself. Sir then please take down your "Wait to be Seated" sign. The waiter never told us there were nightly specials and we only knew after we ordered as we overheard another waitress tell a different table. Service was mediocre for only a half full restaurant as we waited minutes among minutes for drink refills. The food was not bad but not outstanding either. I don't foresee that we will be visiting there again.

Caryl F.

We sat in the restaurant part in a booth. Had the ribs, they were so tough you had a hard time trying to eat them. Looked down under the tableand there was a rib bone some French fries with ANTS on then. Told the waitress but didn't seem to bother her. Needless to say we won't ever go back.

Alikat N.

Highly recommend outside bar!!! The girls out there are awesome! I cannot explain why, But eating in the bar or outside on the deck is by far better food than eating in the dining room! It makes no sense but I'm telling you the food is different. We sat outside we love it that's an hour ago to the girls are great we never wait for a drink and food was spot on

Larry S.

Portions are nice sized but you pay for it. Over priced and over hyped. Used to be a great place to hang out. What put me over the top was seeing how poorly the staff was treated. New ownership needs to learn how to manage. that's a Non starter for me

Load More

Coomb's Tavern / Bones n Shells

2575 S Queen St, York, PA 17402
(717) 854-8146