Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

Unfortunately they are not generous with their toppings. A lg thick crust pizza 3topping pizza is $27 but it had too little of those toppings, 2 slices only had 1 piece of Pepperoni and 1 green olive on them(the olives weren't sliced so it looked like they were too lazy to slice them?)

Visiting from Texas on business. I must say I haven't had a pizza that tasty in a long time. The thin crust personal size pizza was amazing and cheesy. Very friendly staff and service.

The service was nice and the food was good.

The food was good, but the restaurant itself needs a little TLC. The restroom wasn't clean and the walls were beat senseless. We both got the threefer and the salads were good, I got the cheeseburger (ok) and my wife got the calzone. It came with dessert so we got a cookie and donut bites (which tasted a little stale, maybe they were previously frozen?) They were out of the beer I asked for first, but I loved their wide selection and a second choice was easy. Overall decent, but with as much competition in restaurants around the area there is, I wouldn't return. Corey was our server and he was fantastic.

Came last week health grade was a B, came back this week Health Grade DECREASED now a C. BEWARE!!

Food is great, but can we PLEASE get a real chicago style deep dish?

I’m from out of town and wanted pizza. This place was nearby. Of course I know ordering on the uber eats app the pricing is increased. But who in their right mind would have thought this is what you get for $38??? Never again!!! Take a look at the photos and tell me it’s worth the price.

Afternoon visit with party of eight. Server Ashley was attentive. Promptly taking orders. The kitchen had difficulties getting food out as it took three separate trips with 10 minutes waits between deliveries. Food was ok. Pizza dough undercooked. The restaurant needs some major cleaning. Floor covering throughout stained, dirty and needed swept.

I come here frequently with large groups of people I perform with in musicals in Columbia - they always take us, no matter how many, and the food’s pretty good!

Food was cold not enough sauce.this was horrible for a first time experience.id rather go to food lion and by a 3 pizza box of jacks pizza.they always say the same thing.sorry and give us a chance to get it right.No second chances, should have gotten right then.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pan Pizza

Amazing pizza! Everything we ate here was on point. The speed of service was a tad disappointing however.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Rolls, Pan Pizza

The pizza was great. Good selection of beers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

They're Greatttt, like tony the tiger would say!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

I feel so bad for the wait staff here. We've been to Old Chicago multiple times but recently it has gone significantly downhill because of the kitchen staff's incompetence. Waiting 50 minutes for 2 pizzas when there are about 5 or 6 tables in the restaurant is RIDICULOUS. You can see the frustration on the wait staffs faces and hear it when they keep coming to say the food should be out soon. Very apologetic and attentive but unfortunately at the mercy of the kitchen. Kitchen staff what are you doing? I don't know if this is a management or logistics issue, but you've lost us at this point. I'll just stay home and make pizza for much less...I suggest other people do the same.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

The food tasted good but the waiting time is very long, the place was empty and still the service was very slow

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2