Marcello's Pizza

2323 Carlisle Rd, York
(223) 232-4047

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Chicken Wings

French Fries

Cheese Pizza

Quesadilla

Cannoli

Photos

+24 photos

+23 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We’ve been ordering pizza for a few years. Most of the time it is very good. I get that everyone has their bad days. However the last pizza we ordered was not very good. Tasted like all parmesan cheese and seasonings and no mozzarella. We couldn’t even eat the left overs. Two of us ate one piece each and threw the rest away.

August 2025

We tried out this restaurant when it first opened and wasn’t impressed ,we tried it again now months later and were surprised! My boyfriend got an Italian sub and was overjoyed saying it was better than his favorite sub place ,which I never heard him say. I got a shrimp avocado salad and man it was amazing !!! Fresh veggies and ripe Avocado,and shrimp made just right ! We are already talking when we will order again ! So I highly recommend!

August 2025

My daughter and I stop here just about every Monday, after her boxing class. The staff are always friendly, the place is always very clean and as for the food, never been disappointed. My daughter loves their Sicilian-style pizza. I get a little something different every time we go, they usually have pre-made pies, by the slice, always a good quick option, and they have a large menu to choose from. Their food has never disappointed.
I have yet to ask for my personal favorite...

July 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in York, PA

Marcello's Pizza

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Marcello's Pizza