Mamma Mia is it.Kid-friendliness: Very friendly with children, even though small space
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark H.
Jeff's looked like a good option since I was on a business trip to Mansfield. Their menu is pretty extensive and they offer some really unique pies. I have to say, I had extremely high expectations for Jeff's. The place is a real neighborhood joint (big plus), it is spotless, great vibe, and a really engaging staff. I thoroughly enjoyed "talking pizza" with the counter guy. But my pizza fell short, but I think it is because I was influenced by the variety of pies. There was actually too many strong flavors that seemed to be in competition with each other. I say this with the knowledge that my preference for pizza is the simpler the better ... so this is clearly an individual preference. What I will say is that the equality of the ingredients was outstanding and the pie was cooked to perfection. So while I give this pizza a 4 star review, I will absolutely go back and order a pie that is more aligned with my preference (simpler). I have every confidence that rating will be different.
Deborah W.
I say the best pizza in Rhode Island is at Jeff's. I go and get the figgy piggy at least once a week. The crust is perfect
Keith S.
Top notch! It's not possible to give the title of best to any RI pizza place. There's too much variety, so it's an apples and oranges situation. That being said, this is among the best. The crust is amazing. I've had nearly every one of their pies, and they're all fantastic. I really like the fig pizza and the Dom. I don't know. It's pizza done right. Try it.
Justin hussey
Pizza was fantastic and very friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph E.
Not quite New Haven, but damn close! Absolutely loved it. I'd give it an 8.6. Tangy cheese/sauce and amazing crust. Well done.
J V
Not a Portnoy Stan...tried because of a recommendation from the guys at work. Great Pizza and Salad. Grab a pitcher of beer, a pie and some salad. You won't regret it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heather Beckler
Delicious pizza and friendly staff
Eric Collins
Delicious. If you haven’t been, make it a point to get here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon Mead
This is my absolute favorite Rhode Island pizza joint.
Can’t place a call on three different days. Won’t take online orders either.
Service: 1
Sarah Washington
Best pizza I ever had!My favorite was Parents favorite ADD the green hatch chiles thank me later!!!!!The truffle mushroom was very yummmmmm but didn’t really taste the truffle but still amazing either way!Figgy Pig really good just a tad too sweet.Pepperoni and cheese soooo good!Only problem is I just wish if they are busy maybe update Facebook stating no more orders for the night because we are sitting there calling over and over! Didn’t realize they did cut orders for the night called around 5 last Friday and called on and off for two hours! I was told they stopped orders! Just give us an update so we can go somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Walter N.
They seem proud of their dough, and rightfully so. It's one of the best crusts I've had. The Margarita was good. I'm a huge fan of Neapolitan 'pizza margherita' and New Haven 'tomato pie', and this perfectly checked off a bit in both boxes. My only complaints are that the basil is large leaf (has a dark clove flavor I'm not fond of) and they switched from pecorino to parmigiano. If it had pecorino and small leaves, it would have been an A++ for me. The Fungus Amungus had good flavors (the hot honey compliments the crust excellently). But for the price, the mushrooms seemed like cheap baby bellas (even though the website said wild mushrooms). All said, if you're hunting pizza in Rhode Island, Jeff's is a must try.
Michelle S.
Fresh and delicious pizza every time! Pizza wine is also a great pairing. My go-to pizzas are Figgy piggy, The Mamma Mia, and The "John belushi"
Sean H.
I rarely write reviews, but this place really deserves a five star rating. I'm a pizza snob from New York City and this place competes with the best of them. The crust is crispy, the sauce and cheese are perfect. The menu is simple and uncomplicated. A perfect pizzeria!
Mamma Mia is it.Kid-friendliness: Very friendly with children, even though small space
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff's looked like a good option since I was on a business trip to Mansfield. Their menu is pretty extensive and they offer some really unique pies. I have to say, I had extremely high expectations for Jeff's. The place is a real neighborhood joint (big plus), it is spotless, great vibe, and a really engaging staff. I thoroughly enjoyed "talking pizza" with the counter guy. But my pizza fell short, but I think it is because I was influenced by the variety of pies. There was actually too many strong flavors that seemed to be in competition with each other. I say this with the knowledge that my preference for pizza is the simpler the better ... so this is clearly an individual preference. What I will say is that the equality of the ingredients was outstanding and the pie was cooked to perfection. So while I give this pizza a 4 star review, I will absolutely go back and order a pie that is more aligned with my preference (simpler). I have every confidence that rating will be different.
I say the best pizza in Rhode Island is at Jeff's. I go and get the figgy piggy at least once a week. The crust is perfect
Top notch! It's not possible to give the title of best to any RI pizza place. There's too much variety, so it's an apples and oranges situation. That being said, this is among the best. The crust is amazing. I've had nearly every one of their pies, and they're all fantastic. I really like the fig pizza and the Dom. I don't know. It's pizza done right. Try it.
Pizza was fantastic and very friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not quite New Haven, but damn close! Absolutely loved it. I'd give it an 8.6. Tangy cheese/sauce and amazing crust. Well done.
Not a Portnoy Stan...tried because of a recommendation from the guys at work. Great Pizza and Salad. Grab a pitcher of beer, a pie and some salad. You won't regret it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza and friendly staff
Delicious. If you haven’t been, make it a point to get here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my absolute favorite Rhode Island pizza joint.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Dom, Brenton
Restaurantji Recommends
Can’t place a call on three different days. Won’t take online orders either.
Service: 1
Best pizza I ever had!My favorite was Parents favorite ADD the green hatch chiles thank me later!!!!!The truffle mushroom was very yummmmmm but didn’t really taste the truffle but still amazing either way!Figgy Pig really good just a tad too sweet.Pepperoni and cheese soooo good!Only problem is I just wish if they are busy maybe update Facebook stating no more orders for the night because we are sitting there calling over and over! Didn’t realize they did cut orders for the night called around 5 last Friday and called on and off for two hours! I was told they stopped orders! Just give us an update so we can go somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
They seem proud of their dough, and rightfully so. It's one of the best crusts I've had. The Margarita was good. I'm a huge fan of Neapolitan 'pizza margherita' and New Haven 'tomato pie', and this perfectly checked off a bit in both boxes. My only complaints are that the basil is large leaf (has a dark clove flavor I'm not fond of) and they switched from pecorino to parmigiano. If it had pecorino and small leaves, it would have been an A++ for me. The Fungus Amungus had good flavors (the hot honey compliments the crust excellently). But for the price, the mushrooms seemed like cheap baby bellas (even though the website said wild mushrooms). All said, if you're hunting pizza in Rhode Island, Jeff's is a must try.
Fresh and delicious pizza every time! Pizza wine is also a great pairing. My go-to pizzas are Figgy piggy, The Mamma Mia, and The "John belushi"
I rarely write reviews, but this place really deserves a five star rating. I'm a pizza snob from New York City and this place competes with the best of them. The crust is crispy, the sauce and cheese are perfect. The menu is simple and uncomplicated. A perfect pizzeria!