Michael Anthony's Cucina Italiana
37 New Orleans Rd, Hilton Head Island
(843) 785-6272
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
The 3 of us went there 6/26/25 for dinner. We had a fantastic meal. I had the shrimp and scallop over risotto. It was the best I ever had. Perfectly prepared. My one friend had the lasagna which he raved about. The other friend had the bolognese which she said was excellent. Our sever was point one. Definitely worth the price.
Loved it. The Gnocchi wowed me.
Amazing Italian food - the locals have told us this is the place to go…and we can confirm! If you arrive at 4pm, there are unbelievable specials on wine!! and the Chicken Parmesan is delicious!
Grew up in HH. I only add that for context as I have been to many places on the island. My wife arranged a birthday get together here for me this past weekend. I have been to Micheal Anthony’s multiple times as it is my favorite restaurant on the island. We rented out the upstairs for the event. Let me be clear, as a group we were not easy to serve. 50 plus people with multiple kids running around. The catering team, Josh, and the servers truly did a fantastic job. Drinks were made quick and brought from downstairs up to my guests. Food was wonderful as always but came out hot with can be hard to do with that many people. The team navigated my group extremely well, remained patient with us, and all my guests enjoyed themselves. This made for a truly fantastic night. If you are considering an event or just want a nice dinner, this is the place to go.
Good! Very nice staff. Food good not great lovely atmosphere and good wine list
Atmosphere is very nice, service was great. Ordered veal scallopini which came with mashed potatoes. I requested a side of pasta in place of potatoes and was charged a ridiculous fee of $6.95. The scallopini was floating in sauce resembling a bowl of soup. Although it was covered in a soup like base it was dry. The prices they charge don’t reflect the quality of their food in my opinion. I don’t recommend.
We had a great experience. The food was delicious and tasty. All dishes we picked including dessert was fantastic. Sean seated us early for reservation. We got in a little earlier. Michelle was very accommodating. We loved her skill in pouring wine. Great place for romantic dinner.
Always a wonderful experience at MA.Cusine is fantastic, pasta dishes are incredible and service exceptional!
My husband and I were very disappointed with our meal at Michael Anthony's on Saturday night we have wanted to eat there for years! He never complains about his food but had the Ravioli with seafood and said it was gross and could not even taste the seafood! The dessert was also not worthy! When you pay $170 00 you want a meal that you can enjoy! We were so looking forward to nice romantic dinner ! We would not recommend eating at Michael Anthony's again!Sure hate that because we love Hilton Head Island!
Required to book party of 10 via phone, which I did at 1129am. Table of 10 at 5pm as we had a 2 year old in the group. No record of such a call so the manager sent us packing. Travel a lot with groups and it’s a first. And last.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great atmosphere. My seafood cannelloni was good but had to send it back because it was burnt covered with sauce. However, our server, Hunter, took great care to get it right, and he was very busy. Will be back. Thanks Hunter!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Excellent. We were very surprised! We expected highish prices with this being Hilton Head but the quality of the service, the food and the ambience by far exceeded my expectations.
A great night.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were recommended this restaurant for dinner. Great vibe, excellent servers. They made us feel so welcome. It was my husbands birthday and he really wanted the chicken parm. It wasn’t on the menu, but the Chef was kind enough to make it for him. Tiramisu was to die for. I had the stuffed chicken which was great. They made a penne pasta for my son to accommodate him as well. Great experience and vibe. Definitely coming back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food and great service. The pasta was clearly homemade and had great flavor. I got the sausage and mushroom gnocchi and it had a strong earthy flavor, very high quality italian.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The insalata fragole is delicious. The shrimp pasta dish is also fantastic. Great service as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...