Delicious and interesting crossover of Italian and Mexican cuisine! The fungi pizza was phenomenal.
Richard Weinsteiger
I figure I throw a positive review out there. I been disappointed with some places recently but Mexitaly is always consistent with quality and they are not skimpy with portions.
Anthony Ocasio
Great spot
Richard Hart Heiden
Open spaces. Table seating. Private booths. I was a little shocked by the size of the room tbh.Absolutely authentic cuisine. My order was a to-go burrito w/guac no sour cream. Great hospitality, compassion, leadership-suited deck come meet the aces!I offer up Juarez, MX (founding of the burrito) better have a check-in because this cuisine’s got something that might have a person reconsider their definition of burrito. Go strong! Stay long! I know their bar serves nicely so bring your friends! Muchas gracias! Gratzie!:) Salud.
Pat Montagne
I have never been disappointed with this establishment. Great food and great service.
holly malmberg
Their salads, quesadillas, and burritos are delicious! Their ranch dressing is the best ranch I’ve ever had and it’s rich with dill. I believe it’s made in house, but could be wrong. They should bottle that and sell it to take home.
Michael Murphy
Fun place, food is good. Servers are nice
John Bair
Authentic California style burritos. They make good beer too.
Karen denny
Delish steak burrito
Tim Erwine
Really great food at a good price. Best area micro-brew!I've been to just about every local brewery in the York/Hanover/Lancaster area(~18 or so establishments). This place is on par with the best of the best. The flavors are unique and well balanced. Growler fills are very reasonably priced.The food is delicious and the Mexican/Italian fusion theme is unique. I highly recommend the BBQ Burrito with your favorite meat choice.2022 Edit:No changes, still awesome! Had the tacoritto tonight and it was delicious.2024 Edit:They no longer fill growlers. Bummer.
Everything was delicious! Will definitely go again!
April C
We come to York from Baltimore to eat here on occasion. It is so good. They have an extensive menu, very fair prices, and large portions. The dining room is large and comfortable. If I lived in York I'm sure I would eat here all the time. They have an extensive drinks selection as well. Really there's just nothing to not like about this place.
Raymond Marseglia
Take out was fantastic pickup was quick and efficient
Jennifer Staszak
The fish tacos are amazing here. I have also tried some of the other dishes and so far everything has been great. The mead is also pretty good.
Maggie Mehalko
Ordered side platters and sauces and never received them. The food is good, but make sure you check your bag before you walk away cause they tend not to give you what you paid for.
Delicious and interesting crossover of Italian and Mexican cuisine! The fungi pizza was phenomenal.
I figure I throw a positive review out there. I been disappointed with some places recently but Mexitaly is always consistent with quality and they are not skimpy with portions.
Great spot
Open spaces. Table seating. Private booths. I was a little shocked by the size of the room tbh.Absolutely authentic cuisine. My order was a to-go burrito w/guac no sour cream. Great hospitality, compassion, leadership-suited deck come meet the aces!I offer up Juarez, MX (founding of the burrito) better have a check-in because this cuisine’s got something that might have a person reconsider their definition of burrito. Go strong! Stay long! I know their bar serves nicely so bring your friends! Muchas gracias! Gratzie!:) Salud.
I have never been disappointed with this establishment. Great food and great service.
Their salads, quesadillas, and burritos are delicious! Their ranch dressing is the best ranch I’ve ever had and it’s rich with dill. I believe it’s made in house, but could be wrong. They should bottle that and sell it to take home.
Fun place, food is good. Servers are nice
Authentic California style burritos. They make good beer too.
Delish steak burrito
Really great food at a good price. Best area micro-brew!I've been to just about every local brewery in the York/Hanover/Lancaster area(~18 or so establishments). This place is on par with the best of the best. The flavors are unique and well balanced. Growler fills are very reasonably priced.The food is delicious and the Mexican/Italian fusion theme is unique. I highly recommend the BBQ Burrito with your favorite meat choice.2022 Edit:No changes, still awesome! Had the tacoritto tonight and it was delicious.2024 Edit:They no longer fill growlers. Bummer.
Restaurantji Recommends
Everything was delicious! Will definitely go again!
We come to York from Baltimore to eat here on occasion. It is so good. They have an extensive menu, very fair prices, and large portions. The dining room is large and comfortable. If I lived in York I'm sure I would eat here all the time. They have an extensive drinks selection as well. Really there's just nothing to not like about this place.
Take out was fantastic pickup was quick and efficient
The fish tacos are amazing here. I have also tried some of the other dishes and so far everything has been great. The mead is also pretty good.
Ordered side platters and sauces and never received them. The food is good, but make sure you check your bag before you walk away cause they tend not to give you what you paid for.