Best NY Style pizza in Columbia. If you order the big roni expect it to be oily because.. pepperonis release a lot of oil… so, common sense. Regardless, my big roni was amazing, oily, but the crust held strong and there was no flop at all. This is the wife and I’s new GO-TO place for pizza.
Food: 5
Brittany Austin
This was the worst pizza ever. Even the kids refuse to eat it. Burned on the bottom so bad it leaves a nasty taste in your mouth. I will never again order from this establishment.this pizza went straight into the trash.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Denki Kaminari
really delicious food but prices are out of my paycheck
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Matthew Ross
I hate writing these reviews, but they're the ones making the food. Our first and last time trying Papa Tony's. No kid finished a slice and complained about the taste, then we flipped it over to see they were completely burned. Forty dollars for 2 large pizzas and one had to go in the trash while the other was ok at best. We won't be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Delvin Goodwin
Got my pizza and it wasn't cut into slices at all. Still good pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Jayne A
Wrote a very favorable review when Papa Tony's first opened and we were so hopeful that we had a great pizza joint so close to home. The mozzarella was whole milk and stringed when first out of the oven and toppings were top notch. Tonight, I would have never recognized this as the same pizza. Crust seemed from a box, toppings were scarce and the cheese had no flavor. We had three pieces left over from a medium pizza and they went into the garbage disposal instead of the refrigerator for breakfast. We were told it would be 20-25 minutes when ordering and it was 35 minutes. Previously, we ordered a "dry" crust, as we don't like the garlic butter on the bottom which makes it greasy, but the bottom was greasy when we received it that time. I called back and spoke with Elizabeth, one of the owners, to give her feedback about this and she wanted to argue that I should have ordered a "crispy" crust. Not good customer service, especially since she was such a great sales person when they first opened. Going to give Stoner's another try as he appreciates the business and strives to make everything right!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Cynthia Craig Simpson
Thank you for the awesome pizzas and salad to welcome our teachers back at Muller Road for another school year. The food was awesome but the professionalism of the owners were stellar. Everything was so smooth and executed perfectly. Please support this establishment not only for the great food but the owners definitely care about the community.
Patricia Thornton
Best pizza in Columbia Small family owned place Service is kinda slow but the results are worth it Give it a try
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
S T
The best pizza I have had since "Not Ray's" pizza in Brooklyn!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Papa T's Favorite Cheese Salad
Carl Hazel
First time there. Great pizza. I had the Papa Special.
Perhaps the "oiliest" pizza I have ever seen in my life. Reminds me of high school cafeteria pizza. The pie here was floppy and wet, absolutely dripping with oil.
We won't be ordering from here again.
Food: 2
Service: 4
Patrick Phillips
Only 2 visits first and last. The meatball sandwich was very soggy because it had been sitting around for my pizza was ready. I told the lady that, but she said it was still warm. Pizza was undercooked.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Brantley Davidson Smith
Loved having this great spot to bring my extended family to. Atmosphere was great, service was exceptional and pizza was delicious.
Angie Stone
If you've not given Papa Tony's Pizza a try...You must! From the service to the food, perfection!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mrs M
Really good pizza! Three of us each ordered a small size different toppings. All 3 arrived hot, tho at different times so that the first served was cold by the time the third came. That was a bummer. Crust was thin and crispy as we like it, very good sauce, generous toppings. Tea was sweet, cold and plentiful. Nice outdoor area, both on sidewalk and on new deck to side. Lots of parking in a big lot in back. It's nearly an hour drive for us so we won't be regulars but will try it again
Best NY Style pizza in Columbia. If you order the big roni expect it to be oily because.. pepperonis release a lot of oil… so, common sense. Regardless, my big roni was amazing, oily, but the crust held strong and there was no flop at all. This is the wife and I’s new GO-TO place for pizza.
Food: 5
This was the worst pizza ever. Even the kids refuse to eat it. Burned on the bottom so bad it leaves a nasty taste in your mouth. I will never again order from this establishment.this pizza went straight into the trash.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
really delicious food but prices are out of my paycheck
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
I hate writing these reviews, but they're the ones making the food. Our first and last time trying Papa Tony's. No kid finished a slice and complained about the taste, then we flipped it over to see they were completely burned. Forty dollars for 2 large pizzas and one had to go in the trash while the other was ok at best. We won't be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Got my pizza and it wasn't cut into slices at all. Still good pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 2
Wrote a very favorable review when Papa Tony's first opened and we were so hopeful that we had a great pizza joint so close to home. The mozzarella was whole milk and stringed when first out of the oven and toppings were top notch. Tonight, I would have never recognized this as the same pizza. Crust seemed from a box, toppings were scarce and the cheese had no flavor. We had three pieces left over from a medium pizza and they went into the garbage disposal instead of the refrigerator for breakfast. We were told it would be 20-25 minutes when ordering and it was 35 minutes. Previously, we ordered a "dry" crust, as we don't like the garlic butter on the bottom which makes it greasy, but the bottom was greasy when we received it that time. I called back and spoke with Elizabeth, one of the owners, to give her feedback about this and she wanted to argue that I should have ordered a "crispy" crust. Not good customer service, especially since she was such a great sales person when they first opened. Going to give Stoner's another try as he appreciates the business and strives to make everything right!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Thank you for the awesome pizzas and salad to welcome our teachers back at Muller Road for another school year. The food was awesome but the professionalism of the owners were stellar. Everything was so smooth and executed perfectly. Please support this establishment not only for the great food but the owners definitely care about the community.
Best pizza in Columbia Small family owned place Service is kinda slow but the results are worth it Give it a try
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
The best pizza I have had since "Not Ray's" pizza in Brooklyn!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Papa T's Favorite Cheese Salad
First time there. Great pizza. I had the Papa Special.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Perhaps the "oiliest" pizza I have ever seen in my life. Reminds me of high school cafeteria pizza. The pie here was floppy and wet, absolutely dripping with oil.
We won't be ordering from here again.
Food: 2
Service: 4
Only 2 visits first and last. The meatball sandwich was very soggy because it had been sitting around for my pizza was ready. I told the lady that, but she said it was still warm. Pizza was undercooked.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Loved having this great spot to bring my extended family to. Atmosphere was great, service was exceptional and pizza was delicious.
If you've not given Papa Tony's Pizza a try...You must! From the service to the food, perfection!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good pizza! Three of us each ordered a small size different toppings. All 3 arrived hot, tho at different times so that the first served was cold by the time the third came. That was a bummer. Crust was thin and crispy as we like it, very good sauce, generous toppings. Tea was sweet, cold and plentiful. Nice outdoor area, both on sidewalk and on new deck to side. Lots of parking in a big lot in back. It's nearly an hour drive for us so we won't be regulars but will try it again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Loading...