Nicky's Pizzeria Five Points

Ordered a pizza 2 weeks ago. They messed up the order. went right back in to tell them that they have made my order wrong. The manager got an attitude with me. The remade the order or I thought they did. They gave me back the same pizza I gave them with the toppings picked off. They added a sprinkle more cheese and rebaked it. So this was a $24 rebaked pizza that had toppings on it that I don't eat that they just picked off. Would not recommend to anyone.

Never open when they say they are. Best pizza in town but doesn’t do any good if I can’t get it.

Wish they still had the lunch special...

Excellent.. closest to a N.Y. PIZZA down here.ate outside. Very friendly staff.. felt like I was back home at a N.Y. PIZZEria

Amazing food.. True Gyros. Highly recommend.. You won't be disappointed ??????

This is a great place for pizza.

Without a doubt the best restaurant in the state of South Carolina. Best pizza south of New Jersey.

Excellent. I am from NY. Others are excellent. Nikki's is worth the 20 mile drive for a slice.

I had a hankering for some NY pizza. It was perfect I was going to get more today, a full pie for my family, but they were closed on Monday

We always enjoy our Large Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza every Friday evening! Totally “New York style pizza” in our books. Haven’t found anything better for hundred of miles near.

Great pizza, Stromboli, and calzones. Have came here a few times. Customer service is awesome and the food is always top notch.

I have not even tasted the pizza yet and already disappointed. Please realize that I did not need to order from Nicky's so next time someone decides to spend money are your restaurant why don't you try Thank You instead of Yep. Cannot stand the use of that word or the fact that you don't feel customer service includes thank you.

I have been here in Columbia on and off for 6 months for work. Basically living in a long term residence hotel and some Airbnb spots. Nicky's was recommended by a local and I have returned perhaps a dozen time. Pizza is awesome. I especially like the antipasto salad. Fresh and large. Will continue to return although the work load is decreasing. NB: Social Distancing respected at this restaurant.

Great NYC style pizza however google maps had it labeled as open Tuesday 12/8/2020 open at 11:00 i was there at 11:20 it was closed, need to update times but great pizza!

I'm a recent transplant to the South and sampled half dozen pizza joints in Columbia. Nicky's in the best NYC style by far. Slices are huge, pepperoni has a nice spicy kick and the sauce complements the pie instead of overwhelming it or getting lost. I wish they carried wings. This will be my go-to pizza place.