Isaac's Restaurant - South York

Waitress extremely rude and food was served one at a time, so we each were done eating before the next person was served...

$20 for a deli sandwich is wild!

Waiter was great . The cashier was horrible . She said “ thanks for having children they are the best control “ “ I won’t have any it isn’t that hard to not get pregnant” honestly if I had the time and my children were not present I would have gone off on her and told how unprofessional and rude she was !

I Can always be sure of quality food, fast service and pleasant wait staff.

I ordered carryout for my teenage daughter. I needed to pick her up from basketball practice at 8pm. So I made sure to order her food so that I could pick it up by 7:42pm. When I arrived, my order wasn't even started yet. Not a big deal, but I waited until 8pm for it. Then I overheard the worker tell the manager (or whoever was in charge tonight) that she dropped the sandwich and to help her fix it. When she handed me the bag, I asked if she dropped it and she said no. I overheard the other lady say there wasn't even bread on the bottom of the sandwich. I was late picking up my daughter, then when we opened the box to look at the sandwich, my daughter said even the bread was ripped apart and it wasn't even a sandwich, but just looked like a mess thrown into a box. I just couldn't let my daughter eat that. So I returned around 8:20pm and the manager approached me rudely. Told me they were closed. But they don't close til 9pm. I asked for a refund, she said she couldn't do it because I ordered online. I asked for the actual manager on duty contact information, because this is the 2nd time I've had a bad experience at this location in a row. Wouldn't give it. So I left the bag of food and walked out. I would have appreciated honesty, but instead I was treated rudely and lied to. I would have gladly came back if they would have offered to make a new sandwich. They know they should not have served this to anyone! My only regret, not taking a picture to add here of what it looked like.

Overpriced for “alright food”. Tomato soup about the best thing they got l and even then will pay 10$ for a large that’s the size of a small. Also got rid of bread bowls for some reason as if the tomato soup doesn’t already not fill you up. Now you have no bread to eat after. Issac’s really disappointing and falling apart after the years. Wouldn’t be surprised if the franchise went out of business charging as much as they do.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

First time here and absolutely a fan now!! Service was wonderful and the sandwich and deli sides were absolutely delicious. They're also getting local beer soon. Will definitely be returning again. Very happy to find this gem! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pickled Vegetables, Broccoli Salad

First time here and absolutely a fan now!! Service was wonderful and the sandwich and deli sides were absolutely delicious. They're also getting local beer soon. Will definitely be returning again. Very happy to find this gem! 😋

So disappointed. Haven't there in awhile and the food & prices changed drastically. Used to be able to take the grandkids there for a reasonable price, but the prices have almost doubled, the food nor as much. Older grandson said, " My sandwich was good but not $15 good.: Younger grandson had hair in his applesauce. Probably won't revisit for a long time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Chips, Pickled Vegetables

Staff is friendly. However, the sandwiches are way over-priced with no proper sides, and the quality of the sandwiches is something that I could easily make at home. Issac’s is not what it used to be 10 years ago.

quite location. Food is great if desiring sandwich's and soups. Burger way to expensive for what is given($20ish). Waitress Destiney is a total rockstar and me and my wife look for her every time we go. But to be fair, all the staff is pretty good and friendly.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Way way way! Too expensive! I paid $23.53 with tip for a slider sized sandwich a near empty bag of chips drink and a small cup of soup. I was still hungry but could not afford to get anything else as I used way more than my typical budget for work lunch. It cost me an hour an a half's pay to eat lunch here. Lesson learned ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

quite location. Food is great if desiring sandwich's and soups. Burger way to expensive for what is given($20ish). Waitress Destiney is a total rockstar and me and my wife look for her every time we go. But to be fair, all the staff is pretty good and friendly.

Great food. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

In my 10 years of visiting an Isaac's in Pa, I have yet to have a bad experience. I frequently am picking up quarts of the delicious Pepperjack tomato soup for out of state family

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pickled Vegetables, Isaac's Famous Pepperjack Tomato Soup, Isaac's Reuben