Mexitaly Brick oven Brewhouse

Food was amazing. Our waiter was excellent. Absolutely, will be coming back.

So hubby and I ate here today…. As soon as you walk in the smell is incredible and the employees behind the wall greet you very nicely. We were seated immediately and our server Garrett oh my gosh, I don’t even know where to begin. He was fantastic and every meaning of the word he was polite he was funny. He was happy. He was knowledgeable. He was the sweetest person I have ever met in my life and I’ve met a lot of people. More people who own restaurants should have servers like Garrett the compassion inside this person is off the chart he was the sweetest person you’ve ever wanna meet in your life. He knew that menu like nobody’s business. Which in a lot of restaurants, you’re lucky if one of the servers knows what’s on the menu let alone know what it’s about not Garrett. He knew everything and if he didn’t have the answer, he found the answer with Greg the owner who I must say was just as nice and polite and knowledgeable as Garrett. If you wanna try somewhere new and you’ve never been here, you have to try this place. I am telling everybody about this restaurant. The food was phenomenal . We have not one complaint from the front door to the server to our food and out the door again. My husband and I had such a fantastic time here we want Garrett as our server from this point on nobody else I know that probably sounds critical but when you get a good server, that’s who you want every time you go back Garrett was efficient. He was fast. He could walk by your table and grab the dishes without even looking at you. He was that fast. He always checked on us even if it was just for a napkin he’s that good Thank you again Garrett and Greg, the owner for making our day wonderful Thank you for an awesome time Bill and Debbie from Florida

One of our family's favorite spots in York. A unique blend of Mexican and Italian dishes, as the name indicates with a bonus small on-site brewery. The food and beer served are always consistent. I usually trend towards the Mexican dishes but today I decided to try the Exotic Mushroom Cannelloni and I just found my new favorite! I am not a huge fan of crazy amounts of strong mushroom flavor-- this dish was heavy on the cheese and butter, then filled with spinach and mushrooms, exactly what i was looking for. Def highly recommend. Hubby loves the mushrooms on the other hand and got his favorite mushroom pizza. My kid's go to is always the kids pizza. They make excellent light beer, hefeweizen and pils are very crisp and crushable. Very family friendly and great food. Outdoor seating as well.

Great atmosphere. Great service. The food was excellent. It says brewhouse, but being sober, I was still comfortable and had a great time

A local staple for fresh vegan options!!!

Great food , great service! The only thing I didn’t understand why they put a Long Island ice tea in a short glass?

Food was excellent! Waitress had an attitude.

We had the Mexican side of the menu. Did was good. Neat themed restaurant.

In our recent awful experiences with this establishment, the orders are wrong more often than they are right. My wife just drove 20 minutes to pick up what they failed to include in our delivery order only to be told that they gave our order to an employee and would not make her what she ordered. This was a uniquely respectable restaurant in York not long ago.

First time there loved it food excellent, people very nice especially waitress Erin.

I been going here since the old location on Haines RD I now live in Philadelphia for the last 10 years hands down best burritos I ever eaten in my life every time I visit York I have to get one. Nothing in Philly compares to the burritos that greg and his team at mexitaly makes 10 of 10

Love this place. Great food and a cozy atmosphere.

Great food! I love the shrimp tacos, the garlic ginger slaw is amazing!

I will say, their waiter was nice and the atmosphere fine, but the food was not very good and overpriced.

Their $4 side of guacamole was small, pasty and plain. They charged $3 for just the chips and they were worse than Giants store brand bag chips.. Guadalajara right down the road not only gives you free fresh delicious fresh chips and salsa but if you like chunky guacamole theirs is the best hands down. Plus their food is delicious and less expensive.

Their fish tacos were ok only because the cole slaw and pico was yummy (why I even gave them the 2nd star). They only offer fried fish which I prefer not breaded and they only offer black beans which I prefer refried beans, so be prepared for limited options and read the descriptions carefully. The beans and rice were basic and not worth the upcharge.

My bill came to almost $30 and I didn't even like most of it, so I will not be returning here.

Loved the atmosphere and the food was phenomenal. Try their homemade sauces, they are delicious; I like the cherry pepper.