Pizza City New York Style

Came from TR to get my 2 slices n I couldn't believe it the crust was so hard I had to get a drink !! It was disappointing I couldn't even chew it!!!😤😤😤😤

Food: 1

Hands down the best pizza in the Greenville area. Service was excellent but the star of the show was the pizza. So so good! It won’t disappoint.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

We ordered a big delivery from Pizza City to celebrate our team’s birthdays this month, and it was perfect. The pizza was right on time, hot, and honestly some of the best I’ve had. The service was just as good—the kind where you can tell people truly care. What makes it even better is knowing Pizza City has been run by the same family for over 20+ years. We all know that kind of dedication isn’t easy, and you can feel it in the way they treat their customers and in the pizza's quality. Pizza City is a true must-try and I’d recommend it to anyone. 11/10 from me—thank you for making our team lunch special!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pizza was good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dam! This was some incredible pizza!! Locally owned and operated since 1977. Wish I was in the area more often. I like the fact that you can buy a whole pie or grab it by the slice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

$10 for 2 slices of plain pizza that are mid at best is robbery. They went so cheap on cheese that you could see the individual cheese shreds. The best pizza places in nyc charge $3 a slice. RIPOFF!!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

I ordered the lunch special; 2 single topping slices and a soda for $10. It was a great, affordable option. The slices were large and tasty. Staff were friendly. The ceiling tiles were painted by local children.

Pizza and salads are wonderful. The cheesesteak not so much. Will go back but not for cheesesteak.

I’ve been coming to Pizza City for around 7 or 8 years now, and I’ll always say this—it’s my favorite pizza in Greenville, hands down. I’ve tried just about every pizza spot in the area, but I keep coming back here because nothing else really compares.

The food is great—especially the lunch special with two cheese slices. I get it almost every time. It’s simple but perfect. Crispy crust, great flavor, always fresh. And one small thing I really like? They keep lemons by the drink station so I can throw some in my water. I love that.

But what really makes this place stand out is the owner, Richard. He’s been good to me since day one. Years ago, when I was in college, I stopped by but realized I’d left my debit card back at my dorm. I was about to leave, but Richard told me, “Just pay me next time.” That meant a lot to me at the time. I didn’t have much money, and he didn’t have to do that—but he did. That’s the kind of guy he is.

So yeah, Pizza City isn’t just good pizza—it’s a place with heart. I’ll always support them

This is dope . This is a jewel. I love the pizza , lots of different dishes. Go and see what you love

I ordered honey mustard wings regular and a small pizza sausage and pepperoni. My wife ordered hot wings extra crispy. When I got the honey mustard wings - they were fried extra crispy hard with honey mustard sauce watered down splashed all over them. I informed the waitress , she informed the manager, He came out told me , he can't fix another order to make it right , I can give you your money back. I came for wings not to get money back. Crust on Pizza hard , can't chew it. Far from N.Y. Don't go there. Very disappointed. Isn't the customer always right. Sucks 🤬😡

My choice was the Large, Sicilian, Square Pizza. It was 16 inches square, which gives 16 pieces of 4X4 inches. The crust was 1 inch thick, yeasty, sturdy, and crispy. I took most of mine home, wrapped them separately in parchment paper, and put in sandwich bags. The frozen ones stay crispy with air fryer, bake, 400 F for 10 minutes.

I will say that feeding more than 6 people here can get a bit pricey, but man is it good! 👍🏼
Best pizza 🍕 in Greenville that I have had so far. By far.

I don't think the subs were all that good here for the price. Don't get me wrong, it wasn't horrible, but just very basic and bland. They supplement the meat and cheese that should fill the sub with shredded lettuce. The Italian dressing was less than satisfactory as well. It was very oily with little to no taste.

Great staff. Best NY Pizza in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5