Dottie's Crab Shack

2899 Carlisle Rd, York
(717) 764-9705

Recent Reviews

Sort by
La Vashia Luckey

Delicious crab balls! The Mac and cheese needs more crab and seasoning. I would come back again to try more of their menu. Great atmosphere and service.

Kelly Moore

We just got the wings that are a Wednesday special in numerous flavors and Brett was our favorite! The seafood salad is delightful!! Do not buy the small you will regret it like I did! Bones less wings were cooked perfectly! Service was fast and friendly!

Sonya Gettys

Had crab legs the clusters for my granddaughter birthday 3 days after Christmas they were excellent
Was hungry for them last night ordered some and they were horrible water logged and soggy
Very disgusting and disappointing
For the price they should not even be this way ! I normally don’t give a local business a bad review, but I’m very disappointed for my crab legs and the price ! Do better Dottie’s I even said to the two boys when I picked what what the heck do you call this and they looked at one another and shrugged their shoulders

Thank you Dottie’s that you responded back to my review very nice of you ! I was disappointed in how they were , it’s very kind of you to re do my order ! Like I said I don’t like to give bad reviews I’m not a karen lol , I’m not looking for a free crab legs I was disappointed on how the boys struggled their shoulders didn’t offer to make it right I think that freaked me more than anything , after spending over 100 last night and us doing a large order 3 days after Christmas ! I appreciate you offering to make it right would next Sunday work around noon ? Please feel free to message me on facebook !
I appreciate and support local businesses ! I changed my ratings for your business ! Thanks again for the reach out and correction I appreciate that !!!! Have a great week

dave lauer

Great food! Friendly helpful staff. We will return for sure.

Black Dog Military Antiques

Great food as always, thank you again for an excellent New Year's Eve dinner!

Carmela Gimgerich

Delicious crabs! Steamed on the spot!
This was my second visit and never disappointed.
Friendly staff, worth the four hour drive!!!

Ory Bonney

There wings are the best around for MILES

Craig Ilgenfritz

I order food for pick up ....the place is empty no customers and they tell me to show up at 305 pm I do and no ones around and finally a girl comes out saying they never put my order in ....I highly recommend you avoid this place ...poor service even when there's no customers

Toolinaround2

Amazing! In land seafood crab shack, best I’ve had. Try it today, you will not be disappointed!

Kimberly Kelley

Me and my daughter just left here. Food was great, staff were very nice and helpful. The place was very clean, including the restroom. Well definitely be back.

Evette Chapman

Dotties crabs are the best in the Pa region

Michael Paules

Bought a dozen crabs last week. It was a mixed size special for $40. Several of the crabs were extra larges and one was a jumbo. The rest were medium to large size. All were full of meat and very tasty. An excellent bargain!

Tyler Howard

If I could give a zero, I would! This is the second time in a row that I called and placed an order with Dottie’s crab shack and they forgot to cook my order each time .I had company coming over waiting on the food each time it was placed ridiculous. Don’t waste your time.

mamakin 823

Not Maryland crabs! I have had crabs here on 2 occasions. Both times the crabs had no seasoning. Both times they had a fishy taste. I won't be back.

Jim Schrum

The food was awesome and amount was great

Loading...