Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Greenville

Not open - hours need to be updated on Google

Great selections

Update hours online please. Super inconvenient to drive 20 minutes all to be here 2 minutes past closing ( 3pm on Saturday ) after calling and asking if you guys took Apple Pay, I told the employee I would be on my way and “see you soon” and was not notified of the store closing soon.

Update: Thanks so much for reaching out! I went by the store today and picked up my pies. I appreciate you so much. That is so beyond kind. 💓 pregnancy hormones have a way of making you sad when you don’t get pie when you feel like you need it in that moment! I cannot wait to go home and devour these amazing pies.

We had to go for PI day special. Service was amazing, and she patiently waited for us to choose! We tried the blueberry, hwy 41, apple, key lime, icebox lemon, and peanut butter. All were so so good and we each have our favorite!

I've only tried one pie so far, but I bought several and I will review again after I've tasted the others.
When I was young, my mom baked all kinds of pies for the 5 of us kids. In the summer, she would bake all manner of berry pies. My siblings and I would spend the morning picking berries in the berry patch behind our house and mom would bake a delicious pie for supper.
Later, she taught me how to make flaky pie crust and I started baking my own pies. The attached picture is one of my Cherry Cream pies. I consider myself to be a bit of a pie aficionado.
I was impressed with the variety of pies available, but noticed that none of them had pie crust tops. That's okay for some pies, but I like fruit pies made with a top crust. I tried their apple pie anyway, but I didn't care for the Cinnamon Streusel Topping. The pie filling was delicious (I detest store pies that are made with canned apple pie filling)

I can really only speak to the pie and service as my pie was picked up. I enjoy baking myself but my- the crust on the cherry pie, literally melts in your mouth! Absolutely divine. And the cherry filling is made with the best cherries I've ever had. This is clearly a freshly made filling. I am SO glad I bid on this item donated in a silent auction because I will be back!

We were very disappointed in the pecan chocolate chip pie. We cut it 2 days later for Thanksgiving and a knife wouldn’t cut through it! 😢 $35 for a pie 🥧 a knife 🔪 wouldn’t go through. 😢 We bought one 2 years ago and it was great! 😪

Very cute store. However, the pies are not great. They had very little filling in the mini pies most of which was crust. $30 dollars for four pies, I would have expected better pies.

I sent my son to pickup 2 pecan pies and neither was wrapped in clear wrap to prevent drying out! He wasn’t asked if the pies were going in the freezer either. The last ones I purchased were wrapped up. I sure hope they aren’t dry when we eat them.😢 I was also disappointed in the price! Paying $35 for a pie that is NOT any different from any other baker is ridiculous! I don’t think I will be coming back anytime soon. 😢🥧

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pecan Pie, 4 I-40

This is just the cutest clue shop in Greenville! I love the fact that everything is made fresh! I’m always seeking out homemade food in the area that’s non GMO so a place that makes their food there and fresh are qualities I’m looking for! Definitely stop by and check out their options for the holidays coming up!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

OMG!!!!!!!!! EVERYTHING I TASTED WAS DELIGHTFUL. There was a sample with coconut and chocolate, DELICIOUS!!!!!
The young lady was friendly and and helpful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I have to say I love this pie place. They make all the pies in house. We even got their mini pies for our wedding. I have tried most of their flavors, they are all wonderful in their own way. This time, we got my personal favorite, the chocolate chess pie for my birthday. Another bonus is they always have samples to taste.

Kid-friendliness: Always has samples to try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pecan Pie, Mini-Pies

Stopped by on a whim when we saw the sign. The shop is cute, and the service was good. It's a bit pricey for what you get. We bought 2 little pies, so $14'ish. We got an apple pie and a custard pie. The apple was apple. There was nothing spectacular about it, and it tasted like any apple pie you could get at a grocery store. It has a crumble top. I know taste is subjective, but at this price point, a lattice topping would really elevate it and make it more traditional, more esthetically pleasing, and worth the price they charge for full-sized pies. The custard pie tasted similar to a cheesecake. I wasn't a fan of the crust, which was so pale it blended with the custard. I felt like I was eating an undercooked crust.
All-and-all, this was a one and done for us. If you're adequate in the kitchen, you're better off baking your own pies.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Came over here with my wife. I had to drive her. So I was looking around to kill some time and spotted this place and decided to go in. OMG! Glad I did. The pies were outta this world. Will definitely be back and bringing people with us. Had the pie flight. It gives you samples of their best sellers. I’m sitting here now waiting on my wife and considering going back tonight. These definitely are somebody grandmas pies.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Peanut Butter Pie, Chocolate Silk Pie

We came to the butcher near by and saw this little place and thought, hey a good pie would go well with our steak. We ended up getting a chess pie. Don't get me wrong, the pie was good but it was not $35 good. I have had multiple $15 pies that were better than this $35. My main problem with this place is the pricing. I suggest avoiding if you don't have extra money to burn.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3