A very nice experience - a perfect combination of great food and great service, that is so difficult to get these days. Our server, Stacey (?) was fantastic, timely, and professional. The food & presentation was on point. We both had the Filet and it was perfection! Made for a truly fabulous experience. Thank you!
Scott
The restaurant to beautiful inside. The food was very good. The downside is we felt rushed from the time we sat down until the bill was presented. In and out in an hour. The service and meal delivery needs to slow down some so we could enjoy the cocktails, appetizers and then the main course.
Anne
This was our first time here . Our waitress , Carly , was phenomenal and our food was delicious . Plates are on the larger side though , very shareable ! Very nice experience overall . ( The only thing that was a tiny bit disappointing was the ladies room ... didn't match the ambience of the place ... no decor at all and paper towels all over the floor but was clean enough ...)
Kate Connolly
We absolutely love this place! The host did all she could to accommodate our party of 7 & we sat right away in the lounge. Stacy was our server & she was fantastic! The food was amazing - we will definitely be back on our next island trip! Highly recommend.
Best restaurant on Block Island. Thank you Yovanna for making sure the 10 of us got our reservation. Amazing staff. Outstanding food and ambiance. With live music outside
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa
The food and service were very good. It is nice to have a higher end restaurant on Block Island that has great food and delightful servers. We did find the menu to be limited a few nightly specials would be nice. We will definitely be returning on our next visit.
Jeffrey DeSocio
Amazing Swordfish!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Zena
Amazing food!! Our party loved everything including the impeccable service provided by Eli. Our table loved the Osso Buca, the Tuna Tataki and Lobster Mac & Cheese. Everything was superb.
Scallop appetizer and the crab crusted cod were amazing. The swordfish was worse than awful. Whoever plated it put the arugula salad with vinaigrette on top of the fish, plus there was a red sauce. Too many competing flavors. The salad and dressing shouldn't have been smothered over the fish but served on the side. My husband didn't eat, we just shared the cod.
Jason
We go to Winfields 4-5 times each summer. In prior years there would usually be at least one or two specials in addition to the regular menu. This year, we haven't seen one special. A high end restaurant should allow the chef to be creative use the bountiful seasonal produce and proteins available on the island. I get the sense they are acting like a factory this year and mechanically pumping out the same dishes each night. Kudos to the Atlantic Inn that has register specials and Eli's that frequently changes its menu. We definitely miss the former chef Burke.
Orson Glozheni
The food was excellent! The filet mignon was tender and cooked to perfection. The lobster mac and cheese will go down as the best we have ever had, and we've had a ton of lobster mac over the years. We decided to share the filet mignon so we could try other stuff too and the chef was nice enough to portion it out for two and it looked like a legit plate for both of us. It wouldn't have been a big deal to do it myself but the small details really matter. Another big plus here is the ambiance. The dining room is surrounded by beautiful art which makes for an exceptional dining experience. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Mac & Cheese, Roasted Garlic with Bread
TABB
Lobstah Mac and Cheese app was fabulous!!! I shied away from the seemingly spicier dishes, but they weren't hot... My daughter had a fish dish and said it was fabulous. I will try next time. However, my chicken was flavorful and not a disappointment. Will definitely return!!!
Has always been our go to favorite when on Island. What started with great service crashed quickly when our un/cuttable filet and broccolini arrived. Waitstaff never came back to check on us or quality of meals. Very disappointing.
Love the food, the ambiance, and excellent service! Always enjoy Winfield’s when we visit BI! ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Atlantic Swordfish, Roasted Garlic with Bread
The food was good. The fish was done perfectly. Our waitress was great and very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tuna Tartare Appetizer, Grilled Atlantic Swordfish
A very nice experience - a perfect combination of great food and great service, that is so difficult to get these days. Our server, Stacey (?) was fantastic, timely, and professional. The food & presentation was on point. We both had the Filet and it was perfection! Made for a truly fabulous experience. Thank you!
The restaurant to beautiful inside. The food was very good. The downside is we felt rushed from the time we sat down until the bill was presented. In and out in an hour. The service and meal delivery needs to slow down some so we could enjoy the cocktails, appetizers and then the main course.
This was our first time here . Our waitress , Carly , was phenomenal and our food was delicious . Plates are on the larger side though , very shareable ! Very nice experience overall . ( The only thing that was a tiny bit disappointing was the ladies room ... didn't match the ambience of the place ... no decor at all and paper towels all over the floor but was clean enough ...)
We absolutely love this place! The host did all she could to accommodate our party of 7 & we sat right away in the lounge. Stacy was our server & she was fantastic! The food was amazing - we will definitely be back on our next island trip! Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Seared Scallops, Cod Fish, Tuna Tartare Appetizer, Garlic Dipping Sauce, Lobster Mac & Cheese, Swordfish Entree, Roasted Garlic with Bread
Best restaurant on Block Island. Thank you Yovanna for making sure the 10 of us got our reservation. Amazing staff. Outstanding food and ambiance. With live music outside
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and service were very good. It is nice to have a higher end restaurant on Block Island that has great food and delightful servers. We did find the menu to be limited a few nightly specials would be nice. We will definitely be returning on our next visit.
Amazing Swordfish!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Amazing food!! Our party loved everything including the impeccable service provided by Eli. Our table loved the Osso Buca, the Tuna Tataki and Lobster Mac & Cheese. Everything was superb.
Restaurantji Recommends
Scallop appetizer and the crab crusted cod were amazing. The swordfish was worse than awful. Whoever plated it put the arugula salad with vinaigrette on top of the fish, plus there was a red sauce. Too many competing flavors. The salad and dressing shouldn't have been smothered over the fish but served on the side. My husband didn't eat, we just shared the cod.
We go to Winfields 4-5 times each summer. In prior years there would usually be at least one or two specials in addition to the regular menu. This year, we haven't seen one special. A high end restaurant should allow the chef to be creative use the bountiful seasonal produce and proteins available on the island. I get the sense they are acting like a factory this year and mechanically pumping out the same dishes each night. Kudos to the Atlantic Inn that has register specials and Eli's that frequently changes its menu. We definitely miss the former chef Burke.
The food was excellent! The filet mignon was tender and cooked to perfection. The lobster mac and cheese will go down as the best we have ever had, and we've had a ton of lobster mac over the years. We decided to share the filet mignon so we could try other stuff too and the chef was nice enough to portion it out for two and it looked like a legit plate for both of us. It wouldn't have been a big deal to do it myself but the small details really matter. Another big plus here is the ambiance. The dining room is surrounded by beautiful art which makes for an exceptional dining experience. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Mac & Cheese, Roasted Garlic with Bread
Lobstah Mac and Cheese app was fabulous!!! I shied away from the seemingly spicier dishes, but they weren't hot... My daughter had a fish dish and said it was fabulous. I will try next time. However, my chicken was flavorful and not a disappointment. Will definitely return!!!
Has always been our go to favorite when on Island. What started with great service crashed quickly when our un/cuttable filet and broccolini arrived. Waitstaff never came back to check on us or quality of meals. Very disappointing.
Loading...