Benny Hudson Seafood

Excellent service and food was great! Drinks were great also! I’ll be back.

We arrived to a spacious parking lot, walked in to a very nice, comfortable ambiance, we then stepped outside to the back patio, and wow, what a beautiful view.
Buddington, our amazing server extraordinaire, was not only knowledgeable, he was funny, courteous, personable, listened to our request and attentive.

Now, to the food, very, very good and fresh. We had the raw oysters, garlic shrimp, beef carpaccio and the fried whole fish.

We will definitely come back again, and again...keep up the great work, food and service.

If you want fresh seafood for a reasonable price, this is the spot. The store has changed a lot (new building) since we last visited, but the same friendly service is still there. There is a huge variety of seafood available here, from local shrimp and fish to Maine lobster and whole octopus and everything in between. Personally I like the old spot better, but you have to adapt!

Drink served in a small glass and food was not good

Great food, drinks and Entertainment!!

Food was ok but service great. High ceilings do not bode well as hard to hear at your table even when not busy. Limited menu.

Fabulous food, views and service. A great addition to the Reilly family of restaraunts. The food was wonderful including the whole fried snapper I enjoyed. Do not pass on the desserts. They are wonderful

I’m not sure how this place gets anything but 5 stars across the board. Amazingly fresh seafood and the shrimp is some of the best I’ve ever had. Get it, take it home and you’ll have a great meal. Be simple with it because the fish and seafood is so fresh you want to just not mess it up. People are friendly and prices are reasonable for stuff this good. It’s not cheap definitely but the local seafood is second to none on the island

Market selection was nothing exceptional and the staff was particularly unhelpful and unfriendly. We will not be back.

Coastal inside, coastal out
Tasty treats and meals
Decent service, go enjoy...

Tried for the first time today for lunch, we ate outside among the breeze, phenomenal view and atmosphere. The food and drinks were amazing. The service was prompt, friendly and knowledgeable. I highly recommend it!

Beautiful new building! Once you’ve had their shrimp you’ll never have regular store bought “shrimp” again!!

Delicious food with a slightly Mideast flare. The couscous was delicious. Great views.

Gave our first visit with rough food and poor service a pass as it was within their first month. Tonight was one of the worst dinners I've ever had. Steak, chewy, no seasoning. Carrots raw, no seasoning. Demi bland. Scallops over cooked no seasoning. Chimichurii was saw dust and off putting. Farro dry and bland. Just an awful experience.

Arrived at 4:30 for dinner, they had 6 ladies up front as hosts and couldn’t fathom or figure out where to seat us even though 80% of the restaurants was open. We sat for 10 minutes and no one ever came to even take drink orders or greet us. We left.