Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches

Our family visit here for lunch, we had high expectations which fell short. My Providence Monthly barely had any chicken on it, my daughter’s David Cicilline had way too big of a bun/bread for the proportion of meat, they were out of certain breads, and the side pickles tasted sour.

Tried it a couple times now due to people saying it’s awesome, but I gotta disagree. Selling someone a Rueben with only two cold pieces of pastrami on soggy not toasted rye bread is way over the line.

I got the Providence Monthly sandwich and it was good until I bit into a bunch of sauce that was so gross I only got a few bites in and threw it away. Called to see what the sauce was and they said mayo, mustard, and horseradish 🤮🤮🤮 this should definitely be disclosed. So disappointing.

My family loves to come here. Amazing variety of sandwiches and the home made pickles are so good!! The owner is also so kind and friendly. Highly recommend!

Good. A lot of people for the lunchtime crowd. My family found their sandwiches to be pretty good. All of them got mushy and fell apart before we finished them.

I live in CT.
Have to get Geoff's whenever I come to Providence.
Awesome sandwiches!

Was told it was the best sandwich in Providence, did not disappoint

I went for the first time on 10/19. I was greeted by a very nice cashier with a big smile. She was very polite and helpful. The sandwiches were terrific!! The girls making them knew their stuff. I highly recommend Geoff’s

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Reuben, Pastrami, Pickle Pail

The half of the sandwich you guys filled was delicious! Times are too tight to walk out of sandwich shop almost 40 dollars lighter after tip(chips and drink) to get a half full sandwich.

Bread... Delicious. Atmosphere... Deli on the East side. Portions.... Highly disappointing,especially for the price. Can't say I'll come back anytime soon.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

This is the 2nd time in 2 days I have had a sandwich from Geoff's superlative sandwiches. Both sammies were delicious. The pickles are super flavorful-yum garlic. I appreciate the creativity in flavor. I do have a suggestion though-the frigid B would be over the top with some sage!!!!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Salad, Turkey, Pickles

This place has amazing food, so many sandwiches to choose from! Their staff is so friendly too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Providence Monthly

Superlative really is the word! The Jen and Berry sandwich is delicious and I always enjoy the pickles.

I’ve been visiting Geoffs for 15+ years and it’s always been my favorite sandwich shop. However, my more recent visits to Geoff’s were sub par and disappointing. One of my favorites is the Providence Monthly, overall quite simple ingredients, but the combination is delicious. Recently this sandwich has been disappointing… very little contents to sandwich leaving lots of dry bread, chicken is scarce and fatty, little avocado and cheese, and my last one had no special sauce at all. It was far from the Geoff’s quality I remember. I may give another try or two, but very unfortunate that such a great sandwich shop has gone downhill.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

place is nice but we ordered a j savage with no tomatoes. what we got was a slopfest with what tasted like a microwaved chicken slab and no buffalo at all, barely any bleu cheese. it was really horrible and costed about $13.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Got free food for wearing a Geoff’s shirt atmosphere was great service was amazing. The grilled cheese could have been better but overall great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5