Paradise Pizza Express

4265 N Susquehanna Trail, York
(717) 268-8100

Recent Reviews

Robin Jones

Food is Soooo Good! BLT PIZZA is Amazing! HAND TOSSED PAN PIZZA W/ XTRA SAUCE & CHEESE is the Best Ever! FF are Soooo Good! Everything is delicious! This is the only place My Fam gets its PIZZA from........#10

Alexcya Kline

Great prices, great food. Will be coming back more regularly for sure.

Michelle Miller

This was an amazing experience. I ordered ff and a sandwich also a hot sub. Everything was hot and ff were still crunchy. Great experience ?

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Fries, Sub

Travis Harris

Watch out for the extra fees! The food was ok, nothing special, but my real problem is the surcharge they added for credit card use. Please stop adding charges to your customer’s bill and price your menu accordingly. I have no problem with you raising your prices 3% but I have a real problem with the bait and switch practice of advertising one price and charging another at the counter just for using a credit card.

Sherrie Musser

the food and service are fantastic! the fish sub that I ordered was the best I've had in a long time!

Paulette Wilson

First time visit. Bought pizza and steak sub. Very flavorful sub. And they are now my new favorite pizza place!

Dieseldave91 Fubulous

1 star is too much this place. Dude dropped my pizza out the window. Not impressed with the new management, nor the one armed guy at the window.

Bean

The best pizza, loaded fries and subs! We use to order from them weekly until I moved now it's a great treat when visiting family still close by. Great food and customer service!

Mackenzie Wilkerson

Business has gone down the drain for the last year! The way they treat their staff is absolutely disgusting and inhumane. I would highly recommend putting your hard earned money elsewhere!* I am free to share my personal opinion on this business as many others here have done; many 1-2 star ratings. This is not slander or defamation of individuals, solely an opinion of how I view your business. Also I'm not technically a former employee and I'm not disgruntled. I'm voicing my personal views and opinions which I can do; thanks to the constitution our country has had in place for MANY years. What you did to the co-owner of the shop all over Facebook was defamation.

nichole foster

Ordered 2 extra large pizzas that are the size of a large. They used to fill the box. I called and they continued to insist they are extra large. I will not be ordering again for $60+ for this

Alicia M

I’ve lived around the area for over 10 years. Saw the management change multiple times, it’s NOT any better under this new management. They don’t do the famous cheese/sauce swirl anymore. Sauce is really sweet, even the crust is sweet. If you like that, good news for you! Ordered 2 small pizzas, fries & 2-2 liters. 45 dollars! They’re still handing out the menus from the previous owner-false advertisement on pricing/availability. Ordered delivery, showed up over an hour later-we live three minutes down the street-one of the pizzas wasn’t cut, they weren’t well done as we asked for, fries were soggy -FYI they carry crinkle cut now, I personally don’t like them & we would have known not to order them if they’d have their own menus- and they forgot one of our 2 liters. For 45$ I expect more. Wouldn’t recommend and won’t be getting robbed from them anymore. Go to Antonio’s in Goldsboro. That’s good pizza for a reasonable price.

David

Very good food. We love supporting local family owned businesses. We did have a coupon for a pizza. It was delicious along with the sub and mozzarella sticks. Looking forward to coming back

David Kelly

Just tried their pizza again 5-5-22 they just changed management but always loved rheie pizza before. Well the pizza used to be expensive and need more sauce in my opinion. Now it’s thin and cheap and I will not be buying it again went from a 4⭐️To a 2⭐️

Omar C.

I went to a ordination for a job and they brought pizza from paradise pizza the cheese pizza was on point the pepperoni was good

Jim smith

they were sold and went out of business

Load More